T. Belman. Shalev reviews the attempt by the Peel commission in 1936 to solve the conflict between Jews and Arabs and compares their efforts to Trump’s efforts today. He writes “Israelis will then have to ask themselves whether they wish to live in a Jewish state that represses Palestinians on a permanent basis or in a democratic state that would inevitably precipitate civil war, as the Peel Commission envisioned. ”
“An irrepressible conflict has arisen between two national communities within the narrow bounds of one small country” the Commission’s summary states. “There is no common ground between them. Their national aspirations are incompatible. Neither of the two national ideals permits of combination in the service of a single State.”
This is what Martin Sherman keeps arguing but he offers a third option, namely compensated emigration whereas “Ze’ev Jabotinsky demanded, in fact, that Britain revoke the autonomy it had set up in Trans-Jordan, today’s Jordan, and earmark it forthwith for future Jewish settlement; the socialist left, meanwhile, decried the loss of a binational state based on complete equality and mutual respect.”
I might add that the Jordan Option that Zahran and I have been promoting effectively draws from Sherman and Jabotinsky.
The president’s recognition of Jerusalem was like the Balfour Declaration – a godsend for Jews but a knife in the back for Arabs
By Chemi Shalev, HAARETZ
The concept of dividing Palestine between Arabs and Jews was first presented formally in July 1937, by the British-appointed Peel Commission, charged with investigating the Great Arab Revolt that had broken out a year earlier. After hearing witnesses from both sides, the Commission asserted that the violent rebellion stemmed from the steadfast resistance of Palestinian Arabs to the establishment of a Jewish National Home, their fear that Jews would one day lord over them and their suspicion that this is exactly where the British Mandate was heading. The 400-page report is riveting, especially today, when Palestinians once again feel betrayed and the report’s brainchild, the two-state solution, is slowly dying. Read more…