Israpundit is entirely dependent on readers support. Please help me continue educating people with the truth about what is going on in Israel and around the world.
Israpundit is entirely dependent on readers support. Please help me continue educating people with the truth about what is going on in Israel and around the world.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
@ yamit82: There is no question that some nations have achieved more in terms of industrial production, medical breakthroughs, and improvements in the standard of living and quality of life for their peoples, than have others. But I think that cultural differences, and even to a limited extent the different natural environments of diiferent countries, is the major cause of these different performances, not genetics.
Continue article at http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/culture/features/1478/index1.html
https://www.haaretz.com/what-makes-jews-so-smart-1.5316148
YAMIT– I have both “A Treasury of Jewish Folklore” and “A Treasury of Jewish Humour” by Nathan Ausubel, and in the first especially, there are many stories about Torah scholars being sought after for sons-in-law. How their “living” would be apportioned out amongst the whole village, one here giving breakfast, another giving dinner, another giving a place to sleep (often just a plank of wood), another to mend his coat another his shoes, pants, etc. and the whole village would rotate in turn. And I have other sources that are similar…. so I DO know…
By the way those books above are wonderful to read. Really “Treasuries”….
@ yamit82:
Yes Yamit, I know about the first part, in fact my maternal grandparents were first cousins..from Akmene, Lithuania. We “Irished” it into “Ack-me-anne” (my dear late father’s family was from across the River in Latvia, a town (3/4 Yidden) called in Yiddish, “Nyrea or Nyra” also called “Friedrichstadt” and today, Jaunjelgava.
(Maybe that’s how I got my brilliant mind …???!!)
Perhaps you are also right about the mind dissipation of the past 100 years. Very much like the theory that since Jews brought social conscience into the world, and caused preservation of lives which otherwise would have “gone under”, and aided by medical discoveries, saving those who otherwise would have been “weeded out” allowing them to breed, and bear sub intelligent beings, who themselves were allowed to breed…. et cetera..et cetera etc.
Another theory is that since man began to live in settlements, and later, to read, his long distance sight which had always warned him against danger in the open field looming, gradually became lost, and the weaker humans who were not “out and about” anyway, survived.. That they bred fewer and fewer normals but more and more sub-normals… Just a theory as is the other, but there’s SOME sense in each.
Eugenics a la carte….
Edgar G. Said:
LOL
Edgar G. Said:
Genetics… Jews were for most of their history small populations self-exiled or ghettoized in their host countries so a lot of inbreeding first and 2nd cousins, Marriages were arranged were most sought after spouse for women were rabbinic scholars. Usually, daughters of learned scholars have arranged marriages with young rabbinic scholars. One can see where the highly developed IQ’s of some Jews came from. Lack of intermarriage insured this trend among Jews until about 100 years ago where Western Jews freed from their ghettos and massive assimilation will shortly reverse the high degree of Jewish IQ developed over nearly 2 millennia.
Jewish DNA – Genetic Research and The Origins of the Jewish People
@ yamit82:
That last part of your highlight excerpt from one of your specialty “links”….surely that was “Muhammed Ibn McCoy..(maybe McCarthy.).al Chazerim”
@ yamit82:
As I said elsewhere above… Arabs invented Airliner Hi-Jacking. They are also the world’s greatest thieves.
@ adamdalgliesh:
Adam you’re dragging “red herrings” all across the “scent”….. There s NO denying that the Jews…..0.2% of the world’s population, have won 23% of all Nobel Prizes in the sciences, philosophy, literature etc. regimens that the World consider as pre-eminent for human advancement.
{ And, as I remarked to you regarding another of your posts, perhaps the higher intelligence of the Jews in Israel (and elsewhere) which you specifically chose as the area, leans towards making them good lawyers, and not good leaders…
Got to be genetics first…. environment, somewhere after that. Having the environment and not the genetics doesn’t seem to work en masse. I’m referring to the fact that there are exceptions everywhere….but who knows how far back in their family history they may have had a Jewish “lodger”……
You keep trying HARD to be as Politically Correct as it’s inventor. (maybe also a Jew)
You lean over backwards to dredge out those studies that show Jews are not any more intellgent than blacks.
@ yamit82:
When the Greeks discovered the Yahud, they described them as “a nation of philosophers”…Also from around the late 1st Cent. BCE onward, Goyim became very interested in the ethical content of Torah Judaism, and crowded into the synagogues everywhere. They were Torah believers…. There were numerous discourses by the Sages and later rabbinic discussions about them, and it was decided that they were NOT Jews but because the observed the Noachide Laws, they also were not Goyim. The called them “G-d Fearers/G-D Lovers”.. So Jews DID contribute Social morality to the ancient world, (which stopped leaving unwanted babies on hillsides to be eaten by wolves etc) and much more that there is no point in going into now. I’m not about to be dragged into an argument with anybody who has discovered a “favourable link” on Wikipaedia.
By the way the Arabs DID invent something…..Airliner hi-jacking”……..!!
Also they invented “Muhammed’….according to the archaeologists who worked kn the Mecca area for years, and who denied that there was ever any historical time when Mecca existed as described in Arab “traditional” accounts nor in the Koran.
@ adamdalgliesh:
Perhaps their extra intelligence leads them to become excellent lawyers and not suited to be “leaders”….
@ adamdalgliesh:
Arabs were not inventive they stole from everyone….
@ yamit82:
@ adamdalgliesh:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algebra#History
@ adamdalgliesh:
I think wiki…
@ yamit82: Source for quotation, Yamit?
@ adamdalgliesh:
Scientific Proof of God
Genesis & The Big Bang Theory
@ adamdalgliesh:
adamdalgliesh Said:
You recognize hypothesis, assumptions, and theory ….Until about 50 years ago science ( over 90% of all scientists and philosophers) assumed since Aristotle the universe was eternal with no beginning. We have since the echo of the Big bang proving the universe had a beginning. Darwin has been mostly debunked. Almost daily some accepted scientific fact assumptions have been proven fallacious.
Curious that no 2 philosophers ever agree with another. Proving the human mind cannot be depended upon.
@ yamit82: It is an important point that the contributions of various peoples to “civilization” and progress in science and technology varies widely in different times periods, depending on that countries political and miitary situation, economy, cultural values, and even climate. Thus the Greek contribution to civilization largely ended with the conquest of the Greek city states, first by Macedon, then Rome, then Byzantium, then by the Crusaders ,and finally be the Turks. The Greeks needed military, political and economic power before thay could contribute much to the growth of civilization. The same was true of the Dutch, the English, the Germans, the Russians, and yes, the Swedes in later times. And let’s not forget that “civilized” values can be abandoned at the drop of a pin by supposedly “advanced,” sophistoicated nations, such as Germany 1933-45, when the country reverted completely to the vallues of its pre-Christian, barbarian past, and did so proudly and openly.
@ yamit82:
Oh my gosh! To th extent that this is true, it makes “science” a joke. Most genuine scientists, at least in the natural sciences do not not accept generalizations based on lack of evidence as valid. Only generalizations based on a great deal of accumulated evidence are accepted as facts-such as experiments that are replicated over and over again with the same results. Other proposed generalizations are regarded only as “hypotheses,” or “conjectures.”
It is not strictly true that the Arabs invented nothing of value, because they developed Algebra (derived from an Arabic word) and Arabic numbers, and made discoveries in astronomy. In the early Arab period, there were also sophisticated philosophers, such as Ibn Rushd (Averoes in Latin) who made towards the development of a rational method for acquiring knowledge. Ibn Rushd influenced both Maimonides and Thomas Aquinas, who was the first Christian rationalist philosopher.
It is interesting, however, that IBn Rushd’s writings were preserved only in Hebrew and Latin translations, while all copies of his original Arabic work were burned on orders from fundamentalist Arab rulers who regarded them as heresy. It was only when rationalist works of philosophy were banned throughout the Arab world and the mystical philosophy of al_Gazali, who maintained that everrything that happened in the world was the Will of God, and that humans could do nothing to change His Will, that the decline of Arab civilization began in earnest (approximately 13th century). It has been declining ever since then. This is all documented in a book called “The closing of the Arab mind.” I can’t remember the author’s name. It demonstrates that it is the values and ideology that prevails in a certain culture, not genetics, that determines if a people make contributions to civilization or not.
The Steve King saga reveals how political damaging and self-isolating it is to show any sympathy with “white supremacy” or “white nationalism.” It alienates aven the main stream Right in the U>S. What possible purpose could be served by Israpundit publishing aerticles that appear to support this idea? This from Fox News two days ago:
@ yamit82:
Meatball in cream gravy and Ikea
yamit82 Said:
You call fermented canned herring nothing
Trying to curry favor with rest of the world, assimilated Jews brag about Jewish achievements that benefited others. That is nonsense. Classical Roman authors disparaged Jews for being useless citizens of the world. Despite the idea that “Plato is nothing but Moses speaking Greek,” realistically Jewish input toward the ancient world’s knowledge in next to nil.
In the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, only baptized Jews exerted appreciable influence on gentile thought. In our times, the scores of scientists and artists of Jewish origin are not Jews to practical purposes: they do not lead Jewish lives and their grandchildren are usually not Jewish. The wave of Jewish participation in science and art declines as the developing nations increase their share.
Most nations have proved intellectually futile on a grand scale. Latin Americans, Ukrainians, and Swedes have introduced very little knowledge to the world’s pool. Germany, the model of intellectual activity, seethed with it for only about a century. Ancient Rome and modern Britain were intellectually active for two or three centuries, and Ancient Greece for just a bit longer.
Jews enjoyed their religion and themselves while the ancient authors derided them for intellectual emptiness, as having given nothing to the world. And why should we? We owe the world nothing. Our fiduciary obligation is to God, rather than to other nations. We lead the way of life he prescribed. Incidentally, that’s also the most ethical and politically sensible mode of living, and it offers a fine example to the rest of the world. But we’re equally proud of what they see as barbarisms: exterminating the Amalek, the mass murder of Jew-haters in the Persian Empire after Purim, conquering Canaan, bringing the foul-smelling sacrifices in the Temple, and meticulously observing Sabbath.
We need not prove ourselves before the world, but before its maker.
@ adamdalgliesh:
The equality of people is no more proven than their inequality. It is socially acceptable to detrimentally generalize about mothers-in-law or to dislike one’s neighbors. It’s okay to discuss the varying intelligence of various breeds of dogs, or to assert that one person is smarter than another. Leftists decry applying that reasoning to nations for a single reason: leftists’ pet groups are always deficient. Leftists find it hard to claim to represent, say, Americans, but position themselves as the heralds of primitive peoples, such as Africans or Arabs.
Cats are less intellectually advanced than humans, but humans don’t kill cats for that reason. Human beings evolve; modern humans are definitely smarter than Neanderthals. The West and the Middle East evolved differently; Westerners statistically have achieved better than Arabs throughout history. Could all the previous generations have been wrong? Can we imagine that no Arab throughout history was sufficiently educated to come up with a major invention?
Rational recognition of the statistically different achievements of nations is not the same racism as lynching. Passive dislike doesn’t equal hatred, and surely not actionable hatred. Thoughts are not deeds; Jesus was wrong to equate lust with adultery. Leftists sophistically widen the meaning of racism to accuse the detractors of their pet nations of immorality. By the current standard of racism, books written before the 1960s are generally racist, and the leftists have already censored The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. Arabs exploit popular unwillingness to assert their intellectual inferiority.
Generalization about Arab intellect is presumed immoral, but leftists generalize the other way in presuming Arabs to be good and smart. Generalization and arguing from absence of evidence are accepted scientific methods. We don’t care that the Arabs could have achieved decent intellectual results if they had been forced to attend universities from seventh century onwards; absent positive evidence of their achievements, it is logical to presume them stupid.
Groups, including nations, are different from each other. Their competition fosters social evolution and progress. In the process, some groups die out. Oil purchases artificially keep the Arab hordes alive.
Nobel Prize Winning DNA Pioneer Stripped of Titles After Sharing His Views on IQ and Race
Distinguished scientist and Nobel Prize winner James Watson was stripped of several honorary titles after suggesting our genetic makeup cause differences in IQ tests
Watson’s Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory stripped him of his titles following his comments.
Evidently, acknowledging racial differences in IQ scores is now forbidden — even from one of the greatest scientists of our time.
Watson’s laboratory condemns the misuse of science to justify prejudice.
CNN reported:
A Nobel Prize-winning American scientist who co-discovered DNA has been stripped of his honorary titles at the laboratory he once led after repeating racist comments in a documentary.
James Watson, who discovered the double-helix structure of DNA alongside Francis Crick in the 1950s based on the work of British chemist Rosalind Franklin, said in a PBS film that genes cause a difference in intelligence between white and black people in IQ tests.
The 90-year-old’s comments were labeled “reprehensible” by the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (CSHL) on New York’s Long Island, where Watson had been the director from 1968 to 1993.
The laboratory said it “unequivocally rejects the unsubstantiated and reckless personal opinions Dr. James D. Watson expressed,” noting the statements were “reprehensible [and] unsupported by science.”
James Watson DNA pioneer – honours stripped – fall from grace (USA) – Sky News – 13th January 2019
adamdalgliesh Said:
Einstein was a political idiot
@ adamdalgliesh:
interesting thought. lots of evidence of Neanderthals thu out the ME and Mediterranean
.
@ honeybee: Good point.
@ honeybee:
Another good point. Also, geneticists have determined that Europeans and Asians are 3 per cent of Neanderthal descent, which Africans have no Neanderthal descent. Did that 3 per cent Neanderthal descent make Europeans and Asians more intelligent than Africans?
@ Edgar G.: I find it very difficult to believe that Jews have a higher genetic intelligence than other people, given the moronic nature of Israel’s political leadership ad rulimg clas of lawyer-bureaucrats. More intelligent people would elect more intelligent leaders, and would not allow a non-elected, self-appointed clique to govern them
@ Ted Belman: Ted, you haven’t republished any articles by the numerous scientists who have expressed doubts as to whether there is a correlation between intelligence and race. On this basis I suspect that you do have an “ulterior motive,” which is sympathy for the white nationalist movement. They are the political force that drives provide writers like Peterson with an audience for thie views.
For many reasons, the white nationalist movement is bad news for the Jews. For one thing. most of them (although not Peterson personally) are antisemites. Second, these views alienate nearly all “people of color” and their white sympathizers. Identying Israeli interests with white nationalism makes a lot of enemies unnecessarily, and will turn many people away from Israpundit, and maybe even Israel, if they assume your views are common in Israel (they are not).
Although some deny it, political intelligence, aka sechel, is a real phenomena. For a pro-Israel publication to even give the appearance of endorsing white nationalism shows no sechel.
@ jaywhite39:The major supporters of the intelligence and race correlation are the pschologists who administer and devise these tests. They have an obvious vested interest in finding these tests to be correct.
It is dubious whether pschologists can be considered scientists. They have no background whatsoever in genetics and human biology, which are the only sciences that can discover whether their is a link between genetically inherited intelligence and race. I have known a lot of psychologists. Each one has his own coxamamie theory to explain human behavior. Many are influenced by “New Age” religious ideas. Their judgment in scientific matters is not to be relied upon.
Nearly all geneticists and biologists who have investigated this question have found no scientific evidence of a link between race and intelligence. They have not even been able to identify what gnomes are related to intelligence, let alone detrmine the distribution of these gnomes in different racial or ethnic groups. They also have determined that the usual social definitions of “race” do not correspondend to the actual groups with a common descent. Africans, for example, can be divided into several different “races” that have had little genetic contact with each other. And a large part of the earh’s population consists of people of mixed racial origins. All this means that it has not been possible to determine a genetic basis for different IQ test scores by different groups.
You obviously have a polical agent behind your “scientific” conclusions–your belief that you have been discriminated against because you are a white man. This is a political opinion, not “science” as you claim.
@ nerett0: Some comparative studies of black and white children raised in similar environments have found no signiciant differences in their IQ scores.
@ nerett0: The argument by “emet” is called into question, however, by the fact that many genetic researchers think a correlation between race and genetically inherited intelligence is unlikely.This from Wikipedia:
@ honeybee:
Seemingly not…look how un-elected pinheads are able to run (ruin) Israel…. And found new political parties that won’t even pass the former threshold of 1.8%…like Ya’Alon….!!
Remember what Churchill said (the cause of so many millions of Jewish deaths in WW2-but he had a caustic-witty side too) when he was walking around with the Director of Bletchley Park and eyeing the sometimes strange looking people that were wandering around…. “I know I told you to leave no stone unturned…but I didn’t expect you to take me so literally…”.
P.S. ***look up “Bletchley Park”…***
@ Edgar G.:
-So size doesn’t matter!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@ honeybee:
Here is a riddle wrapped up in an enigma for you……..An’ don’ say I nivver give you nuttin’….. Archaeologists and scientists say the the Neanderthal brain cavity was rather larger than that of Homo Sapiens….
Edgar G. Said:
you done got that right, Cowboy !!!!!!!!!!!
@ yamit82:
Yes, again you are correct…. they compose the Israel bureaucracy and the Jewish Arab lovers. Also the American Liberal Jews. All can trace their origin back to Chelm…..
jaywhite39 Said:
You are kidding, of course
@ yamit82:
So size matters when come to brains or does brain matter, matter.
At the top of the Bell Curve Jews may have a disproportionate # of geniuses but there is also a disproportionate # if morons at the bottom or tail.
@ adamdalgliesh:
Science cannot be racist. Mean differences in IQ among different racial and ethnic group are pure science, not theory. Ignoring the science of intelligence allows Blacks and other minorities to falsely claim they are victims of discrimination if their percentage of Ivy League students, MDs,university professors, doesn’t equal their percentage of the population it is proof of racial discrimination termed “desperate impact”. In the USA, this anti-white discrimination exists for any government job and almost every full time desirable job. There is a whole industry and areas of state and Federal government devoted solely to promoting anti-white discrimination. The science of intelligence recognizes all groups have a percentage of geniuses.Peterson gives good reasons why IQ differences must be recognized. He gives reasons for Jews in particular, to recognize this when antisemites say Jews are over represented in top positions as if they have stolen them from non Jews. “Political intelligence” is an absurd concept. Higher mean IQ in whites and even higher mean IQ in Ashkenazi Jews are not theories. “Political intelligence” is another term for spineless ass-kissing.
There is no such thing as political intelligence. Your assertion that this non existent alleged form of intelligence is more important IQ is absurd. Spineless fear of offending blacks is the primary reason an awful anti-Semitic, white hating traitor like Obama, could become President of the USA. Obama wasted more than several trillion dollars and accomplished absolutely nothing. He regards his major achievement as the Iran deal, which, of course greatly helps them obtain nuclear weapons faster and his gift of $50 billion which they can use fund Hezbollah, Hamas, murder Jews all over the world and develop their missile programs more rapidly.
@ adamdalgliesh:
I happen to be fascinated by the issue and enjoy hearing different viewpoints. No ulterior motive.
I understand your argument but in Judaism EMET is especially privileged and we ignore it at our peril.
I am utterly baffled by why Ted would push this extremely unpopular cause in a web site devoted to promoting Israeli interests. The idea that blacks are biologically less intelligent than whites is “as popular as Hitler,” and associated in the popular mind with Nazis, the Ku Klux KLan, and Hitler. Both the left and the mainstream right view that doctrine in this light.
It is true that much of the leadership class among black Americans are antisemites. But not all black Americans are antisemites. Neither are all liberal=minded whites. Why go out of your way to alienate all of them?
Political intelligence, the ability to size what issues or opinions have political traction is far more important in politics than inherited genetic intelligence. And frankly, pushing theories of innate white intellectual superiority over blacks gives a political intelligence score of zero. Absolutely no sechel. A “Chelmite” level of common sense.