Harry Liberman
Click Image to Enlarge. Image created via AI.
A fictional account : What would Benjamin Franklin opine on the state of the Union in 2026 …..
By B. Franklin, Late of Philadelphia
My Dear Countrymen,
Roused once more from my quiet rest in Philadelphia, I find my spectacles trained upon a modern dispute that strikes at the very heart of our constitutional compact. When Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed recently declared Michigan to be the “capital of Arab America” The National News Desk, he employed a phrase that violates the foundational principle of this Union. In the United States of America, no state is an Arab state, a European state, or an enclave of any foreign region. Every state in this republic is singularly, indivisibly, and exclusively an American state.
Let me be crystal clear on a point of constitutional truth: a citizen’s color, creed, ancestry, or religion is never antithetical to America, so long as the U.S. Constitution is upheld above all else. Indeed, our Founders explicitly rejected Old World prejudices and spoke with profound respect for the ancient traditions that shaped our moral laws.
In 1790, President George Washington famously wrote to the Hebrew Congregation in Newport, praising the “Children of the Stock of Abraham”—whose ancient heritage gave the world the foundational principles of moral law and monotheism—and pledging that the American government gives “to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance.”
Domestic Civic Petition vs. Foreign Sovereign Interference
In your modern political discourse, many confuse the constitutional right of American citizens to petition their government with the unlawful intrusion of foreign powers. Look at how some critics falsely portray the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) as a foreign agent, when in truth it is an entirely domestic American civic organization funded by American citizens—and thus distinct from entities registered under the Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA). Indeed, the broader pro-Israel movement in America is anchored by millions of American citizens across faiths, including Christians United for Israel (CUFI), a majority-Christian grassroots coalition whose membership alone outnumbers the entire Jewish population of the United States. Citizens exercising their First Amendment right to advocate for alliances that reflect American values is the very essence of self-government.
Contrast that lawful domestic advocacy with the documented intrusion of actual foreign governments into your institutions.
As congressional inquiries and reports from the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP) and the Jewish Institute for National Security of America (JINSA) have revealed, foreign states such as Qatar have poured billions of dollars into American universities, think tanks, and lobbying operations—often under-reported and structured to buy institutional influence, shape curricula, and advance foreign state interests on American soil. When foreign regimes use sovereign wealth to compromise American academic freedom and civic institutions, that is a direct encroachment upon American sovereignty.
Protected Peoples, Open Ideologies, and the First Amendment
Your own Supreme Court affirmed the vital distinction between protecting human beings and debating ideas. In the landmark 1987 ruling Shaare Tefila Congregation v. Cobb, the Court unanimously held that Jewish Americans constitute a distinct ethnic and ancestral people protected from racial discrimination and violence under federal civil rights law. Conversely, under the First Amendment, no political, religious, or social ideology in America is ever immune from scrutiny, debate, or criticism.
Yet across your campuses and city streets today, foreign political crusades and “Free Palestine” encampments are treated as replacements for American civic duty—a foreign cause that is not American in origin or allegiance. As documented in the ADL Campus Antisemitism Report Card and ongoing U.S. Department of Education Title VI investigations, we witness an inversion of constitutional liberty: Jewish citizens have been harassed, intimidated, and physically violated by mobs who trample upon the true meaning of the First Amendment—confusing the right of peaceful speech with unlawful coercion, vandalism, and the suppression of others’ rights. Free expression protects vigorous debate over ideas; it never grants license to assault a protected people or silence fellow citizens.
Moral Clarity on Self-Defense and Human Bondage
Every sovereign nation possesses an inherent, unalienable right to self-defense against aggression—a truth we asserted in 1776 and which remains the bedrock of international law today. When evaluating those entrusted with high office, citizens rightly demand moral clarity regarding adversaries who openly chant “Death to America.”
During his Senate campaign, Mr. El-Sayed drew sharp scrutiny from foreign policy observers and columnists over his stances on the conflict with Iran, opposing U.S. military action against Tehran and calling to end American military aid to democratic allies such as Israel The Jerusalem Post / JCPA. A republic cannot afford ambiguity toward regimes whose rulers openly declare enmity against the United States and sponsor terror across the globe.
Furthermore, we must never lose sight of the hard-won moral triumphs that define Western constitutional civilization.
America fought a terrible Civil War and ratified the Thirteenth Amendment to abolish the stain of human bondage from our soil, and later secured the equal civil and voting rights of women under the Nineteenth Amendment. Contrast that constitutional achievement with nations across the Middle East and North Africa—including Qatar, Sudan, the United Arab Emirates, and Libya—where modern slavery, forced labor, and human trafficking remain documented realities Walk Free Global Slavery Index, and where women are frequently denied the legal equality guaranteed to every American daughter. Those practices are wholly antithetical to the American creed, and we must never trade our hard-earned standards of universal human dignity for cultural relativism.
The Establishment Clause and the Public Square
When we ratified the First Amendment, we also established a vital safeguard against religious establishment: Congress—and by extension, state and municipal authorities—shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, nor prohibiting the free exercise thereof. We had witnessed the ruin of Old World nations where civic power was used to elevate one faith over the public square.
Look now at the fierce debates unfolding in New York City surrounding Mayor Zohran Mamdani, amplified calls to prayer across city neighborhoods, and viral controversies over public religious broadcasts in Times Square. While the Constitution fiercely protects every citizen’s right to worship freely in private and in their houses of assembly, using the instruments of municipal government or turning the shared civic commons into a stage for sectarian dominance tests the delicate balance of the Establishment Clause.
Escaping Old World Tyranny and Heeding Europe’s Warning
The earliest settlers who crossed the perilous Atlantic did so to escape the suffocating grip of Old World monarchies, state-enforced orthodoxies, and top-down collectivist systems that subordinated the individual to the crown or the state. Look even today at modern Europe—where recurring civil unrest, riots in cities like Paris, heavy state centralization, and failed integration policies have strained social cohesion to the breaking point. We built the American Republic upon a radically different premise: that liberty belongs to the individual citizen, bound not by tribal or foreign allegiance, but by a shared devotion to the Constitution.
When an official takes the Oath of Office, they swear to support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic, and to represent the whole people of an American state.
Sovereignty Forged on the Shores of Tripoli
In the infancy of our Republic, we learned firsthand what happens when a nation fails to assert its sovereign independence. During the Barbary Wars, North African corsairs seized American merchant vessels and enslaved American sailors, demanding tribute from a young nation that lacked the naval might to defend itself. Rather than submit to foreign extortion, President George Washington signed the Naval Act of 1794, establishing the United States Navy, and President Thomas Jefferson dispatched our fledgling fleet across the Atlantic.
The courage of those early sailors and Marines—immortalized in the Marines’ Hymn with the immortal words “to the shores of Tripoli”—established a permanent truth: America pays tribute to no foreign power and carves out no exceptions to its sovereignty.
Vigilance Against Division and Extremism
Across the centuries since, whenever foreign ideological conflicts or violent extremism have breached our shores, they have tested our national resolve. We saw it in the 1968 assassination of Senator Robert F. Kennedy in Los Angeles, when Middle Eastern political violence claimed the life of an American leader. We saw it on a catastrophic scale on September 11, 2001, when extremist hijackers destroyed the World Trade Center and struck the Pentagon, murdering nearly three thousand souls in a direct assault on our way of life.
That vigilance is precisely why our legal and security institutions must never turn a blind eye to organizations with documented ties to extremism. During the 2007–2008 Holy Land Foundation terrorism financing prosecution—the largest such case in American history—federal prosecutors named the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) as an unindicted co-conspirator, and a federal court subsequently upheld the listing after finding ample evidence of associations with Hamas.
The True American Creed: Content of Character
If modern leaders wish to understand how a diverse nation remains one people, they should turn not to divisive ethnic labels, but to the words of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Standing before the Lincoln Memorial in 1963, Dr. King called upon America to fulfill the “promissory note” of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence. He did not seek to balkanize the states into competing ethnic capitals; rather, he envisioned a unified nation where citizens are judged not by the color of their skin or their ancestral origin, but by the content of their character.
That is the enduring genius of E Pluribus Unum—Out of Many, One. Every individual citizen—regardless of color, creed, or faith—enjoys the full protection of our Bill of Rights, provided they uphold the constitutional principles that make liberty possible.
Yet in the public square, under the flag of the United States, there are no hyphenated states and no state-sponsored pulpits.
Michigan, New York, Pennsylvania, and every star upon our banner belong wholly and forever to the American Republic.
I remain, your obedient servant,
B. Franklin
Benjamin Franklin was born on January 17, 1706 (January 6, 1705, Old Style), and died on April 17, 1790.
His given name, Benjamin, is rooted in Hebrew tradition (Binyamin, meaning “son of the right hand”) , stemming from the biblical patriarch Jacob’s youngest son and the founder of one of the Twelve Tribes of Israel—a name frequently chosen by early Puritan families in colonial New England who drew deep inspiration from the Hebrew Bible.
If Benjamin Franklin were to visit America today, he would likely marvel at how his early experiments with electricity have evolved into smartphones, global telecommunications, and space travel, while admiring the enduring survival of the constitutional republic he helped forge. Carrying a name deeply tied to the ancient traditions that shaped early American moral thought, he would be fascinated by the sheer reach of modern media, yet he might also caution modern citizens—just as he did at the close of the 1787 Constitutional Convention—that preserving a free, self-governing nation still requires active civic participation, compromise, and vigilance against deep partisan division.
Israpundit is entirely dependent on readers support. Please help me continue educating people with the truth about what is going on in Israel and around the world.


Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.