By Moshe Phillips
Click Image to Enlarge. Image created via AI.
In the wake of the horrific October 7th massacre, looking back at the May 2019 rocket offensive launched from Gaza against Israel reveals a sobering truth: things could have been infinitely worse for the Jewish state years earlier.
Had Israel caved to international demands to allow “dual-use” items into Gaza—the very same materials now being demanded by British Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband, and other foreign ministers—an atrocity on the scale of October 7th might very well have occurred back in 2019.
“Dual-use items necessary for humanitarian operations and early recovery must be granted before it is too late” tweeted Miliband on November 15. But who decides which “dual-use items (are) necessary”? Hamas still rules Gaza. Does Miliband actually trust Hamas? It certainly seems so.
Fortunately, there are still principled leaders in the U.K. willing to call out this dangerous recklessness. Former Shadow Foreign Secretary Dame Priti Patel deserves genuine praise for her moral clarity when she told the British newspaper The Jewish Chronicle that it was “shameful” that Miliband and his Labour Party were “promoting the narratives and spin put out by Hamas terrorists.”
To understand why Patel is so right, one can look beyond the horrors of October 7th and take a close look at what happened in May 2019. During a coordinated barrage, terrorists from Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad fired approximately 700 rockets at Israel. Tragically, four Israelis were killed. But how is it possible that the casualties weren’t exponentially higher? One would think that 700 terrorist rockets would have caused far heavier Israeli losses.
When Israel fires missiles at enemy targets, they strike with deadly, pinpoint accuracy. For example, they have been known to hit a single terrorist in a vehicle, or one apartment in the middle of a dense neighborhood. Yet when Hamas and Islamic Jihad fire rockets into Israel, the vast majority of them land in empty fields, parking lots, or other uninhabited sites.
The difference is not that the Israeli military has better aim. The difference is that the Israeli army has the latest equipment and the most sophisticated computer systems necessary to ensure that their missiles hit the desired targets. Meanwhile, the terrorists are actually trying to cause as much damage and death as possible — but their rockets still don’t make accurate landings. Why? Because they don’t have that technology. And the reason they didn’t have it in 2019 is because of the Israeli blockade of Gaza and the prevention of the type of “dual-use” items that Miliband wants Hamas to have access to.
Far too many politicians in Europe have been leading the charge against the blockade for far too many years.
In 2011, for example, a panel of five supposed “independent human rights experts” for the UN declared that the blockade is a “flagrant contravention of international human rights and humanitarian law.” In 2012, the UN’s annual report on Gaza labeled the blockade “collective punishment.” In 2013, the UN’s “humanitarian coordinator” for Gaza, James Rawley, claimed that “Gaza is becoming uninhabitable” because of the blockade.
The “Gaza Flotilla” and other extremists have also made ending the blockade their number one target. Miliband should know better than to join them.
It is also worth recalling that back in 2010, Joe Biden told Bloomberg TV that, “We have put as much pressure and as much cajoling on Israel as we can to allow them to get building materials” and other forbidden items into Gaza.
Then, just as Miliband and other foreign ministers are now, Biden was completely oblivious to the fact that many construction materials and supplies are dual-use items: in addition to their primary purpose, they can also be used by terrorists to build weapons or underground bunkers. Concrete for the foundation of a building can also be used to make an arms smuggling tunnel—the exact kind of terrorist infrastructure Hamas utilized on October 7th.
To its credit, Israel resisted this international pressure before 2019 and maintained the blockade. As a result, terrorists in Gaza were deprived of advanced targeting computers, and their 700 rockets were not nearly as deadly as they could have been. With Hamas refusing to disarm and still in control in Gaza, why should Israel allow the terrorists to refortify and rearm by taking advantage of the dual-use scheme?
Miliband and his fellow critics of Israel still have time to reverse course—and they should heed Priti Patel’s warning instead of helping Hamas to survive to fight another day. We shouldn’t hold our breath waiting for that from Miliband, though. Instead, we must remember the vital lesson of both the May 2019 rocket attacks and October 7th: restricting dual-use materials and maintaining security controls over Gaza saves lives, and Israel must stand firm, no matter the attempts at foreign coercion.
Moshe Phillips is national chairman of Americans For A Safe Israel, AFSI, (www.AFSI.org), a leading pro-Israel advocacy and education organization.
Israpundit is entirely dependent on readers support. Please help me continue educating people with the truth about what is going on in Israel and around the world.


Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.