Analysts and advocacy voices warn that key structural issues must be addressed before any ceasefire agreement is considered sustainable.
David Bedein | The J.Ca | Mar 16, 2026
Over the next weeks and months, Israel will be pressured by the US into accepting a ceasefire.
However, before agreeing to a ceasefire, fundamental issues must be brought to the forefront to show that the war conducted by the Palestinians and their Iranian allies is far from over.
• The official Voice of Palestine, operating on Israeli government radio and TV frequencies, continues its daily incitement.
• The Palestinian “Pay for Slay” law continues, mandating a salary for life for anyone who kills a Jew.
• The PLO charter places the Palestinians in a permanent state of war until all Jews have been expelled from all areas that had been Mandatory Palestine.
• The PLO has now spawned a new Palestinian constitution, which does not recognize the right of any Jews to live anywhere in Palestine.
• The Palestinian-designated Jew-free areas include all of the territory which today constitutes the state of Israel.
• The Palestinian war curriculum continues to educate all Palestinian children to live a life of permanent war with the Jews, until all Jews are expelled from Palestine.
• UNRWA transforms generous humanitarian aid into cash for arms training to prepare the next generation for war. Sixty-seven nations pour 1.6 billion dollars into UNWRA for humanitarian services. UNRWA hosts five million descendants of Arabs who left Israel in the wake of the 1948 war and remain in 58 “temporary” refugee camps under the premise and promise of the right of return to Arab villages that existed before 1948.
All the above begs the question: What about the PSF, Palestinian Security Forces, established by the Israeli security apparatus to ensure at least one Palestinian partner on whom it could rely for cooperation.
Already receiving hefty salaries on the PA payroll, all levels of Israeli security document that PSF officers are consistent perpetrators of terrorism against civilians and the security forces of Israel.
Glorified as “martyrs,” all PSF groups are complicit.
The Palestinian Security Forces were formed under the Oslo Agreement signed in September 1995:
“To guarantee public order and internal security for the Palestinians of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip… shall establish a strong police force that consists of the Palestinian Police and other branches responsible for national, preventive, public, and presidential security.”
– all of which are, in theory, supposed to combat terrorism and collaborate with Israel on security matters.
PSF officers hold parallel positions in ‘resistance’ movements, either civil or military, such as the Al Aksa Martyrs Brigades (the military arm of Fatah), using armed confrontation with Israel.
Rather than upholding public order and preventing terrorism, they themselves carry out acts of terrorism against Israeli civilians and members of Israel’s security forces.
In sum, no ceasefire can be implemented in the Middle East until each of these issues is resolved.
It is crucial to understand the precise nature of the “ceasefire” that the Palestinians offer: a hudna to stop firing, a term frequently misunderstood as “truce” or “ceasefire.”
A hudna is nothing but a temporary respite and does not remotely resemble either a “truce” or a “ceasefire.”
Here, then, are four terms now in use in the Arabic understanding of what a ceasefire means:
• Hudna: tactical pause intended for rearmament
• Tahida: temporary halt in hostile activity, which can be violated at any time
• Hudaybiyyah: cessation of fighting for 10 years, invoking the “Treaty of Hudaybiyyah” in 628 CE
• Sulch: total cessation of hostile activity
Notably, a hudna, tahida, or hudaybiyyah has no relation to the mu’ahada treaty of peace that Egypt signed with Israel in 1979, or the mu’ahada treaty of peace that Jordan signed with Israel in 1994.
The authoritative Islamic Encyclopedia (London, 1922) defines “hudna” as a “temporary treaty” which can be approved or abrogated by Islamic religious leaders, depending on whether or not it serves the interests of Islam, and that a “hudna” cannot last for more than 10 years.
The Islamic Encyclopedia adds that the Hudaybia treaty is the ultimate “hudna.”
When our news agency sent a crew to monitor Yassir Arafat’s speeches following the Oslo peace accords, we documented that the PLO leader repeatedly declared that the Oslo accords were akin to the Hudaybia treaty.
No one listened.


Thank you David for this summary of some if the issues that cause any attempt at peace to be self-defeating. The temporary breaks in hostilities when they are unable to proceed is in end-effect nothing other than a break for reestablishing their forces for the next round as if we were fighting according to Queensbury rules. They are nowhere on the gentleman scale and when dealing with them, there is no reason why we should follow any rules.
If the so-called Palestinians insist on incitement, they need not complain when their means of incitement are destroyed.
Anyone who is paid due to the pay-for-slay law should be required to pass that money over to the estate of their victims, at least as long as they are within the reach of Israeli law. If they prefer not to hand over these ill-gotten gains, they are free to leave immediately.
If they insist on being in a state of war with Israel, they need to be dealt with accordingly. No benefits, no positions in the government or in the courts. No other advantages they can use only for their own good.
If their new constitution denies the right of any Jew to live in what they consider to be their country, Israel must apply the same kind of law on them. None of them may live within what Israel considers to be our land.
Their children must leave too. Sorry but there is no choice.
UNRWA must be dismanteled permanently. Why can’t all these generous countries contribute a little of their largess to help Israel keep them under control as long as they live here?
The PSF was the greatest bad deed committed against Israel by our US friends. Not enough to institute and finance this “police force”, they had to indoctrinate them in terror activities too and even loudly support them. Shame on them.
no surrender no retreat , no deals , UNCONDITIONAL SURRENDER OR NOTHING