T. Belman. The NYT tries to suggest that Jewish money is inducing the GOP to be more pro-Israel. It titled this article “G.O.P.’s Israel Support Deepens as Political Contributions Shift”. This is the chicken and the egg controversy. They way I see it, after the Republicans demonstrated their support for Israel Jewish money supported them.
Notice that the article also tries to make the point that these financial contributors are an anomaly in the broader Jewish community. Notice that it also describes J Street as a “liberal pro-Israel group”.
Jeremy Ben-Ami, president of J Street, a liberal pro-Israel group, said this relatively small group of very wealthy Jewish-Americans distorted the views among Jews nationwide who remain supportive of the Democratic Party and a more nuanced relationship with Israel.
“The very, very limited set of people who do their politics simply through the lens of Israel — that small group is tilting more heavily Republican now,” he said, adding, “But it is dangerous for American politics as too many people do not understand that of the six million American Jews, this is only a handful.”
I ask, why is this “dangerous for American politics”? To me it is simple. As the Democratic Party lead by Obama shifts its support away from Israel and calls for more daylight, Jews are increasingly shifting their alliance and money to the GOP. Notice that most Jewish institutions, the Democrats and Obama keep stressing that Israel is and should remain a non-partisan issue. How can that be when both sides treat Israel differently. They are saying that their anti-Israel positions shouldn’t cost them. But they should. Israel should only be non-partisan when the Democrats embrace Israel as much as the Republicans do.
See also: US Jewry and the Spirit of Capitalism: Synagogue of the rich and famous marks 25th anniversary.
Rabbi Marc Schneier’s synagogue in the Hamptons caters to the US’ richest and most powerful Jews, mixing a distinctly American brand of religious pluralism, local community life and deep-pocketed philanthropy to consolidate a pro-Israel force to be reckoned with.
By Eric Lipton, NYT
WASHINGTON — As the proposed agreement over Iran’s nuclear program is debated in coming weeks, President Obama will make his case to a Congress controlled by Republicans who are more fervently pro-Israel than ever, partly a result of ideology, but also a product of a surge in donations and campaign spending on their behalf by a small group of wealthy donors.
Read more…