Peloni: The slowed pace of the war, the propaganda campaign in favor of Hamas, and the international campaigns to continue feeding and thereby funding Hamas have each played a role in stabilizing Hamas in Gaza rather than displacing it. This has also had the counter effect of reducing Gazan expectation of Hamas being ultimately displaced from power, thus intimidating any locals who might have an interest of working with Israel. Thus, we are caught in a stymied mess of achieving victories without ultimate victory, while any local resistance to Hamas is in turn quashed by the limits placed upon the war, and the butcher’s bill just gets longer and more painful to achieve. There can be no end to this war without defeating Hamas, but defeating Hamas requires that the war must begin in earnest, which is currently nowhere in sight.
Despite multiple IDF campaigns, Hamas continues to recruit fighters
by Seth J. Frantzman | Jan 7, 2025
As the new year begins, Israel will need to find a strategy for the war in Gaza. Several factors are at play in this decision. First, the war has gone on for more than fifteen months since it began with the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7, 2023. Although Israel has fought long conflicts in the past, such as the Second Intifada and the war in Lebanon that began in 1982 and lasted for eighteen years, the war in Gaza has been of greater intensity and complexity than those other wars. This is because the war in Gaza also set off Iranian-backed attacks on Israel from multiple fronts. It is also due to the fact Hamas still holds 100 hostages captive in Gaza.
The conflict in Gaza is challenging because there is evidence Hamas continues to recruit and also controls a large swath of the area. “We are not yet at the point of defeating Hamas entirely,” Brigadier General (res.) Yossi Kuperwasser told ILTV in December 2024. A separate report at The Jerusalem Post noted that Hamas is recruiting more members.
Read more…