According to Haaretz, “Lior was wanted for questioning after he endorsed the controversial book “Torat Hamelech,” which justifies the killing of non-Jews. ” There was no mention about the circumstances that would justify it. Does anyone have more info on what the book espouses? We must be able to distinguish the difference between this and expressions in the Koran or Christian Bible which many criticise. Rubin makes the case for the killing below and I entirely agree with him. This is a push back against the left who are trying to rewrite the rules of war. To advocate such killing is not incitement but common sense.
Two years ago this article, Rabbi Lior Says It’s OK to Kill Civilians …and other rabbis are silent, was published in an anti war blog. Lior alledgedly said,
“The law of our Torah is to have mercy on our soldiers and to save them. This is the real moral behind Israel’s Torah and we must not feel guilty due to foreign morals.”
“When our forces come across civilians during a war or in hot pursuit or in a raid, so long as there is no certaintly that those civilians are incapable of harming our forces according to Halkah they may and even should be killed.”
I have no ojection to these principals. In fact I have argued that it is criminal negligence to put your own soldiers at risk to save the lives of your enemies. Our duty is to our own and not to mankind.
The article ends with this surprising statement,
”I should also note that Lior’s resoning is very similar to the logic that Madeleine Albright used when asked to respond to the charge [in 1995] that a half million Iraqi children has been killed by U.S. sanctions. It was “worth it” because it was her responsibility to make sure US soldiers would not have to“refight the Gulf War”
Totally aside from the validity of the charge that 500,000 children died, to my mind we should not allow the left to tie our hands in seeking victory. That is not to say that we should drop the Bomb at the drop of a hat. It is to say that there are times when you drop the bomb. Ted Belman
Rabbi Lior’s Arrest
by David Rubin, INN
Rabbi Lior’s arrest was much more than a travesty of free speech. The reason for the arrest made no sense at all.
There has been much commotion over the arrest of Rabbi Dov Lior by the police, with many rightly referring to it as an infringement of free speech.
His crime? He endorsed a book entitled Torat Hamelech, authored by Rabbi Yitzhak Shapira and Rabbi Yosef Elitzur, which says that it is permissible to kill civilian non-Jews in certain situations during wartime.
Read more…