By T. Belman. Kristol approaches this question with optomism, Krauthammer with pessimism. What right does Kristol have to be optomistic. Can he point to any precident in the arab world that supports his optomism? So what if Krauthammer and he share the same goal, if it is highly improbable that it will be achieved. Iraq didn’t work out so well and its going to get worse. Meanwhile he supports the bad precident of abandoning your friends.
Would Kristol support an uprising in Saudi Arabia or is the risk too great? It would be great to abandon all our dictator friends and favour the Arab street, if the street would then be friendly. And if it wouldn’t, is that a good move for the US? And if the US is undermining our friends in the name of democracy without any assurance that what replaces the dictator is a friendly regime or a democracy.
So far Obama lost Lebanon and Turkey and alienated some European allies. How can Kristol trust him to not blow Egypt or to even have the same goal as he does?
Stand for Freedom
Bill Kristol, WEEKLY STANDARD
Our friend Charles Krauthammer began his column last week by asking, “Who doesn’t love a democratic revolution? Who is not moved by the renunciation of fear and the reclamation of dignity in the streets of Cairo and Alexandria?”
Some on the right, that’s who.
It’s understandable that conservatives should be wary of people taking to the streets—even when they are entitled to do so. It’s also reasonable for conservatives to warn of the unanticipated consequences of ostensibly hopeful developments.
As Krauthammer puts it, “All revolutions are blissful in the first days. The romance could be forgiven if this were Paris 1789. But it is not. In the intervening 222 years, we have learned how these things can end.”
Read more…