T. Belman. On the one hand, Israel negotiates resolutions such as 242 and 1701 or the terms of the Roadmap or the disengagement letter from Bush, to the best of her ability. Then their leaders tell Israelis what a wonderful deal they got. Israelis buy into it thinking they have a measure of protection. But the truth of the matter is, they don’t.
For instance, it has always been believed that all final status issues are to negotiated and that failing an aceptable agreement, Israel can always say no. In fact Oslo II provided “Neither Party shall be deemed, by virtue of having entered into this Agreement, to have renounced or waived any of its existing rights, claims. or positions.” The problem is the US is there to prevent our freedom to negotiate. They weigh in on the side of the Arabs and keep limiting our options. Nevertheless, Israel must insist on negotiatios without pre-conditions which means, if she doesn’t like the deal she can walk.
Guaranteed in America
By Elliot Jager, Jewish Ideas Daily
Why should the Netanyahu government place any faith in the incentives offered by President Barack Obama in return for an extension of the moratorium on settlement construction? So grumble some Israelis, pointing for added emphasis to Obama’s refusal to honor an earlier, Bush-administration pledge to Ariel Sharon. For these Israelis, such backtracking is another indication that Obama has broken with precedent and is bent on significantly shifting longstanding American practice toward Israel.
But what if the president is only following longstanding practice? As it happens, principles enunciated by one American president have regularly been ignored or silently repudiated by his successor, and some presidential commitments have enjoyed an even shorter shelf life than the one to which disillusioned Israelis now point.
Read more…