Incorporating Judaism and Zionism into Israeli public schools
Ted Belman: It wouldn’t be Haaretz if it didn’t include comments from leftists professors like Dr. Na’ama Carmi, an expert on human rights and a lecturer at Haifa University,
“But when it comes to Zionism, she says, “When referring to the state as a shaper of identity – this is problematic. The state is not supposed to do this. Society is supposed to influence the formulation of identity.”
On the contrary. The state must take the lead in inculcating values like patriotism and particularism. What she wants is multiculturalism and universalism.
Prof. Eyal Naveh of the history department at Tel Aviv University says it is inappropriate to attempt to renew national identity to what it was at the beginning of Zionism.
“The world today is in a post-nationalist place. There is a different discussion taking place today about the content of national identity from what was discussed in the 19th century,” Naveh says. The contemporary discussion, he explains is about the struggle between nationalism and globalization, among other things. Regarding Jewish studies, he says, “It is impossible to bequeath a legacy via artificial means. If the legacy does not stem organically and naturally from the community in which a person lives, this is education by indoctrination, which is likely to be perceived as coercion, and it won’t work.”
Nationism to him is bereft of particularism. He obviously doesn’t want a Jewish state. How about education of national standards as opposed to community ones, by inculcation.
The American people led by Palin want to be true to the founding fathers and the constitution. That’s akin to Israel returning to Zionism and rejecting post Zionism.
New Jewish studies curriculum is in part a product of a trend that has caught on in Israel which involves a ‘return to the Jewish bookshelf.’
By Tamar Rotem, HAARETZ
With the new school year underway, students have begun preparing Rosh Hashanah greeting cards in their classrooms, a sign the holidays are just around the corner. But then a familiar anxiety starts to take hold. While there is no doubt the fall holidays are the most important on the Jewish calendar, as always the teachers begin to get slightly worried about what and how to teach their students, and how to make the religious content relevant to those who are secular. How, for example, should they explain a quotation such as “Repentance, prayer and charity remove the evil of the decree” – the motto of the Rosh Hashanah holiday.
Read more…



