Peloni: Trump demands that Hamas release all 48 remaining hostages, while Israel releases hundreds of terrorists and thousands of detainees, and following this, all hostilities should halt while a negotiated end to the war is pursued. This is a very bad plan. Prioritizing the fate of the Hostages over the defeat or UNCONDITIONAL SURRENDER of Hamas should be understood to be a victory for Hamas. Instead of this, the Hamas leadership in Doha should be transferred to Israel, where they are placed on trial for crimes against humanity. Alternatively, Israel should take out the leadership in Doha as part of its campaign to take over Gaza City.
?BREAKING? Trump's proposal for a comprehensive deal for Gaza: Trump sent Hams a proposal for a comprehensive deal with significant changes from previous offers. It says all 48 hostages, alive and dead, will be freed on the deal's first day, along with hundreds of Palestinian… pic.twitter.com/Mj8kKGSH8L
— Raylan Givens (@JewishWarrior13) September 7, 2025
Is it possible Trump has proposed everything his and Bibi’s domestic opposition could want, just to take the wind out of their sails, knowing Hamas will never comply?
What madness is this! The proposal would simply turn the clock back to 06 October 2023. And, according to the writer, the Israeli government has accepted this ‘in principle’?
There is something wrong with the text. The author wrote that the fighting would not commence until after the negotiations conclude. This makes no sense; in fact the whole proposal makes no sense unless you happen to be an American president who is getting tired of having to deal with this matter and wants to get on with chasing drug cartels.
A terrible idea – why on earth is Trump even considering it? Hopefully Israel will take no notice and carry on with eliminating Hamas anyway.
OMG, I am so disappointed with Trump. Just as Israel is finally winning the war, Trump saves Hamas!