Israel betrayed Pollard

Hug for a Betrayed Brother
By Moshe Feiglin, Israel Insider

Moshe Feiglin visited Jonathan Pollard in prison on Tuesday, April 2, 2008. The following is his report (originally published in Makor Rishon on April 8, 2008) on the visit as translated to English by Justice For Jonathan Pollard (J4JP):

He almost never talks about himself. Throughout our conversation, he speaks about Israel, about the Jewish People, about me. But not about himself.

We hug. “You’re banned from England, eh?” he chuckles, before we even have a chance to sit down. These were the first words out of his mouth when we met last Tuesday. It never ceases to amaze me how this man, betrayed by us and buried alive in prison 24 years ago, is always so up to date on everything. How clear he is and sharp as a razor.

In the hours leading up to the meeting, I feel distressed. A kind of uncomfortable collective guilt enfolds you before meeting with the betrayed captive. He probably senses it and tries to dispel the dark feelings with his smile.

Jonathan Pollard begins with a detailed analysis of what is going on in Israel. Of the 2 hours that have been allotted to us, Jonathan uses 90% of the time to discuss the problems we are facing as a nation. He keeps to a minimum any talk about himself, and that is, in fact, why the few personal words which he does volunteer have such a tremendous impact.

When names like Yisrael Maimon (the former Cabinet Secretary who was previously responsible for the Pollard file) come up, it is hard for him to control his feelings, but he does. The names of other Israeli officials, like Ehud Barak who was the head of Israel’s Military Intelligence back then, come up in the course of the conversation from time to time and produce a similar response. “They betrayed me 24 years ago, and they are still stabbing me in the back in prison now.”

The reaction to the Israel State Comptroller’s decision to investigate the continuing failure of the government and its abandonment of an agent, was to be expected. Too many top officials were involved in the espionage and they want to keep Pollard buried along with the operation. It is not just the Minister of Defense Ehud Barak. It is not just Minister Rafi Eitan, and not just the Supreme Court Justice Elyakim Rubinstein, who was the Special Envoy at the Washington Embassy and who bears direct responsibility for throwing Jonathan out, into the arms of the FBI agents waiting outside of the gates. Not just because of Israel’s refusal to make an official request for Jonathan’s release, while at the same time peddling lies to the Israeli public claiming that “exhaustive efforts for his release are continuously on-going behind the scenes.” 112 Members of Knesset signed a petition for Jonathan’s release, but Prime Ministers Sharon and Olmert prefer to ‘forget’ to relay it to the President of the United States.

It was also to be expected that Lindenstrauss’ investigation of the case would generate a move to blacken the State Comptroller’s name. “This populist investigation is sabotaging efforts to secure the release of Pollard,” allege unnamed “security” officials, close to the Prime Minister’s office.

Simultaneous with the attack on the State Comptroller comes a co-coordinated attack on Jonathan himself. If we can trash Jonathan and his wife Esther and falsely portray them to the public as mercenaries lusting after luxury apartments and money, then public concern for their plight will evaporate. So we get a pack of lies published in Yediot Achronot [under the ‘respectable’ byline of Nachum Barnea, aka winner of the Israel Prize for Journalism.]

Esther Pollard doesn’t live in a luxury apartment. For years, Esther rented a tiny room in a cheap motel close to the prison, to be near her husband. It was the best she could do. When she realized that the reason that her husband continues to languish in prison is situated in Israel and not in America, Esther relocated her place of residence to Israel. Not to a luxury apartment in Jerusalem either — but to a small room in the apartment of a kindly Jerusalem widow who opened her home and her heart to the Pollards.

“If you come anywhere close to winning the primaries,” Pollard switches the subject to talk about me, “they will simply murder you. Two weeks before he was assassinated, Gandhi (Rechavam Zeevi z”l) came to visit me. I tried to warn him. I told him what I feared was going to happen, but he just brushed aside my warnings. They did it to one of their own; do you think that they would have any trouble doing it to you?” This is not the first time that people have cautioned me about this possibility, but when the warning is coming from the mouth of Jonathan Pollard, the words take on greater meaning.

“How is Israel able to succeed in having the Americans keep you in prison?” I ask Jonathan, “Even the head of the CIA has been saying for some time that it is time to let you go.”

“They have never given the Americans the slightest reason to officially begin the process,” Pollard replies. In matters like this, there are no free gifts. As opposed to what Israel is telling its own citizens, it has been made clear to the Americans through every channel, that Israel has no interest whatsoever in the man who saved the State by providing vital intelligence to ensure its survival. There are an endless number of American spies who have been caught in Israel. One of them was even a member of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee.

All it would take is a sign from Israel to bring about Pollard’s speedy release. Israel has numerous ways to secure the immediate release of Jonathan Pollard, but prefers instead to seek his death in prison.

Only towards the end of the visit does Jonathan share what he keeps locked in his heart. He describes the hostile, violent and noisy atmosphere he lives in. He says that he spends most of his time alone in his cell with earplugs in his ears. He speaks of his deteriorating health and how he is no longer able to climb up into his top level bunk bed; he is now forced to carry a medical permit allowing him a bottom bunk. He speaks of his legal situation. “Legally speaking, my life sentence condemns me to spend 45 years in prison. I am supposed to leave prison at age 75. They will never let that happen,” he says with disgust.

“At a certain moment in time,” I tell him, trying to encourage him, “these gates are just going to suddenly open, and you are going to walk out, a free man. That moment is closer than you think.”

Jonathan Pollard is a mirror who reminds us of who we are; a mirror that Israel is trying to shatter.

When the Pollard case first broke, Pollard was a young officer. Even back then it troubled me that Jonathan (the Jew) was thrown out of the Embassy, while his handler, IAF officer Aviam Sela (the Israeli), was given asylum and defended by Israel. Despite American pressure to hand him over, Israel stood firm for Sela. It looks like Israel is not a State of the Jews; I remember thinking at the time, but a State of Israelis.

Pollard is a Jew who saved the Israelis from American treachery. He did not save us because we are Israelis. He saved us because we are his Jewish brothers. The Pollard case imposes a Jewish identity upon Israel. Israel’s current leadership prefers to keep its Jewish identity safely stored under lock and key, in a jail cell in Butner, North Carolina.

April 20, 2008 | 5 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest

Leave a Reply

5 Comments / 5 Comments

  1. This might be the right time for Israel to round up all the American spy’s here and hold them pending out come of the Arrest of Israeli American working for US Army. Till now we have just kicked them out of the country quietly but going after an alleged spy for something he did?over 30 years ago is stretching believability that they are not targeting Israel from within the American system. If I were Jewish and living in America I would heed the early warnings and start to make plans for future moves, as later it might be too late.


    A US Army mechanical engineer has been arrested on charges that he slipped classified documents about nuclear weapons to an Israeli Consulate employee.

    The arrest of Ben-ami Kadish was announced Tuesday by the US attorney in Manhattan and FBI officials.

    The activities allegedly occurred from 1979 through 1985. Kadish worked at the US Army’s Armament Research, Development and Engineering Center in Dover, N.J.

    Kadish is suspected of taking home classified documents several times, and the Israeli government worker allegedly photographed them in Kadish’s basement.

    The documents included information about nuclear weapons, a modified version of an F-15 fighter jet, and the US Patriot missile air defense system.

    This I suppose is the one that the US has been Lookng for all these years and the reason the Americans would not release Pollard. Pollard always claimed no knowledge of the second Guy But Israel always claimed he did not exist now if this is the guy they have no reason to hold Pollard!!!

    Here WE Go Again!!!!

  3. I agree with Feiglin up to a point but I cannot absolve the American Jewish community either for abandoning a fellow Jew, who acted as a Jew should and is paying the price by the betrayal not only of Israel but not least of all American Jewry who would like to forget Pollard and for some, believe he got what he deserved.Gentile America sent a clear message to the Jews and they got it. American Jewry’s behavior toward the Pollard affair is similar to American Jewry’s behavior in the late 30’s and 40’s. The message I got from all of this affair is that we are no longer our Brothers Keeper. Every man or woman for himself/herself. The Talmudic injunction of Kol Yisrael Arvei Zeh le Zeh The people of Israel are the guarantors of ea. other. Shame on us Shame on You!!

  4. Israel betrayed the Altalina, Pollard, and the Jews who lived in Gaza. Now there is talk about total betrayal by giving away part of Jerusalem. Sometimes its not a pretty picture. If Israel will not stand up for itself, who will stand up for it? If not now, when?

  5. May the God of Israel BLESS this great hero, warrior, martyr for Israel!

    May he join the brotherhood of Jewish saints who are now alive with God in Heaven, ruling in a Kingdom where there is no map of Iran, Syria, Arabia, Egypt, Palestine, or England!

    Well, if the New Earth is identical to the old earth we live on, then there are no borders with the names of these nations – POLLARD is part of a greater Kingdom that is not of this earth – God bless him for his great courage and heroism!

    He’s an example to all of us!