Living (and dying) in bad times: the flood, the holocaust, the pandemic, and more

by Howard Rotberg, NER

In my 2003 novel, The Second Catastrophe: A Novel About a Book and its Author, a Canadian Jewish professor, son of a survivor of the Shoah, becomes obsessed with the idea that Iran is pursuing a Second Holocaust against the Jews, this time against the 6 million plus Jews of Israel.

When I look around the world today, I am appalled at the resurgence of antisemitism, some of it based on antisemitic strains in anti-Israelism, some now more often emanating from the Left rather than the extreme Right. The submission of the Left to the racist and anti-Semitic Black Lives Matter movement parallels the submission of the Left to militant Islamism and to globalist transfers of power to the same United Nations whose General Assembly is obsessed with passing anti-Israel resolutions and promoting the terrorists who would “drive the Jews into the sea.” From black rappers like Wiley and Scarface to self-hating anti-Israel Jews like Peter Beinart and the rest from J-Street and Jewish Voices for Peace, there seem few popular restraints against the crime we hoped would end with the Shoah.

The bad times, however, are not just man-made, but extend to the Coronavirus and the puzzling response by conflicted Public Health Officials, including leftist political interference to prevent the use of a clear life-saving drug (when taken early in the illness) – Hydroxychloroquine. An out of control pandemic when our leaders seem confused, is another reason that bad times are here.

A pro-Israel president of the United States, with Jewish children and grand-children, is hated by Jewish members of the American Democratic Party, and is absurdly painted as having authoritarian impulses – when it is the Left which has the totalitarian and authoritarian policies of censoring opposing viewpoints on Facebook and Twitter.

An emergency room physician, in New York, Simone Gold, with an additional degree in Law, is fired from her hospital for joining with a group of physicians promoting the use of hydroxychloriquine. We are left shaking our heads when Governors take over the role of physicians and ban a long-used drug with few side-effects that hundreds of doctors are using successfully in early stage (or as a prophylactic) treatment of Covid19.

Universities, even elementary education are now promoting the anti-Semitic aspects of Islamism, and the New York Times has become nothing except a mouthpiece for the leftist, now dominant, wing of the Democratic Party; yet many Jews still virtue-signal their Leftism and Globalism, by their persistent reading of the biased news from the NYT, or its allies on television, such as CNN, MSNBC and PBS. Jewish columnists of the New York Times, like Roger Cohen, Thomas Friedman and Michele Goldberg, regularly portray President Trump as authoritarian and Nazi-like while refraining from calling out the anti-Semitic words and actions of Black Lives Matters, and the Islamists Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib. They are in fact following the playbook of the Times’ failure to object to the Holocaust and failure to report on it. They also fail to cover the “Cancel Culture” and the clear abuse of process in the fake Russian collusion matter and the ridiculous attempted impeachment by Democrats like Adam Schiff, Gerry Nadler and Chuck Schumer.

I am certain that if the Democrats led (sic) by the elderly figure-head, Joe Biden, with true power in the Marxists, including both economic and cultural Marxism, then America as a force for good will be mortally wounded and will witness enhanced fighting in the streets. It is worrying when prominent supporters of the Leftist-Islamist-Globalist alliance, are Jewish intellectuals or politicians.

How do we understand the resurgence of “bad times”?

My father, Leon Rotberg Z”L, a survivor of Auschwitz, who lost his parents and then 8 year old sister in the gas chambers there, would have turned 100 this upcoming November. He lived a long life, passing away seven years ago at 93.

What occurred to me when writing my novel The Second Catastrophe during the anti-Israelism and antisemitism of the Second Intifada (2001 to 2002), was that Survivors like my father would surely be especially upset to witness the murder of more Jewish children and other Jewish civilians, this time in Israel, and the apparent support for same among Jewish leftists and others in America. And so, I began to wonder if sometimes it is better that certain people pass away before they can see some terrible event, whether political, cultural or financial.

As I read the news (from the few reputable sources), I sometimes think that it is good that my father is no longer alive to see this or that. Certainly, I wanted him to enjoy life with his children and seven grandchildren as long as possible, even though his later years were marked with some physical maladies and the common Survivor illness of Depression. But were he alive today, I would hate for him to see the moral and political chaos, including that within the Jewish community.

I wrote my novel in Israel during the worst of the Second Intifada, with near-daily attacks by suicide bombers at restaurants, disco-clubs, Passover Seders in old-age homes, school buses, and wherever Israelis might be gathering. Few tourists were coming to Israel then, and I was staying at the Maiersdorf Faculty Club Hotel, at the Mount Scopus campus of Hebrew University.

I wanted my novel to deal in some way with the modern fate of the Jewish people: the issue of how a just G-d, could allow the six million deaths of the Shoah was therefore a central concern. When I was writing, this problem seemed to be intellectually beyond me, and I felt incapable of finishing the novel.

One afternoon, I wandered over to the Bloomfield Library, just across the court-yard from the Maiersdorf. For some reason, right after I started browsing a book title seemed to jump off the book spine and grab my attention; it was by Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, formerly Chief Rabbi of Britain, and it was called Crisis and Covenant. I immediately realized what was stopping my writing was an inadequate understanding of the covenant between G-d and the Jewish people. In just one hour, I read most of the book.

The issue of the covenant, and then what is called the “Tochacha” – the blessings in the Torah for following the commandments in the covenant and the curses for rejecting them, seared itself into my mind.

I made the professor in the novel recall his talks as a teenager with an elderly Shoah survivor who developed a Torah-based theory of why G-d allowed the murder of six million Jews including about one million children. In part he explains that the Biblical curses come not merely for failing to keep the commandments but from a rejection of the covenant itself.

The old man’s theory revolves around the Biblical figure, Chanoch, or Enoch in English. From the time of Adam up to Noah and the flood, humans were living 800 or 900 years, but Chanoch “only” lived to 365. According to the first two parshas or chapters of the Torah, Chanoch was a particularly righteous man, so why did G-d take him so early? It also says that Chanoch is the great-great-great-great-great grandson of Adam, and the great-grandfather of Noah.

We are told that mankind became very evil in the time of Noah, so G-d decided to destroy the world, except that Noah and his family together with two of every animal, would survive the terrible flood in an ark that they were instructed to build.

By scrutinizing the names of the men after Adam and up to Noah, he establishes that Chanoch would have been 434 years old when Noah was born, and had he lived the usual 800 or 900 years, he would have witnessed the growing immorality around him, which resulted in the flood. And so, shocking as it might seem, this elderly Holocaust survivor, comes up with a theory that G-d took Chanoch earlier than usual for the times, because he was righteous and because G-d wanted to spare him from seeing the terrible immorality and perhaps from seeing how that immorality might bring the curses. The character in my novel worries that the old man is correct: that the death of the six million spared them, like Chanoch, from seeing the immorality ahead.

Are those who are passing away from Coronavirus being spared the experience of living through the bad political and cultural times of today? Is Coronavirus a contemporary “flood”? Aren’t we told in the Torah that G-d establshes another covenant with the Jewish People – this time to never again wipe out the Jewish people?

In fact we are reminded of this as every time we see a rainbow, as Noah did, we should recite the blessing: Blessed are You, Lord our God, Ruler of the Universe, who remembers the covenant, and is faithful to God’s covenant, and keeps God’s promise.

And remembering is really what a rainbow is about, at least for God. After the flood, God establishes a covenant with Noah and sets the rainbow as a sign of this covenant “between Me and the earth” (Gen. 9:13), says God:

“When I bring clouds over the earth, and the bow appears in the clouds, I will remember my covenant between Me and you and every living creature among all flesh, so that the waters shall never again become a flood to destroy all flesh.” (Gen. 9:14-15). Does this apply to all major destructions of Jewish people or just one, the flood, where almost all of our people are destroyed? Does this apply only to natural disasters but not to man-made events?

I later wrote a book called The Ideological Path to Submission … and what we can do about it. In this book, I canvas all the ideologies, such as cultural and moral relativism, postmodernism, denialism, excessive tolerance (which I call Tolerism), multiculturalism, Islamophilia and inclusive diversity, which seem to be promoting bad times by causing a western submission, especially to Islamism, but also to Leftism and Globalism. But in that book, I looked at ways to slow down or stop this submission and I wrote a chapter on how Israel has been able to achieve, despite the terrorism and anti-Semitic anti-Israelism, a kind of social resilience, which puts Israel in a different category than other western nations.

Terrorism and the other violence we see now in America is meant to so frighten a target society that it submits to the agenda of the domestic terrorists, like Antifa or Black Lives Matter, or the international Islamist terrorists. This result is clear from the situation in Europe, where the more that Islamists abuse their host nations, the more these nations seek more Islamist immigration and special privileges for the Islamists.

Professor Dov Waxman of City University of New York, wrote in an essay called, “Living With Terror, not Living In Terror” that the purpose of terrorism is to alter the political and cultural reality and change the political agenda of the targeted population by creating a sense of hopelessness and fear and demoralization, which has indeed happened in Europe and America, but not, as I can attest by my time in Israel, to the Jewish State. Professor Waxman writes:

“Palestinian terrorism during the second Intifada was ineffective because it did not succeed in demoralizing the Israeli-Jewish public. While Israelis were certainly fearful of terrorist attacks, they did not become despondent and dispirited… Instead of panic and public hysteria, there was stoicism and fortitude. Israelis did not allow the threat of terrorism to dominate their lives. Although they experienced high levels of stress and fear, they went on with their lives.”

Waxman and others have written about various coping mechanisms that arose in Israel but don’t seem to be present in an increasingly fragmented U.S.A., to withstand adversity and cope effectively with change.

Social resilience is key: if we react to Leftist violence and manipulation of the Rule of Law and Islamist terrorism and dangerous globalist empowerment of institutions that hate us, by appeasement or naive attempts at friendship, or a Cultural Stockholm Syndrome, or a guilt that turns into masochism or depression, we shall not deal well with the Bad Times that have arrived.

The U.S. and in particular the leftist, improperly educated, university students, and the media, have chosen to submit to the Leftist-Islamist-Globalist enemies. Jews in America should stop their infighting and submission – and unify enough to achieve social resilience to pass successfully through these Bad Times. Israel, for all its problems, and political fights, still manifests a social resilience in a nation that is far from giving up or rejecting the Jewish role in history. I suggest that there is nothing good about dying in bad times, and we should, like the boy in my novel, choose life, to further our mission, and not aspire to leaving the bad times without doing our best to remedy them. Bad times then require us to double-down on our obligations in the Covenant made with our creator. Bad times should remind us our that we have a role in preventing another Flood, another Shoah, and another pandemic, and hopefully in saving lives of some of the most moral among us.

Howard Rotberg writes on political culture, values and ideologies. His books are The Second Catastrophe: A Novel about a Book and its Author, Exploring Vancouverism: The Political Culture of Canada’s Lotus Land, Tolerism: The Ideology Revealed and The Ideological Path to Submission… and what we can do about it He has written foNew English Review, Jewish Voice of New York, Israpundit, Israel National News, and Frontpage Magazine. He is president of Canada’s sole conservative and pro-Israel publishing house, Mantua Books – www.mantuabooks.com.-

September 6, 2020 | 10 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest

Leave a Reply

10 Comments / 10 Comments

  1. @ Michael S:
    “debunked” REALLY?
    https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffsb&q=trump+eliminating+the+payroll+tax&atb=v183-1&ia=web
    And that’s why AARP keeps E-mailing me about this?
    This organization must be totally corrupt!
    I think that you deserve a “MOST BRAINWASHED” Nobel Prize.
    If those vicious Democrats really wanted to remove Trump and win the elections WHY would they choose the nearly disabled candidates to run for President TWICE IN A ROW?!?!
    I know, I know, “because they are totally irrational”.
    Let’s just make it a ONE PARTY state with the party headed by Trump Der Fuehrer with “Amerika, Amerika ueber alles!!!”
    I mean, why continue to be hypocritical and pretend to have more than one party?

  2. @ Adam Dalgliesh:
    Wise Donald Trump?
    He plans to totally DEFUND Social Security and 60% of Medicare by abolishing the payroll tax, if elected.
    25% of the elderly depend on Social Security for most or all of their income.
    Replacing the tax money with treasury bonds which, by your own admission, everybody will be trying to dump is questionable, to say the least.
    Is this wise?
    Of course, if the goal is to get rid of as many “useless eaters” as possible.

  3. @ Edgar G.: Edgar, just the other day, Arutz Sheva reported that the total number of deaths from all causes in Israel during the first seven months of 2020 was no higher than in 2019, before there were any CV-2 cases in Israel. The British national bureau of statistics has reported the same thing for Britain. A physician writing on a web site calledprimarydoctor. com crunched the numbers for the first seven months of 2020, as reported by America’s cdc, and compared the results with the months death rate for the years 2000 through 2019, and discovered that the monthly death rate (for all causes) for 2020 was actually less than for 19 of the past 20 years–even including 2019.

    Our own (American) CDC (Center for Infectious diseases) has admitted that only 9,000 people have died of COVID-19 and its complications alone). The other people whose deaths were attributed by the CDC had two or more “comorbidities–meaning that they were suffering from other serious illnesses, such as heart disease, that contributed to their deaths. More than half had three or more “comorbididies.” In other words, the likelihood that COVID-19 will kill you is extremely remote unless you are already very sick with other conditions.

    It seems that there is no pandemic in Israel , none in Britain, probably none in the United States and in most other countries throughout the world. We have been sold a bill of goods by China and the World Heath Organization. Probably none of these restrictions on personal freedomand on businesses have actually been necessary for health reasons. Certainly they have been carried to far greater lenghs than is served by any rational purpose.

    The tak by senior Israeli politicians about a total lockdown for the country strikes me as insane.

    Time to end the lockdowns and let the good times roll!

    Warmest best wishes, Adam.

  4. It looks as if there might be a lull, temporary or otherwise, in the rising death figures in Israel. The rate has been in the daily 20-35 level lately. But since yesterday when the total had reached 995 deaths, I find that today is is 1007, an addition of 12.

    Is this an indication of something…??? I don’t know, but am hoping.

  5. I am definitely no prophet and have no prophetic powers. This prediction, based partly on my observation of the current political scence the u .S., and partly on my private mystical system, is definitely very fallible. I realize that any Israpundit readers who happen to read this will take it with a grain of salt, and maybe laugh at it, and they will certainly be justified in doing so. Nevertheless, it is what I personally think is likely to happen.

  6. Concerning some of the mystical elements in Mr. Rutberg’s novel: I have worked out my own personal mystical system of numerology. It is based on certain passages in the Jewish scriptures, the chronologies of the eras of human history described in the scriptures, constructed by both rabbinic and non-rabbinic sources,
    and by chronological references in the scriptures themselves: and by the numbers assigned to the psalms; and numerous other chronological and numerical references in the scriptures.

    Using this personal system of numerology, which is not the system of gematria sanctioned by Jewish tradition, I have come up with the following predictions for America’s future:

    There will be something like civil war in the United States between 2020 and 2023. There wil be widespread riots, burning and looting, and a dramatic rise in violent crime and property crimes. Foreigners and many wealthy Americans will lose confidence in the country’s stability, and consequently its ability to produce goods and services that are valuable to people in other countries. This in turn will lead to panic selling of U.S. securities by foreigners and some Americans, and the withdrawal of foreign money from U.S. banks and other financial institutions. At present 27 per cent of the money in American financial institutions come from foreign sources, which are therefore essential to keeping our economy afloat). The loss of confidence in the United States, and the panic selling of u.S. dollars and dollar-denominated assets abroad, will make the dollar wothless for buying goods abroad. Since the U.S. imports most of our consumer goods, this in turn will lead to panic buying and hoarding in the United States, severe shortages of nearly everything, and perhaps some starvation.

    In spite of all these hardships and disasters, a wise and strong leader (Donald Trump?) will succeed in restoring order by about 2023, and an economic-political recovery will begin. However, it will take another ten years or so before the country reaches the level of prosperity and internal peace that was achieved in February of 2020, before the CV-2 panic was launched. Perhaps even longer.

  7. “Dr. Zev Zelenko

    Follow
    Dr. Zev Zelenko
    @zev_dr
    If interested in funding my Covid-19 related work; My paypal acc# is 8452384214
    M.D., Jacobs School of Medicine, SUNY at Buffalo
    New York, USAthezelenkoprotocol.comJoined April 2020

    Followed by James Todaro, MD and Andrew Bostom
    Tweets
    Tweets & replies
    Media
    Likes
    Dr. Zev Zelenko’s Tweets
    Andrew Bostom and James Todaro, MD follow

    Dr. Simone Gold
    @drsimonegold
    Follow
    doctor-lawyer-writer-mom.
    Show more

    Dr. Zev Zelenko
    @zev_dr
    ·
    Sep 4
    This can be avoided with Zelenko Protocol

    Key coronavirus forecast predicts over 410,000 total U.S. deaths by Jan. 1: ‘The worst is yet to…
    “We are facing the prospect of a deadly December,” Dr. Christopher Murray, director of IHME, said in a statement.
    cnbc.com
    73
    494
    1K

    Dr. Zev Zelenko
    @zev_dr
    ·
    Sep 4
    Comprehensive plan to defeat Covid

    NATIONAL PLAN FOR SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19
    NATIONAL PLAN FOR SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19 By George C. Fareed, MD Michael M. Jacobs, MD, MPH and Donald C. Pompan, MD September 2020 The United States is more than 6 months into the COVID-19 pandemic,…
    corsination.com”

    Please look at Dr. Zelenko’s twitter account, as well as the several excellent web sites theat he recommends, and the Twitter accounts of Dr. Todaro and Dr. Bostum (all M.Ds) who are close associates of DR. Zelenko. Also the web sites that he recommends.

    Dr. Zelenkpo and his medical associates believe that if the medications and mineral supplements that he recommends, not just hydroxichloriquine, but a number of other medications that researchers have found are helpful for treating this illness, COVID-19 could be eleiminated as a serious threat to public health within 1-2 years, even without a vaccine ( of course, a safe vaccine would also help). But it would require an end to the Federal and state bans on the use of HDRXCHL and several of the other medications for outpatient use. These meds are effective only if the disease is diagnosed and treated in it s early stages.