AIPAC does more harm than good.
Israel’s relations with the Diaspora are in flux. And as Israel prospers and matures, its distance from America’s faux “pro-Israel” organizations will continue to increase. That’s a good thing, not bad, and it couldn’t come at a better time. The anti-Zionist Jewish Left is currently making inroads on a wide front in the USA. To wit, the UJA/JCRC has allowed BDS-supporting groups to participate in today’s Celebrate Israel Parade in NYC. In fact, Israel-bashers like the New Israel Fund, Partners for Progressive Israel and B’Tselem are marching down Fifth Avenue even as I write – and, alas, doing so with little or no organized Jewish opposition. Dan Friedman
Like Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy, the Israel Lobby is a myth. AIPAC, like jolly bearded men sitting in shopping malls, exists. And like the men with fake beards and pillows under their red coats, it goes through the motions. Its activists lobby, its events attract politicians and the one thing that it and its enemies agree on is its vast sphere of political influence that, like Santa, is absolutely everywhere.
If you believe AIPAC, it’s an incredibly effective organization. If you believe its enemies, AIPAC runs America and parts of Canada. It’s not an accusation that AIPAC denies too hard. Mall Santas don’t deny that they have flying reindeer waiting for them on the roof. AIPAC is a fat man in a rented red suit and fake beard trying to pretend that it can do anything. But AIPAC would have better luck making reindeer fly than countering the dominant power of the anti-Israel left and the Saudi lobby in Washington D.C.
And that’s because it doesn’t even try.
Read more…






