Has the War in Gaza Ended with a Historic Defeat for Israel?
Peloni: Here is a key point to consider. The Trump doctrine is predicated on having strong allies who are not just capable of enforcing American interests around the world, but having the public prestige and recognition of doing so as well. This, more than any other aspect of the Surrender Deal forced on Israel, is why I believe that this war is not at an end. Indeed, Israel has its own reasons for eliminating the threat emanating from a Hamas controlled Hamastan, but I would argue that Trump’s need of having, not just a strong Israel, but a regionally dominating Israel serves to perfectly align both US and Israeli interests on this point. Israel needs to return to Gaza, destroying Hamas utterly, and failing to do so will not only result in an obvious and perceived Israeli defeat, but an American defeat as well. A strong Israel makes America stronger, and no one is more aware of this fact than Pres. Trump who envisioned the Trump doctrine in the first place.
By

Israeli political commentator Daniel Mendel certainly thinks that the war in Gaza has ended in a historic defeat for Israel. But the war is not yet over. Hamas is crowing that it is still standing, but will it still be standing when the hostage-for-criminals deal is over, and the Israelis realize, to their horror, just how many of those “98 hostages” were murdered by Hamas? Will the IDF not again gird its collective loins and reenter the Gazan cities it has pulled out of, in order to destroy whatever weapons Hamas may have managed to keep from being seized by the IDF, and to kill what remains of its combatants, including the estimated 15,000 new recruits — young and inexperienced in war — that Hamas now claims to have attracted? Mendel thinks the deal Israel has made is a “tragic and historic mistake.” He is convinced that the release of so many terrorist murderers will cause tremendous numbers of Israeli casualties in the future. He may be right. More on Mendel’s rage and despair at this lopsided exchange can be found here: “Israel’s Hostage Deal Is a Tragic and Historic Mistake,” by Daniel Mendel, Algemeiner, January 29, 2025:













