I reject the Palmer Report. First because it was a panel set up by the UN. Need I say more? Secondly it was a consensus report. Thus each side gets something. The Panel was not to adjudicate on legal liability yet it reported that Israel’s use of force was “excessive and unreasonable”. To my mind this is a legal conclusion. Based on this finding, the report recommended that Israel make “an appropriate statement of regret” and pay compensation to the families of the nine people killed by troops aboard the ship. They had no business doing this. If the families believe they are entitled to compensation let them make their case in an Israeli Court. There should be no compensation without legal responsibility. Who gives a s… that this panel thinks Israel should make a statement of regret. This panel acted as mediator suggesting compromises to get agreement from the parties. I didn’t see any recommendations as to what Turkey should do in return, given that Turkey probably aided and abetted the attackers. Ted Belman
IDF to defend flotilla commandos against legal action Apparently Israel is expecting criminal and civil prosecutions. That’s why she tried to negotiate. But I don’t see how that would have avoided the prosecutions.
PROCEDURE
The Secretary-General established the Panel of Inquiry on the 31 May 2010 Flotilla Incident on 2 August 2010. The Panel received and reviewed reports of the detailed national investigations conducted by both Turkey and Israel.
The Panel reviewed these reports and further information and clarifications it received in written form and through direct meetings with Points of Contact appointed by each government. In light of the information so gathered, the Panel has examined and identified the facts, circumstances and context of the incident and considered and recommended ways of avoiding similar incidents in the future. In so doing it was not acting as a Court and was not asked to adjudicate on legal liability. Its findings and recommendations are therefore not intended to attribute any legal responsibilities. Nevertheless, the Panel hopes that its report may resolve the issues surrounding the incident and bring the matter to an end.
The Panel’s Method of Work provided that the Panel was to operate by consensus, but where, despite best efforts, it was not possible to achieve consensus, the Chair and Vice-Chair could agree on any procedural issue, finding or recommendation. This report has been adopted on the agreement of the Chair and Vice-Chair under that procedure.
By HERB KEINON, JPOST
Turkey on Thursday warned Israel of drastic diplomatic sanctions if it did not apologize for the Mavi Marmara incident, even as the oft-delayed UN Palmer Commission report that will be formally presented to UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon on Friday says Israel’s naval blockade of Gaza was a “legitimate security measure” to prevent arms smuggling into Gaza.
The report, which was obtained and published by The New York Times on Thursday, concluded that Israel faces “a real threat to its security from militant groups in Gaza. The naval blockade was imposed as a legitimate security measure in order to prevent weapons from entering Gaza by sea and its implementation complied with the requirements of international law.”
Read more…