U.S. plans confidential appraisal of Israeli and PA peace moves  

By Barak Ravi, Haaretz Correspondent, and Reuters

The United States will conduct confidential assessments of whether Israel and the Palestinians are meeting their peacemaking commitments and share the results privately with the parties, U.S. and Western officials said.

Israel has sought to keep the U.S. process of judging compliance with the long-stalled “road map” peace plan largely secret. Palestinians say they favour disclosure of judgments on whether Israel is halting all settlement activity and whether the Palestinians are curbing militants as the plan demands.

Though the Bush administration has decided to keep the assessment process confidential, it reserves the right to go public with its views if necessary, the officials said.

U.S. judgments will be crucial because Israel has said it will not implement any peace deal until the Palestinians meet their commitments to combat militants in both the West Bank and the Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip, where militants continue to fire rockets across the border into Israel.
Read more…

December 23, 2007 | 3:06 pm | 2 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Increased Housing Allocation for Har Homa, Maaleh Adumim  

by Hana Levi Julian

(IsraelNN.com) The government has approved construction of more than a thousand new housing units in the Jerusalem suburb of Maaleh Adumim and the southern Jerusalem neighborhood of Har Homa.

[This is contradicted by, Olmert halts Har Homa tender, but ministers say capital building won’t stop]

A furor was raised over a ten-year-old housing project for Har Homa that received its final permits this month for construction of 307 new apartments.

The Palestinian Authority has claimed that the neighborhood belongs to the section of Jerusalem it plans to use for the capital of the new state it assumes it will build in Judea, Samaria and Gaza. PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas made frantic calls to US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice immediately after the plan’s approval was announced, asking her to force Israel to quit the project.
Read more…

December 23, 2007 | 2:30 pm | Comments Off on Increased Housing Allocation for Har Homa, Maaleh Adumim

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The Way Forward  

By Ted Belman

In my article Why I hate the “peace process”, I set out in point form what is wrong with the peace process.

Bottom line is that it is a vehicle that the world community rides to force Israel to capitulate to Arab demands. Many people including Jews support the process and even support US pressure on Israel to make more concessions. Without making a further argument in support of my rejection and against their designs, I would like to identify certain facts which inform the reality upon which I base my ideas of the way forward.

1. Before the Oslo Accords, the Arabs living in Judea and Samaria had good relations with Israel. Israel provided schools for them and even universities. As a result, such Arabs, now called “Palestinians” had a better education than their Arab brethren in adjacent countries. Their standard of living was higher also and they weren’t dependent on the world for charity. Jews and Arabs mixed freely for the benefit of all.
Read more…

December 23, 2007 | 1:37 pm | 34 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The leader Israel needs and deserves  

Fitzgerald, JihadWatch

    “The Israelis now living in the territories of the future Palestinian state should return to living within the borders of the state of Israel. No Jew in the world, now or in the future, as a result of this document, will have the right to return, to live, or to demand to live in Hebron, in East Jerusalem, or anywhere in the Palestinian state.” –-Sari Nusseibeh

What makes this outrageous but perfectly believable remark, by a so-called “Palestinian,” of such note is that the utterer is one Sari Nusseibeh. Nusseibeh is supposedly the most “moderate” and “reasonable” of “Palestinians” — because he is “Oxford-educated” (the epithet is Homeric, in Nusseibeh’s case) and scion of one of those Arab families of Jerusalem. Left-wing Israelis, Peace-Nowists, and so on, have always loved Sari Nusseibeh.
Read more…

December 23, 2007 | 10:30 am | 3 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Never Mind the Bomb, Beware of Islamofascism  

By: Amil Imani

The National Intelligence Estimate regarding Iran’s bomb project has stirred a great deal of controversy. Some say that there is now reason to abandon the war posturing and start negotiating a live-and-let-live deal with the Mullahs, since they have “abandoned” their quest for the bomb. At least that is what the not-so-reliable report seems to imply. Others, with good reason, remain skeptical of both the validity of the report and the ever-cheating, conniving Mullahs.

This controversy aside, the irrefutable fact is that the Jihadist belief of Islam itself poses existential danger to the world. Beliefs energize and direct actions. Beliefs are as indispensable as the air we breathe. Even an atheist is a believer, with his own system of disbelief. Not believing in anything is mental breakdown. There is something about humans that demands a belief. A belief can be anything or a combination of many things; it can be well-defined and even rigid, or a loosely put together hodge-podge with considerable latitude. It can be magnificent or the most abhorrent. But, it has to be there. Beliefs steer our vehicles in the journey of life.
CONTINUE

December 23, 2007 | 6:44 am | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Get the Arabs to make a better offer  

By Ted Belman

I recently emailed my article There is no duty to accept peace on Arab terms. and received this reply


    it must be hard being the only virgin left standing — a true believer who is certain that he has found the right truth and would you believe it, it’s on his right side. In your selective parsing of the Salon article you do exactly the same thing you accuse the left of doing of being blind to reality. Your so sure statement that “right wingers do not reject peace…they just reject faux peace on Arab terms” …ignores the fact that regardless of the “absolutist voices”…of which your, I believe, is a Jewish echo, people of good will, however strained that good will is, on the right and on the left, have to continue thinking of peace and struggling with each other for peace, finding the compromises out of “each others terms” so that at some time, children, on both sides, can grow up at peace.” I am reminded of the Yiddish expression “as beyde bale-dinim zaynen gerekht iz shlekht–When both litigants are right its a sorry sight.” It’s time to get beyond the the sorry sight of the two litigants howling their stories of absolute right. Maybe, then Justice will be served — for the Israeli’s for the Palestinians. Maybe.

Here is my response.
Read more…

December 23, 2007 | 5:40 am | 39 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Gaza; “It is easy to go in, but more difficult to get out,”  

Jacob Katz suggests Israel can defeat Hamas but asks at what cost.

[..] The thinking within Jerusalem that a large-scale operation in Gaza is the only real way for Prime Minister Ehud Olmert’s peace partner, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, to return to power in the Strip has been floating around the halls of the Kirya Military Headquarters for several months now, ever since Hamas’s violent takeover of Gaza in June.

There is no question that the IDF can, if it unleashes it full power, significantly weaken Hamas, and perhaps destroy it.

Israel would first bomb Hamas positions from the air and simultaneously begin assassinating Hamas’s military, and possibly even political, leadership.

The IDF has learned its lessons from the Second Lebanon War and would fairly early on send large forces into Gaza for two purposes – to stop the Kassam rocket fire that will escalate in the first few days of the operations and to hunt down terrorists by going door-to-door on Gaza’s densely-populated streets.
Read more…

December 22, 2007 | 2:33 pm | 12 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Will an Islamic Charter soon prevail over Universal Human Rights?  

Universal Declaration of Human Rights or Islamic Charter?

Dhimmi Watch

Two NGOs appealed today to UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Louis Arbour on the possible conflict between the 1948 Universal Declaration for Human Rights and the 1990 Cairo Declaration for Human Rights in Islam — with shari’a law as “the only source of reference” (articles 24 and 25).

Their Appeal for a legal ruling was prompted by the message of the Secretary General of the Organization of the Islamic Conference, posted on the OIC website on Human Rights Day (December 10). It stated that the OIC was “considering the establishment of [an] independent permanent body to promote Human Rights in the [56] Member States in accordance with the provisions of the OIC Cairo Declaration of Human Rights in Islam and to elaborate an OIC Islamic Charter on Human Rights.” Will an Islamic Charter soon prevail over Universal Human Rights?

Report by David G. Littman, in his capacity as representative of the World Union of Progressive Judaism (WUPJ) to the United Nations Office in Geneva:

    “This letter from two NGOs representing over 6 million members — the World Union for Progressive Judaism and the International Humanist and Ethical Union — was faxed to UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Louise Arbour on Friday December 21.”

[Now read the letter.}

December 22, 2007 | 1:48 pm | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The prosecution of Iran for the bombing in Argentina  

By Ted Belman

The investigation of the bombing of the Jewish Community Centre in Argentina went nowhere until Alberto Nisman was appointed to the case.

David Horovitz covers the amazing story in Exposing Iran’s ruthlessness

    [..] Three years ago, he was named to head a 40-strong team that essentially restarted the AMIA investigation from scratch. Today, the previous, skewed probe has been thoroughly discredited. Those who so signally failed to bring the culprits to justice – including judges and investigators – are themselves on trial or facing indictment. Nisman is collecting evidence which may lead to charges against the president, Carlos Menem, whose admirable foreign policy shift prompted the bombing but whose influence over the failed probe is suspect.

    And thanks to Nisman and his team, the world now knows exactly who is to blame for the death and devastation of July 18, 1994 – who it was that dispatched Ibrahim Berro on his murderous mission. Once investigators focused seriously and honestly on the trail of evidence, it led unwaveringly to Teheran.

Read more…

December 22, 2007 | 1:40 pm | Comments Off on The prosecution of Iran for the bombing in Argentina

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Is the Hebrew Press fascist?  

Maariv Takes on the “Fascist Left”

By Stephen Plaut, JEWISH PRESS

This past Friday was something of a milestone.

For the first time a mainstream Israeli journalist referred to the radical Left as the “Fascist Left.”

Let me explain. First, Israeli Hebrew journalism is by and large the occupied territory of the Israeli Far Left, and under its hegemony. (The electronic media are not much better.) Haaretz is somewhat to the Left of the communist party, routinely runs Op-Eds calling for Israel’s annihilation, and the Haaretz idea of “journalistic pluralism” makes Pravda under Brezhnev look like a fountain of democratic enlightenment. Yediot Ahronot is not as extreme as Haaretz, but is almost as homogeneously and uniformly Left. Maariv is the only Hebrew daily with any semblance of pluralism and even it is more Left than Right. Nevertheless, one can find on its pages Nadav Haetzni, by far the best columnist in Israel, and he is well to the Right, plus some others who refuse to toe the political correctness line.
Read more…

December 22, 2007 | 12:47 pm | 4 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Religion-based laws are meant to keep Jewish identity.  

By Ted Belman

My article Get the Arabs to make a better offer got a lot of attention and many comments, the last of which is by my friend, Alex Eisenberg.

While you are at it, please comment on Israel as a Jewish and democratic state. How do you define these terms and are they in conflict. To start the discussion I looked up the definition of democracy (rule by the people) and found that it is often coupled with human rights. This lead me to Demoracy and Human Rights, a publication of UNHCDR.

Israel has always been in the religion/secularism limbo from its very inception. The state is secular, just as a lot of its laws. But religion does rule over some basic aspects of law in Israel, the most prominent example of which having always been the marriage issue. It’s not possible to legally marry anyone outside of religion. Either you follow the Halakha or get married abroad.

The point is how important the specifically religion-based laws are. This is very easy to understand. Religion-based laws are meant to keep Jewish identity. As most high-schooled Westerners know, Jews try to marry only fellow Jews. The reason is that intermarriage has always meant assimilation for Jews – assimilation means you are still a Jew but your grandchild will not be one. Since Israel is supposed to be a Jewish state, and Jewish identity is exclusively determined by religion, there is no way out of the limbo as far as the current definition of democracy is concerned.
Read more…

December 22, 2007 | 11:47 am | 8 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

A License to Kill  

By Ted Belman

Free speech is under attack everywhere. Hardly a week goes by without another defeat of its defenders. We are saddened, if not outraged, by the recent court decision against Rachel Ehrefield. And now the following takes the cake.

Defaming Islam

by Baron Bodissey, Gates of Vienna

No to the UN!According to CNS news, the UN General Assembly has passed a resolution against the “defamation of religions”, especially Islam.

I’ve never felt a particular need to defame Islam, since Islam is perfectly capable of defaming itself.

But this, of course, is hate speech, not to mention racism and xenophobia, and is thus defamatory in its own right. Once the UN gets its way, I won’t be able to say it anymore.

The anti-religious defamation resolution was introduced by the OIC as a corrective to the Islamophobia revealed by the Mohammed cartoon crisis in Denmark. It has been kicking around the UN in committee for a couple of years, and generally flew under the radar until it was passed by the General Assembly this week without attracting any undue attention.

Read more…

December 22, 2007 | 11:29 am | 4 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The Devil is in the details  

By Evelyn Gordon, JPOST

[See also: The contours of the settlement are not obvious or clear]

One of the most widespread misconceptions about Israeli-Palestinian talks is that “everyone knows what a deal looks like;” all that is needed is for the parties to finally sit down and sign it. As The New York Times put it in an editorial last month, “the issue is less how peace would look than whether leaders … have the political courage to make decisions and move forward. The broad outlines of a deal … have been apparent since President Clinton’s 2000 push.” Haaretz similarly declared, in a front-page headline last Thursday, that “dramatic agreements on core issues” were achieved at the Taba talks in 2001.

The assumption behind such assessments is that the details are unimportant and easily resolved. Yet in this case, it turns out that the details are the core issues – and the disputes over these “details” reveal that in fact, nothing has been agreed at all.
Read more…

December 21, 2007 | 4:01 pm | 6 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The Failed State of Palestine  

Jewish Current Issues

Michael Eisenstadt, director of the Military and Security Studies Program at The Washington Institute, has produced a lengthy Policy Focus Paper entitled “The Palestinians: Between State Failure and Civil War.”

Eisenstadt writes that the Palestinian Authority has “largely functioned as a de facto state since its creation in 1994” and now “displays many of the traits of a failed state:”

    On the eve of the Hamas takeover of Gaza, the PA was no longer able (and in some respects, it never was able) to fulfill the most important functions of a state: to provide for the welfare and security of its people. The clearest signs of the weakness of the PA were what Palestinians referred to as “the four Fs”: fawda (chaos), fitna (strife), falatan (lawlessness), and fassad (corruption).

None of the four “Fs” were caused by Israel.
Read more…

December 21, 2007 | 3:48 pm | Comments Off on The Failed State of Palestine

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The law is an ass  

By Ted Belman

The man on the street knows that Israel lost the Second Lebanon War no matter how much the GoI spins it otherwise.

Caroline Glick in her most recent article The triumph of legal defeatism informs us of testimonies of Attorney-General Menahem Mazuz and Military Advocate-General Avichai Mandelblit before the Winograd Committee

    [..] Mandelblit and Mazuz testified that legal advisers were present at all levels of command in all the relevant service arms and in the security cabinet. At each level the lawyers were asked to judge the legality of all the proposed targets and planned operations before they were carried out. And as the two explained, in their decisions, these lawyers were informed not by the goal of winning the war, but by their interpretation of international law.
    Read more…
December 21, 2007 | 12:04 pm | 3 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Funding the PA: going, going, gone  

Daniel Pipes asks Fund the Palestinians? Bad Idea. His article is extremely well researched and the best part is that he links to a study supported by graphs to prove a correlation between the rise and fall of funding with the number of homicides, i.e. the killing of a human being by another human being.

Hugh Fitzgerald in Boys, let’s turn on the tap for Fatah refers to the PA as a “money pit”.

David Singer coined the best phrase for the Doner’s largess in his article , Paris Produces Palestinian Funding Frenzy

December 21, 2007 | 11:07 am | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Bernard Lewis is an apologist for Islam  

In Another “Just So” Story”, Andy Bostom takes on Bernard Lewis for some of his views.

Now Diana West joins the fight. In What about the Record, after decrying the fact that the Doner’s have pledged $7.4 Billion to the PA without even asking for a “thank you”, she attempts to explain why. Some of the blame, she attributes to Lewis.

    As it happens, I began the calendar year thinking about this subject — exonerating Islam — while discussing a PBS documentary on antisemitism in the Islamic world. The show’s conclusion: What isn’t Israel’s fault is that of the West.

    What was startling about the message, however, was one of the messenger’s: none other than the eminent historian Bernard Lewis. He declared that antisemitism didn’t even exist in the Middle East until European Christian colonizers brought it. You don’t need to be a scholar of Mr. Lewis’ stature to know that European colonization of the Middle East didn’t begin until some 1,100 years after Islamic anti-semitism got going in the Koran, the canonical commentaries on the Koran and in a long and painful (for Christians also) historical record.

Read more…

December 21, 2007 | 10:48 am | Comments Off on Bernard Lewis is an apologist for Islam

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

A one-state solution of our own  

By Ted Belman (In response to Hasan’s article Just One State.)

In my article, The War on Zionism, I decry the smear that Zionism is racism. It is a national liberation movement.

Having said that I want to address the arguments in Just one State. While I also am against the two-state solution it is for a different reason. It is not workable nor achievable.

For some time now I have understood that if we reject the two-state solution then we will have to fight against Hasan’s one-state solution. Accordingly the battlefield of ideas will shift and we must be prepared for it.

In my article above noted I argue

    “But the bottom line is that the Arabs want Palestine to replace Israel. This goal is reiterated by all boycott movements, by the International Solidarity Movement (ISM) and Muslim Student Association (MSA), by Iran when it calls for Israel to be “wiped off the map”, by the PA which publishes books with maps showing Palestine in place of Israel, by Hamas and by many UN agencies and NGO’s.

    “The endorsement of the two-state solution is a sham for western consumption. The demand for a “just solution to the Palestinian Refugee problem to be agreed upon in accordance with UN General Assembly Resolution 194?, otherwise known as the right of return, vitiates any recognition of the two-state solution because it effectively is intended to destroy the state of Israel.”

Read more…

December 20, 2007 | 7:09 pm | 2 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Just One State  

The gathering force of the one state solution for Palestine is a mortal threat to Zionist racism,

By Rumy Hasan, al Ahram

[I have been invited to respond to this article which I intend doing]

On the weekend of 17-18 November, a conference took place in London that I hope and believe will prove a historic event. The reason is that it discussed the one state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Organised by the SOAS Palestine Society and the London One State Group, it was held in the largest hall at SOAS, and was sold out in advance — an indicator of the thirst for discussion of this vision. For me it was the most inspiring event on Palestine I have ever attended.

On the various platforms were not only Palestinians (from the Diaspora, within Israel, and from the occupied territories) but also, uniquely, Israeli Jews. Following the London conference and a related one in Madrid, a “One State Declaration” was issued 29 November. Most of the signatories, an array of outstanding intellectuals and activists, were at the London conference: Ali Abunimah, Naseer Aruri, Omar Barghouti, Oren Ben-Dor, George Bisharat, Haim Bresheeth, Jonathan Cook, Ghazi Falah, Leila Farsakh, Islah Jad, Joseph Massad, Ilan Pappe, Carlos Prieto del Campo and Nadim Rouhana.
Read more…

December 20, 2007 | 4:32 pm | 5 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Gaza: NGO’s, the Times, the World Bank, and the facts  

By Dr Andre Oboler

A December 17 article Israeli sanctions ‘will ruin plans to rebuild Palestinian economy’ in the Times (UK) caused concern for many who care about fair reporting, human rights and effective assistance to the Palestinians.

The article stated that Oxfam, the World Bank and the Red Cross reported that Israeli restrictions on movement have “strangled the Palestinian economy.” It follows an angle initially provided in a December 14 press release by the NGO Oxfam. The press release was titled “For aid to be effective, donors need to insist Israel changes its policies towards occupied Palestinian Territories”.

The policy in question is the isolation of Hamas. Both the article and Oxfam press release lack the context provided in the December 17 World
Bank report
and the speech the World Bank’s Managing Director Mr. Juan-Jose Daboub gave in addressing the Donor conference.

Read more…

December 20, 2007 | 4:04 pm | 3 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free
« Previous Page — Next Page »