What Greenland teaches us About Israel’s borders

Peloni:  Having the capability of successfully providing the defense of the homeland is the primary and foremost obligation of any nation’s governing body.  Hence, it is unfortunate that so many nations in the world have come to accept that such obligations are either arbitrary or conditional, just as it is unfortunate that those nations who are so inclined to ignore such necessities as border defense will likely pass into the pages of history when they find that their security capabilities, or lack thereof, are someday tested.

Security is not a slogan; it is a capability. 

Moshe Phillips | Am Thinker | January 19, 2026

Landscape images of the Judean Hills and Greenland drifts.  Image created via AI

President Trump is saying it plainly — and repeatedly — right now: Greenland matters because security matters. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and China’s near daily threats toward Taiwan, including flying military aircraft near its airspace and rehearsing naval blockades, are just two obvious examples. This much should be obvious: the United States can defend Greenland. Denmark, an extremely small nation of roughly six million people, cannot.

That same hard truth applies to Judea-Samaria — what the New York Times, the United Nations, and the Palestinian Arabs call the West Bank — what October 7 demonstrated is that Israel must retain exclusive security control of the entire region.

Security is not a slogan; it is a capability. It requires intelligence dominance, rapid response, air control, logistics, and the political will to act decisively when threats emerge. Israel possesses those capabilities. The Palestinian Authority does not. It never has.

Even today, it is the Israel Defense Forces — not the Palestinian Authority — that prevent Judea-Samaria from collapsing into the kind of murderer-led enclave seen in Gaza. Israeli forces disrupt terrorist cells, intercept weapons, and prevent mass-casualty attacks not only against Israelis inside the so-called Green Line, but also against Jewish families living in communities in Judea-Samaria itself. Without Israel, those Jews would be defenseless. This is reality.

American conservatives should have no trouble understanding this. Conservatives believe that borders must be defensible. They believe that security precedes diplomacy, and know that pretending weakness is strength only invites aggression. The lesson of Ukraine is clear: when aggressors believe territory is weakly defended, they move. Outsourcing security to entities that lack the means to provide it is not moral — it is reckless.

Geography reinforces the point. Greenland is not merely associated with North America; it is part of its strategic ecosystem. Arctic shipping lanes, missile defense, early-warning systems, and great-power rivalry all run through Greenland. With China pushing into the Arctic and Russia militarizing the polar north, Greenland is no longer a distant ice sheet — it is a frontline. Its future aligns naturally with the United States, not Europe.

So too with Judea-Samaria. The area’s ridgelines dominate Israel’s population centers. Its water aquifers feed Israel’s cities. Its roads, commerce, and labor markets flow westward. The notion that Judea-Samaria “belongs” with the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan — an entirely separate state east of the Jordan River — ignores every strategic and geographic reality on the ground. Jordan has its own challenges and has neither the desire nor the capacity to absorb or secure the territory.

Equally mistaken is the idea that the Palestinian Authority can be allowed to be a part of the future of the region. Mahmoud Abbas, head of the PA, has also long been given a free pass from the UN and others regarding the PA’s harboring and protecting of terrorists. The PA has one of the largest per-capita security forces in the world (over 60,000 men) and it has largely been armed and trained by the United States. Yet instead of using those forces to arrest and extradite terrorists — as the Oslo Accords require — Abbas and his PA pay salaries to terrorists and their families, and shelter fugitive terrorists so Israel can’t capture them.

Neither Jordan nor the Palestinian Authority can be trusted with the future of Judea-Samaria.

President Trump’s Greenland idea is not about conquest; it is about the future and about responsibility. Power carries obligations, and the first obligation is defense. The same realism that recognizes China’s threat to Taiwan and Russia’s brutality in Ukraine applies in the Middle East. Pretending that security can be subcontracted to weak or fragmented authorities is how regions collapse and wars begin.

Judea-Samaria in hostile hands would not produce peace. It would give birth to one huge terrorist base overlooking Israel’s heartland — just as abandoning strategic territory elsewhere invites adversaries to exploit it.

History does not punish strength; it punishes denial. Nations that survive are the ones that secure what they must, when they must. Those that hesitate learn the lesson later — at far higher cost. Americans who care about the future of Israel should stand with those Israelis that are working to remove the Palestinian Authority from Judea-Samaria and end the limbo in which the area has been trapped for far too long.


 

Moshe Phillips is national chairman of Americans For A Safe Israel, a leading pro-Israel advocacy and education organization.

 

January 21, 2026 | 5 Comments »

Leave a Reply

5 Comments / 5 Comments

  1. Q; when was it revealed that Tom Lehrer had been a top secret nuclear scientist?

    AI: It was actually revealed that Tom Lehrer used his nuclear work as a cover story for an even more sensitive position, rather than being a career nuclear scientist. He publicly clarified in 1994 (and again in more detail around 2020) that he was drafted into the highly classified National Security Agency (NSA). [1, 2]
    Because the NSA’s existence was considered a top secret, classified matter during the Cold War, Lehrer relied on his background and time at the Los Alamos National Laboratory to imply he was working on nuclear weapons, acting as a clever cover for his cryptographic and code-breaking work. [1, 2, 3]
    If you’re interested in diving deeper into his life, I can:
    * Provide a list of his best Cold War satirical songs
    * Explain how he poked fun at his NSA service through his co-authored mathematical papers
    * Share details about his academic career teaching mathematics [1, 2, 3, 4]
    Let me know how you’d like to proceed!

    “ The musical humorist used his Army experience as the basis for several of his songs, and in turn worked in references to his music in his work at the NSA.”

    https://taskandpurpose.com/culture/tom-lehrer-comedian-soldier-dies/

    Tom Lehrer: The Elements: Live in Copenhagen 1967

    https://youtu.be/AcS3NOQnsQM?si=Qw0Wehpj0vOXuLw8

  2. “U.S. Scores Major Rare Earth Win With Greenland Deposit Deal”

    By Charles Kennedy – May 27, 2026, 7:01 PM CDT
    Greenland Nuuk
    As Washington races to build a rare earth supply chain that can survive the Pentagon’s 2027 ban on Chinese-origin materials, REalloys (NASDAQ: ALOY) has locked in long-term supply from one of the largest known heavy rare earth deposits in the world.”

    “…REalloys is building one of the only integrated heavy rare earth metallization and magnet production platforms in North America as Washington pushes to break its dependence on Chinese processing capacity before the Pentagon ban takes effect in only seven months.”

    “GREENLAND IS EMERGING AS A WESTERN RARE EARTH STRONGHOLD

    Trump didn’t manage to buy Greenland, but REalloys got its critical minerals.

    The strategic importance of the Tanbreez project goes far beyond scale.

    The Greenland deposit is one of the largest known heavy rare earth resources globally and one of the few major Western-aligned projects capable of supplying meaningful quantities of Dysprosium and Terbium outside China.”

    “Tanbreez isn’t just another rare earths venue. It’s a heavy rare earth behemoth, while most global deposits focus on less valuable light rare earth production. Critical Metals estimates heavy rare earths account for roughly 27% of the project’s total profile. Most global deposits focused primarily on light rare earth production.

    The Greenland project is already fully permitted and advancing under a Western-aligned ownership structure following Greenland’s approval of Critical Metals’ acquisition of a controlling 92.5% interest earlier this year. ”

    “Johns Hopkins economists Steve Hanke and Jeffrey Weng told Fortune magazine that the U.S. has already burned through massive portions of its precision weapons inventory across Iran and Ukraine, while remaining dependent on Chinese-controlled rare earth materials to replace them. The economists suggest that Washington has blown through 45% of its Precision Strike Missile inventory just in Iran, and nearly 50% of its THAAD interceptors and 30% of its Tomahawk cruise missiles, among others.

    Those systems rely on samarium-cobalt magnets or dysprosium- and terbium-enhanced NdFeB magnets that still flow overwhelmingly through China’s refining and metallization system. The authors estimate that replenishing just four major weapons systems could require between five and ten metric tons of finished defense-grade rare earth magnets, with more than 95% of current supply chains still tied to China.”

    “Bloomberg reports that internal disagreements are emerging inside the Trump administration after China’s export restrictions exposed major U.S. vulnerabilities. The argument is over whether the U.S. should rely on market forces to rebuild the rare earth industry or use aggressive state-backed financing and industrial policy similar to the model China used to dominate the sector.”

    https://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-General/US-Scores-Major-Rare-Earth-Win-With-Greenland-Deposit-Deal.html

  3. The Greenland dispute is all the same a vanity exercise in formalities and Mr Trump’s vanity to be in history books as having added to US territory.
    Since 1940 the US has only had to knock and ask – notify – politely for Denmark to let it do as necessary for rmutual defence. This incident, however it ends, will do no good for NATO; and excuses Russia in Ukraine and any mischief China may do in Taiwan.
    Incidentally the Danes and other Norse were in Greenland before the 13 colonies were established.

  4. UPDATE: Trump gains Greenland/Arctic Region Deal

    Based upon a very productive meeting that I have had with the Secretary General of NATO, Mark Rutte, we have formed the framework of a future deal with respect to Greenland and, in fact, the entire Arctic Region. This solution, if consummated, will be a great one for the United States of America, and all NATO Nations. Based upon this understanding, I will not be imposing the Tariffs that were scheduled to go into effect on February 1st. Additional discussions are being held concerning The Golden Dome as it pertains to Greenland. Further information will be made available as discussions progress. Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, Special Envoy Steve Witkoff, and various others, as needed, will be responsible for the negotiations — They will report directly to me. Thank you for your attention to this matter!

  5. What he says rings true. However the missing part is converting into reality. The existing strength must not be wasted. The PA must go.
    Israel is capable of policing J&S but the will to do so while ignoring the screams from all sides is still in denial.