Why do the Arabs hate the Palestinians so?

The Arab world, for many reasons, is not at all interested in giving the Palestinian Arabs a state. The Palestinian Arabs don’t really want one either, because why kill the “refugee” goose that lays the golden eggs?

By Dr. Mordechai Kedar, INN

In Israel, and in much of the Western world, we tend to think that the Arab world is united in support of the Palestinians, that it  wants nothing so much as to solve the Palestinian problem by giving them a state, and that all the Arabs and Muslims love the Palestinians and hate Israel.

This, however, is a simplistic and partial point of view, because while it is true that many, perhaps even the majority of Arabs and Muslims hate Israel, there are a good many who hate the Palestinians just as much.

Their hatred of Israel stems from Israel’s success in surviving despite wars, terror, boycotts and the enmity aimed at the Jewish state; it stems from  the fact that there is an existing Jewish state even though Judaism has been superseded by Islam, the ‘true religion.’ It is exacerbated by Israel’s being a democracy while they live under  dictatorships, because Israel is rich and they are poor, because Israel is Paradise compared to Arab countries, many of which resemble nothing so much as the last train stop before Hell (see Syria, Iraq, Libya, Yemen, Sudan – and the list goes on) …and most importantly, because Israel has succeeded in areas in which they have failed, and their jealousy drives them up a wall.

But why should they hate the ‘unfortunate’ Palestinian Arabs? After all, the Arab narrative says that the Palestinian Arabs’ land was stolen and they were forced to become refugees. The answer to this question is complex and is a function of  Middle Eastern culture, which we in Israel and most Westerners neither understand nor recognize.

One of the worst things in Arab eyes is being cheated, fooled or taken advantage of. When someone attempts to cheat an Arab – and even more so, if that person succeeds – an Arab is overcome by furious anger, even if the person involved is his cousin. He will call on his brother to take revenge on that cousin, in line with the Arab adage: “My brother and I against my cousin – and my brother, my cousin and I against a stranger.”

Regarding the Palestinian Arabs, first of all,  many are not originally Palestinians at all. They are immigrants who came to the Land of Israel from all over the Arab world during the British Mandate in order to find employment in the cities and on the farms the Jews had built.  These immigrants still have names such as “Al Hurani (from Huran in southern Syria)”, “Al Tzurani (from Tyre in Southern Lebanon)”, “Al  Zrakawi (from Mazraka in Jordan),” “Al Maztri (the Egyptian)” and many other names that point to the actual, geographically varied origins of the so-called Palestinians. Why, ask the other Arabs, should they get preferential treatment compared to those who remained in their original countries?

Starting with the end of the 1948 Israeli War of Independence, the politics in the Arab world began to center on Israel and the “Palestinian problem” whose solution was to be achieved only by eliminating Israel. In order to help succeed in that mission, the Arab refugees were kept in camps, with explicit instructions from the Arab League to  keep them there and not to absorb them in other  Arab countries.

UNRWA ensured that they were provided with food, education and medical care without charge – that is to say, the nations of the world footed the bill, while the Arab neighbors of these eternal “refugees” had to work and provide food, education and medical care for their families by the sweat of their brow.  Refugees who were supplied with free foodstuffs, such as rice, flour, sugar and oil, for the use of their families, would often sell some  of it to their non-refugee neighbors and make a tidy profit.

Those living in the refugee camps do not pay municipal taxes, leading to a significant number of “refugees” who rent their homes to others and  collect exorbitant sums in comparison with those renting apartments in nearby cities, thanks to this tax exemption. In other  words, the world subsidizes the taxes and the refugees line their own pockets .

In Lebanon, several refugee camps were built near Beirut, but were incorporated into the expanding city, then turned into high class neighborhoods with imposing high rise apartment buildings. Someone has profited from this change, and it is not the man in the  street, who has every reason to feel cheated.

The Palestinian “refugee” camps located in Lebanon have been taken over by armed organizations, from the PLO to ISIS, including Hamas, the Popular Front, the Democratic Front and organizations of Salafist Jihadists. These organizations act viciously towards surrounding Lebanese citizens and in 1975 brought on a civil war that  lasted for 14 long  years of bloodshed, destruction and saw the emigration of hundreds of thousands of Lebanese from their villages to lives of horrible suffering in tent camps all over the country’ Many took  refuge in Palestinian “refugee” camps, but the Lebanese refugees received less than 10 per cent of what  Palestinian Arabs received, causing much internecine jealousy  and hatred.

In Jordan, in 1970, the Palestinian Arabs, led by PLO head Yassir Arafat, attempted to take over the country by establishing autonomous regions of their own, complete with roadblocks and armed Palestinian Arabs in the country’s north that challenged the monarchy. In September 1970, known as “Black September”, King Hussein decided he had had enough and would show them who is boss in Jordan. The  war he declared against  them cost thousands of  lives on both sides.

Meanwhile, in Israel,  20% of the citizenry within the pre-1967 borders is made up of “Palestinian” Arabs who do not rebel or fight against the state. In other words, the “Palestinians” living in pre-1967 Israel enjoy life in the only democracy in the Middle East, while the Arab countries sacrifice their soldiers’ blood to liberate “Palestine.” Is there a worse case of feeling that you are being exploited than that of an Arab soldier putting his life in danger for this meaningless cause?

Worse still is what every Arab knows: Palestinian Arabs have been selling land to Jews for at least a century, profit immensely from the deals and then go wailing to their Arab brothers to come and free “Palestine” from the “Zionist occupation.”

Over the years, the Palestinian Arabs were given many billions of euros and dollars by the nations of the world, so that the yearly per capirta income in the PA is several times greater than that of the Egyptian, Sudanese or Algerian man in the street. His life is many, many times better than that of Arabs living in Syria, Iraq, Libya and Yemen over the past seven years.

On a political level, the Palestinians have managed to arouse the hatred of many of their Arab brethren: In 1990, Arafat supported Saddam Hussein’s Iraqi invasion of Kuwait. In revenge, Kuwait, once it was freed of Iraqi conquest, expelled tens of thousands of Palestinians, most of whom had been employed in its oil fields, leaving them destitute overnight. This led to an economic crisis for their families in Judea, Samaria and Gaza, who had been receiving regular stipends from their sons in Kuwait.

Today, Hamas and the Palestinian Islamic Jihad are supported by Iran, the country abhorred by many Arabs who remember that airplane hijacking and the ensuing blackmail were invented by the Palestinian Arabs who hijacked an El Al plane to Algiers in 1968, fifty years ago, beginning a period of travail still being endured by the entire world.

Despite the 1989 Taaf agreement that ended the civil war in Lebanon and was supposed to lead to the de-weaponization and dissolution of all the Lebanese militias, Syria  allowed Hezbollah to keep its arms  and to develop its military power unrestrainedly. The repeated excuse was that the weapons were meant to “liberate Palestine” and would not be aimed at the Lebanese. To anyone with a modicum of brains, it was clear that  the Palestine story was a fig leaf covering the sad truth that the weapons were going to be aimed at Hezbollah’s Syrian and Lebanese enemies. “Palestine” was simply an excuse for the Shiite takeover of Lebanon.

Worst of all is the Palestinian demand that Arab countries refrain from any relations with Israel until the Palestinian problem is solved to the satisfaction of the PLO and Hamas leaders. However, a good  portion of the Arab world cannot find any commonalities that could unite the PLO and  Hamas. They have given up on achieving an internal Palestinian reconciliation, watching the endless squabbles ruin any chances of progress regarding Israel. To sum up the situation, the Arab world – that part of it which sees Israel as the only hope in dealing with Iran – is not happy at the expectation that it must  mortgage its future and  its very existence to the internal fighting between the PLO  and Hamas.

And let us not forget that Egypt and Jordan have signed peace agreements with Israel, have moved outside the circle of war for the “liberation of Palestine” and have  forsaken their Palestinian Arab “brothers,” leaving them to deal with the problem on their own.

Much of the Arab and Muslim world is convinced that the “Palestinians” do not want a state of their own. After all, if that state is established, the  world will cease to donate those enormous sums, there will be no more “refugees” and the Palestinian Arabs will have to work like everyone else. How can they do that when they are all addicted  to receiving handouts without any strings attacked?

One can say with assurance, that 70 years after the creation of the “Palestinian problem,” the Arab world has realized that there is no solution that  will satisfy those who have  turned “refugee-ism”  into a profession, so that the “Palestinian problem” has  become an emotional and financial scam that only serves to enrich the corrupt leaders of Ramallah and Gaza.

Dr. Mordechai Kedar is a senior lecturer in the Department of Arabic at Bar-Ilan University. He served in IDF Military Intelligence for 25 years, specializing in Arab political discourse, Arab mass media, Islamic groups and the Syrian domestic arena. Thoroughly familiar with Arab media in real time, he is frequently interviewed on the various news programs in Israel.

Translated by Rochel Sylvetsky, Senior Consultant to A7 English site, Op-ed and Judaism editor.

March 5, 2018 | 3 Comments »

Leave a Reply

3 Comments / 3 Comments

  1. @ Sebastien Zorn:
    Nope. other way around, though I hadn’t read his article. Amazing coincidence. His article came out March 3, at 10:05, my comment was posted March 3 at 10:49, just 45 minutes later. You get the original article if you click on his name in red. Wow.

  2. Interesting that he raises the funding. The pals in camps are usually portrayed as oppressed. In Battleground, Samuel Katz wrote about how nobody really demanded verification of actual refugee status in 1948 and many people who hadn’t gone anywhere claimed to be refugees to get the benefits. And just a couple of days before this article came out I responded to a comment to Caroline Glick’s article about Israeli gun laws as follows. I wonder if he read my comment and thought of writing this as it is unusual and the timing is close.

    MARCH 2, 2018 (4 DAYS AGO) AT 11:08 AM
    Make Israel a gun free zone and there will be no more Israel. Liberals will never learn, there is something wrong in their cognitive abilities.

    Sebastien Zorn
    MARCH 3, 2018 (3 DAYS AGO) AT 10:43 AM
    @ Russell:
    Oh, I don’t know. I think a gun free zone might be a good thing. A lot of people can’t afford to buy a gun, you know? Free guns, free food, free rent. But, then I’m an ex-anarchist, you know, as if you hadn’t guessed — before I was an ex-marxist. A guy can dream.
    But, seriously folks, I think Israel has it down just right. If it aint broke, don’t fix it, you know?

    Sebastien Zorn
    MARCH 3, 2018 (3 DAYS AGO) AT 10:59 AM
    @ Sebastien Zorn:
    Oooh, ouch! I just thought about it. Free guns, free food, free rent = UNRWA.


    Mebbe Not such a good idea, after all.

    Once again, back to the drawing board, dear friends.

    Next, please.”

  3. The usual masterly article we have come to expect from this writer. I recall the Lebanese situation very well. When about 120,000 Arabs from Israel moved in to Lebanon, after time they became aggressive, and war broke out between them and the Christians.

    At that time Lebanon had achieved a nice balance as the Christian and Moslem populations, being the main part of the population, (although there were Druze, Circassians and others there also), had a nicely worked out system. The President, by law was always a Christian, and the PM, by law was always a Muslim.

    Eventually the Muslim Lebanese and the Christian Lebanese were drawn into the original dispute and it became a Civil war. After a few years, the newly elected President, Bashir Jemayel and about 25 of his close associates were murdered by a bomb placed in their headquarters. And it deteriorated further and became even more bitter. A few years later later, the war going all all this time, came the event of the Sabra and Shatilla refugee camps, which caused such turmoil amongst the Israeli leaders, resulting in Commissions of enquiry where a few Israeli heads fell, etc.

    It was said that the Camps massacre was in retaliation for the assassination of Jemayel and his associates, and the more recent slaughter of a complete Christian town by the Moslems, mainly Arabs from Israel, so-called refugees. It seems that they attacked a Christian town called Damour, slaughtered all the inhabitants, locked the remaining 350 in a Church and set it on fire. One of the leaders of those who went into Sabra and Shatilla was Elie Hobeika, whose whole family has perished in the Damour church along with his fiance.

    The war ended in 1982, with the Moslem side in the ascendancy, destroying the traditional balance for all intents and purposes, with a new “partner” more or less in control, the terrorist entity Hezbollah organised, sponsored funded and trained by Iran, and deadly enemies of Israel sworn to our destruction.
    By 1983 Arafat and his terrorists in a separate operation had been trapped in Beirut, where an agreement was made that the whole Fatah terrorist gang, over 10,000, would leave for exile in Tunisia. Then came the 1993 disaster of Oslo which brought them back, gave them free, our precious territory, weapons, training, money, AND ACCEPTED STATUS…setting off the worst terrorist waves of attacks in Israel’s history murdering thousands of Israeli civilians and wounding thousands more many horribly..

    The country has not forgiven the Labour Party foe having done this, and I hope it never will.

    I have glossed over the larger content of the article preferring to post on what was most prominent in my mind about that period. Others, no doubt will have much to say about the main focus of the excellent article.