Netanyahu maintains de facto freeze. Why?

Why must Ma’aleh Adumim and Ariel beg PM to okay new building especially now that the freeze has ended, right? Wrong. Maybe its because if we build international pressure mounts. Or maybe its because Netanyahu is trying to do a peace deal that allows for the loss of these communities. A statement released by Netanyahu’s office after he met with Mubarak, quoted the prime minister as saying an agreement with the Palestinians was possible if they were willing to “end the conflict.” Sounds like he is ready to give away the farm.

    Ma’aleh Adumim, along with Betar Illit and Modi’in Illit, the largest three Jewish West Bank communities, have consistently fueled the bulk of settlement growth for the last 14 years.

    Last year, according to the Central Bureau of Statistics, 58% of all finished homes in the settlements were in those three cities alone.

    But Kashriel has warned, and continues to warn, that this kind of growth is about to come to a halt.

    The state budget, which the Knesset approved last week, set aside funds for 200 new homes in Ma’aleh Adumim, but according to the Construction and Housing Ministry, the project cannot move forward until it receives the approval of the Defense Ministry.

    Sources in the Construction and Housing Ministry said that such approval was not likely to be granted in the near future, because no approval was being given at present for projects in West Bank settlements.

    The funds that were approved for Ma’aleh Adumim construction, the sources said, allow the ministry to do preparatory work so the construction can move forward should Defense Minister Ehud Barak sign off on it.

    Kashriel, however, said he did not believe Barak intended to authorize that project or any new construction in his city.

    Last year, 509 new homes were finished in Ma’aleh Adumim, according to the Central Bureau of Statistics. As of September, work was under way on 102 homes. According to Peace Now, as of mid-November, work had begun on only 24 additional homes.

    In spite of the pending silent freeze, Kashriel has kept his campaign fairly quiet. Betar Illit, which is also out of permits, has not publicly spoken out against the issue.

    However, Ariel, the fourthlargest West Bank city, has embarked on an active campaign for more permits. Unlike in the three larger cities, the government has no large construction projects in Ariel.

    From 1996-2009, 4,844 homes were built in Ma’aleh Adumim, 6,725 in Modi’in Illit and 5,430 in Betar Illit. But in that same period, as a result of a lack of construction approvals, only 1,220 homes were built in Ariel.

    This year, 86 new homes were finished and 97 were under construction as of the end of September, according to the Central Bureau of Statistics.

    According to the November Peace Now report, work had begun on 56 more homes since September.

    This week, Ariel Mayor Ron Nachman published an ad in Haaretz with signatures from Kadima activists and local politicians calling for an end to the silent freeze of Ariel. He also set up a website so Likud activists could sign a petition in favor of building in Ariel.

    Separately, in a letter, he asked Netanyahu to strip Barak of the power to authorize construction in Judea and Samaria.

    The letter was signed by a number of Judea and Samaria regional council heads.

    He also embarked on a campaign against the defense minister, under the slogan, “Barak will not abuse Ariel.”

    Large signs to this effect could be seen hanging by the side of the road in Jerusalem this week.

    Ariel Municipality spokeswoman Chen Kedem said the cumulative effect of the lack of construction permits had given city residents the feeling that they were fighting for their very existence.

January 9, 2011 | 4 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest

Leave a Reply

4 Comments / 4 Comments

  1. drjb:

    If our companies can’t build for Jews they will build for Arabs
    Rawabi Builder Adds Fuel:“100” Israeli Companies Want to Join Up

    Israel’s Housing Bubble set to pop
    Jan 7, 2010

    Maoz: Fischer ignored real estate bubble he created
    Excellence chief economist Shlomo Maoz expects interest rate to reach higher levels in 2010 than consensus estimates.

    Mortgage market booming while interest rates are low
    Mortgage borrowing spiraled upward by dozens of percentage points in June to the highest level in almost a year.

  2. drjb says:
    January 9, 2011 at 11:05 pm


    A lot of Questions but I do know this:

    The law of supply and demand where the demand outstrips supply, pushes prices upwards. That makes all housing and commercial property a more valuable asset. Can’t afford to buy rent, so the rents go up, inflation goes up accordingly etcetc and we have our own little Bubble. Freezing for the past few years have created housing and rental scarcities. It’s all artificial.

    Housing prices continue to rise

    Israel Property Market May Lose Top Ranking on Rates (Update2)
    CBS data shows that since the beginning of the year home prices have jumped 15%.

  3. Yamit,
    maybe you can explain.
    I keep on reading numbers of construction starts which are meaningless to me. Approvals of projects that don’t tell me a thing. What I need to know, and hopefully you can explain, is how much of a housing shortage has been created by this freeze. How many people are waiting for housing in Yehuda and Shomron and Jerusalem? How big is the backlog and how long would it take to process it if construction were to restart unabated? What are the top five communities most affected by the freeze? where is demand for housing highest? Although I fully disagree, on principle, with the building freeze, this info will help me put this building freeze in its proper context in terms of how many people it is affecting.

  4. Some people believe what people close to or in actual positions of political power tell them. I’ve lived here to long to be that gullible and rely on past records of those who count most, never their public declarations and never by Israeli politicians. People do not change their basic Characters especially when they are highly defective characters.

    I remember someone criticizing my criticism of BB by saying “but he is preventing Livni from gaining the premiership.”

    I said I prefer an honest Livni whom I oppose than a liar and corrupt PM like BB whose agenda is little different than Livni’s.

    I stand by that statement.

    That you believed BB had ended the freeze speaks volumns.