Why Does No One Object to Having Eight Officially Islamic States but Apparently Cannot Tolerate One Small Jewish State?

by Nils A. Haug •  Gatestone Institute  •  November 29, 2025

On November 10, 2025, Israel's President Isaac Herzog unapologetically stated that Zionism is "the national liberation movement of the Jewish people; a return to an indigenous homeland after millennia of persecution." Pictured: Herzog addresses a Joint Meeting of Congress in the House Chamber of the US Capitol in Washington, DC, on July 19, 2023. Screengrab via Youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNgva778ID0On November 10, 2025, Israel’s President Isaac Herzog unapologetically stated that Zionism is “the national liberation movement of the Jewish people; a return to an indigenous homeland after millennia of persecution.” Pictured: Herzog addresses a Joint Meeting of Congress in the House Chamber of the US Capitol in Washington, DC, on July 19, 2023. Screengrab via Youtube

  • Jewish have been rooted to Israel (Zion) for nearly 4,000 years….
  • Israel’s immediate enemy is violent extremist Islam — particularly the brand espoused by ideological offshoots of the Muslim Brotherhood such as Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis, Qatar, Syria and Iran. Their worldview seems to be that “Islam is a faith and a ritual, a nation and a nationality, a religion and a state, spirit and deed, holy text and sword.”

  • The world is not just getting less safe for Jews. It is also rapidly becoming less safe for Christians, Hindus and Muslims deemed by other Muslims not Muslim enough. Unfortunately, many in the West appear not to believe that yet. Meanwhile, the doctrines of the Muslim Brotherhood are being spread throughout Europe and Canada, and most recently in New York, Michigan, Minnesota, Texas, the heart of America, and Australia.
  • “To place any religion beyond criticism just because some Muslims may feel offended is to ignore, as Salman Rushdie puts it, ‘the battle against fanatical Islam, which is highly organised, well-funded, and which seeks to terrify us all, Muslims as well as non-Muslims, into cowed silence’.” — Quadrant,, September 16, 2025.
  • When the Third Reich pushed people into gas showers, or during the massacres of October 7, 2023, no one asked the victims if they were “rightist,” “leftist,” or “centrist.” For the Jews, Christians and other “infidels,” although many seem not to believe it yet, the choice is all or nothing: either survival or elimination. In this respect, Zionism – the safety of Israel – is the for persecuted Jews, the only sanctuary.
  • If Jews are to be criticized for defending their minute piece of real estate on Earth, so be it: they hold the moral high ground; their critics and enemies do not.

On November 10, 2025, Israel’s President Isaac Herzog unapologetically stated that Zionism is “the national liberation movement of the Jewish people; a return to an indigenous homeland after millennia of persecution.”

This statement follows the response of his father, Chaim Herzog (then Israel’s Ambassador to the United Nations) in 1975 to an antagonistic UN General Assembly on its shameful resolution that “Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination”:

“Zionism is nothing more – and nothing less – than the Jewish people’s sense of origin and destination in the land linked eternally with its name.”

Continue Reading Article

November 29, 2025 | 4 Comments »

Leave a Reply

4 Comments / 4 Comments

  1. I absolutely hate when someone compares “Islamic” with “Jewish”.
    Jew is a nation. A better word is Israelite.
    So Israel is a national state of Jewish people. And even in the Bible we are described as a people. And God it telling us that we are “a people”. A bad people, good people, hard necked people, people who dwell alone, but PEOPLE.
    So we are a people not a religion.
    Get this, because RELIGIONS DO NOT DESERVE A STATE.
    RELIGIONS DON’T HAVE A NATIONAL HOME.

    This one confusion is why so many people object to Israel. They think well, Southern Baptists don’t have a country, neither do Methodists. Buddhist, don’t have a country neither do any other religion.
    So therefore Jews don’t need a country either.

    You want to change that, stop talking about Jews being a religion.

    Scots are a nation. They may or may not believe in their Loch Ness Monster and Leprechaunes. But whether they believe or not, they are Scots and their national home is Scotland.

  2. ” What country is 100% Islamic?
    AI Overview

    +3
    The Maldives is widely considered the only country in the world where 100% of the population is Muslim, a status reinforced by its 2008 constitution which requires citizenship to be based on adherence to Islam. Other nations like Mauritania have a population that is 100% Muslim, according to some sources, though the Maldives is more consistently cited as being entirely Muslim due to the legal requirement.
    The Maldives: Officially the Republic of Maldives, this island nation has a 100% Muslim population, as mandated by its 2008 constitution which links citizenship to the Islamic faith. Islam has been the central religion for centuries, and the country’s laws reflect its significance.
    Mauritania: Some sources list Mauritania as another country with a 100% Muslim population, with most identifying as Sunni Muslims. It is an Islamic Republic with Islam as its state religion. ”

    AI Overview

  3. ” People also ask
    Are there 57 Islamic countries?
    Member states of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation
    Created 1969
    Number 57 members (49 Muslim majority and 8 Christian majority) 5 observer states (3 non-Muslim majority and 2 Muslim majority) Several non-Muslim member/observer candidates (as of 2025)
    Possible types Republics (47) Monarchies (10)
    Populations 2.04 billion
    2 more rows
    https://en.wikipedia.org
    Member states of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation – Wikipedia”

    How about an Organization of Jewish Cooperation (OJC)?