A revolt against American influence

Ted Belman

Hussein Agha, a senior associate member of St. Antony’s College, Oxford University, is a co-author of “A Framework for a Palestinian National Security Doctrine.” Robert Malley is the Middle East program director at the International Crisis Group and was special assistant to President Bill Clinton for Arab-Israeli affairs.

These very experienced hands see in In post-Mubarak Egypt, the rebirth of the Arab world

The problem they say is

    The Arab leadership has proved passive and, when active, powerless. Where it once championed a string of lost causes – pan-Arab unity, defiance of the West, resistance to Israel – it now fights for nothing. There was more popular pride in yesterday’s setbacks than in today’s stupor.

    Arab states suffer from a curse more debilitating than poverty or autocracy. They have become counterfeit, perceived by their own people as alien, pursuing policies hatched from afar. One cannot fully comprehend the actions of Egyptians, Tunisians, Jordanians and others without considering this deep-seated feeling that they have not been allowed to be themselves, that they have been robbed of their identities.

They go on to conclude,

    For the United States, the popular upheaval lays bare the fallacy of an approach that relies on Arab leaders who mimic the West’s deeds and parrot its words, and that only succeeds in discrediting the regimes without helping Washington. The more the United States gave to the Mubarak regime, the more it lost Egypt. Arab leaders have been put on notice: A warm relationship with the United States and a peace deal with Israel will not save you in your hour of need.

    Injecting economic assistance into faltering regimes will not work. The grievance Arab peoples feel is not principally material, and one of its main targets is over-reliance on the outside. U.S. calls for reform will likewise fall flat. A messenger who has backed the status quo for decades is a poor voice for change. Attempts to pressure regimes can backfire, allowing rulers to depict protests as Western-inspired and opposition leaders as foreign stooges.

    Some policymakers in Western capitals have convinced themselves that seizing the moment to promote the Israeli-Palestinian peace process will placate public opinion. This is to engage in both denial and wishful thinking. It ignores that Arabs have become estranged from current peace efforts; they believe that such endeavors reflect a foreign rather than a national agenda. And it presumes that a peace agreement acceptable to the West and to Arab leaders will be acceptable to the Arab public, when in truth, it is more likely to be seen as an unjust imposition and denounced as the liquidation of a cherished cause. A peace effort intended to salvage order will accelerate its demise.

    The Arab world’s transition from old to new is rife with uncertainty about its pace and endpoint. When and where transitions take place, they will express a yearning for more assertiveness. Governments will have to change their spots; their publics will wish them to be more like Turkey and less like Egypt.

    For decades, the Arab world has been drained of its sovereignty, its freedom, its pride. It has been drained of politics. Today marks politics’ revenge.

February 14, 2011 | 3 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest

Leave a Reply

3 Comments / 3 Comments

  1. “Some ideas are so stupid that only intellectuals can believe them”(Quote from George Orwell).
    These Arab intellectuals,if that is what you want to call them,are suffering from mass delusions.These people suffer from delusions of grandeur brought on by a completely false interpretation of reality & their place in this reality.Bluntly,they are either crazy fools Or liars or both!(1)They blame the western powers for empowering the despots who ruled them.Maybe this was true after WW1.But this has not been the case since the 1950’s.The Moslem world,excluding the oil states,are in the process of becoming failed states.Islamic nations cannot cope with modern reality,they can’t meet the needs of their ever expanding populations(2)This loudmouth complains about western influences in the Arab world.Western influence also brings food & aid without which the Arab world will starve.(3)We supported the tyrant Mubarak.Who were we supposed to support?Mubarak was a completely Egyptian dictator,he wasn’t an American or Israeli creation.We didn’t put him in power,the Egyptian power elite did,blame them.Oil is all that the Arabs have,without oil they are all on the level of Somalia or Yemen.When the oil runs out,so will the clock run out for the Arabs.(4)do these Arab”intellectuals”seriously believe that the hungry,semi literate & brutalized mobs in the streets can be remade.That miraculously they can be made into a modern society of free men in a free country.They can yell & scream all they want.The fact is that the day they drive out western influence & aid will be the day the lights start to go out for the Arab world!