Free Palestine” is  a powerful slogan aimed at dismantling the West

Harry Liberman

Is This the End of the Western Tradition?

Across London, Paris, New York, Michigan, and Texas, a convergence of street-level disputes, rising asylum expenditures, rapid labor automation, and changing local demographics is testing the foundational institutions of Western democracies. Whether these pressures represent a temporary crisis of governance or an irreversible shift in the Western legal and civic tradition has become one of the defining debates of the modern era.

Free Palestine” is  a powerful slogan aimed at dismantling the West: 

The ideological alignments between anti-Zionist activist groups, Marxist-Leninist organizations, and Islamist movements such as Hamas. In this view, attacking Israel—the sole liberal democracy in the Middle East—serves as a proxy for delegitimizing Western constitutionalism, national borders, and Judeo-Christian heritage.

The  United States and Israel share a foundational commitment to individual liberty, private property, rule of law, and national sovereignty rooted in the Judeo-Christian tradition.Marxism, socialism, European social democracy, and political Islamism —despite their ideological differences—share a collectivist premise that subordinates individual agency to class identity, state bureaucracy, or religious law.

Currently The Test of the Western Tradition is Failing Miserably :  

Across London, Paris, New York, Michigan, and Texas, a convergence of street-level disputes, rising asylum expenditures, rapid labor automation, and changing local demographics is testing the foundational institutions of Western democracies. Whether these pressures represent a temporary crisis of governance or a lasting shift in the Western legal and civic tradition has become one of the defining debates of the modern era.

Historical Origins and Governance Models

Western Judeo- Christendom antithetical to Islam :

The  modern legal differences: Church-State Separation vs. Religious Governance.

Christianity spread during its first three centuries as a non-state minority movement within the Roman Empire before Emperor Constantine issued the Edict of Milan in 313 CE. Over subsequent centuries, Western civilization evolved through Roman civil law, the separation of church and state, the Enlightenment, and constitutional democracy—foundations that underpinned the Scientific and Industrial Revolutions.

Conversely, following the migration to Medina in 622 CE, Muhammad established both a religious community and a political-military state, expanding across the Arabian Peninsula through diplomacy and military campaigns (Encyclopaedia Britannica biography of Muhammad). Classical Islamic governance integrated religious law (Sharia) directly into state administration across the Rashidun, Umayyad, Abbasid, and Ottoman empires (Encyclopaedia Britannica Caliphate record).

Legal Asymmetry Today

According to the Pew Research Center, approximately 50 countries have Muslim-majority populations, representing roughly one-quarter of United Nations member states. In several of these states, statutory law explicitly restricts non-Muslims: for example, Pakistan’s Constitution bars non-Muslims from serving as President or Prime Minister while enforcing strict blasphemy laws and administrative hurdles on minority places of worship (U.S. State Department International Religious Freedom Report). By contrast, Western legal systems operate under secular equality statutes—such as the UK Equality Act 2010—that guarantee equal rights regardless of faith, creating an open civic environment that critics argue is vulnerable when paired with uneven enforcement.

Global Literacy and Asymmetric Migration Flows

Demographic and economic records highlight sharp contrasts between Western democracies and developing or conflict-affected nations:

Literacy and Development

According to World Bank literacy data, adult literacy rates across the Middle East and North Africa have risen to roughly 80%–85% overall (exceeding 95% in wealthy Gulf states, while remaining substantially lower in conflict-affected nations such as Yemen and Afghanistan). Meanwhile, Western democracies and East Asian economies continue to lead global rankings in per-capita GDP, scientific output, and technological innovation.

One-Way Migration Patterns

Data from the UN International Organization for Migration (IOM)confirms a predominantly one-way permanent migration flow from developing and conflict-affected nations—including many Muslim-majority states—toward North America and Western Europe. Aside from temporary expatriate contract labor in Gulf Cooperation Council states (such as the UAE and Qatar), non-Muslims rarely migrate permanently to Muslim-majority countries.

Local Flashpoints: London, Paris, Michigan, New York, and Texas

The intersection of global migration trends with domestic law and local politics is visible across several Western jurisdictions:

London and Paris

In West London in 2026, Sikh restaurateur Harman Singh Kapoor displayed signs at his restaurant, Rangrez, stating “Proudly we don’t sell halal,” reflecting his adherence to jhatka meat. Following protests, egg-pelting, and threats outside his venue, Metropolitan Police detained Kapoor on suspicion of carrying a bladed article—his ceremonial Sikh kirpan, which is legally exempt under Section 139 of the UK Criminal Justice Act 1988—and released him without charge, prompting Kapoor to file legal action against the Metropolitan Police and the Mayor of London.

In both London and Paris

—where widespread street unrest and looting erupted in autumn 2026 amid broader political and economic tensions—independent videographer Nate Friedman has drawn millions of views filming street demonstrations and neighborhood shifts. Meanwhile, UK institutions continue to reckon with Baroness Louise Casey’s June 2025 National Audit on Group-based Child Sexual Exploitation and Abuse, which confirmed thousands of children suffered exploitation while local officials hesitated to examine offender ethnicity out of fear of damaging community relations.

Michigan and New York

In the United States, demographic shifts have reshaped local and national electoral coalitions. According to U.S. Census Bureau data, Dearborn, Michigan became the first major U.S. city with an Arab-American majority, making Arab and Muslim voters a decisive bloc in Michigan‘s state and federal elections (Pew Research Center on Muslim American voters). In New York City, municipal budgets have absorbed over $9.7 billion in cumulative emergency shelter and service costs for asylum seekers since fiscal year 2023 (New York State Comptroller asylum seeker spending report).

Texas and the EPIC City Lawsuits

In North Texas, plans by the East Plano Islamic Center (EPIC) to build a 400-acre master-planned Muslim-oriented residential and commercial community—initially marketed as “EPIC City”—triggered federal Department of Justice civil rights reviews (U.S. Senate announcement on DOJ investigation) and state enforcement lawsuits by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton alleging securities violations and unlawful religious exclusivity (Texas Attorney General lawsuit release).

Fiscal Deficits, Labor Automation, and Foreign Influence

While Western governments frequently justify high immigration as an economic necessity to offset low birth rates, fiscal and technological data reveals sharp contradictions:

Asylum Costs and AI Displacement

According to UK government immigration factsheets, total asylum support cost British taxpayers £4 billion in the 2024/25 financial year alone, including £5.5 million per day on asylum hotels. Data from Eurostat confirms that males accounted for roughly two-thirds of EU asylum applications in 2025, with men aged 18–34 forming the largest cohort. Longitudinal studies by the Dutch and Danish Ministries of Finance demonstrate that while Western and high-skilled immigrants generate a net tax surplus, non-Western asylum seekers and family-reunification migrants represent a net lifetime fiscal deficit. Simultaneously, newly arrived migrants are heavily concentrated in app-based delivery, rideshare driving, warehousing, and retail—sectors identified by OECD employment assessments as facing rapid displacement from autonomous vehicles and robotics.

Free Speech and Foreign State Funding and the assassins veto : 

High-profile violence against critics—including the 1989 Iranian fatwa against Salman Rushdie (stabbed in New York in 2022), the 2004 murder of Theo van Gogh, the 2015 Charlie Hebdo attack, and the 2021 police-protected hiding of a teacher at Batley Grammar School—has entrenched self-censorship. In January 2026, the United Arab Emirates removed all UK universities from its state scholarship list over campus radicalization concerns. Meanwhile, U.S. Department of Education disclosures identify Qatar as the largest single foreign state donor to American universities, alongside the 2022 Qatargate investigation in the European Parliament.

Political leaders and foreign donors are intentionally eroding Western legal norms, while institutional defenders maintain that these challenges reflect uncoordinated policy and bureaucratic failures. Regardless of intent, preserving the Western tradition requires enforcing a single standard of secular law, aligning immigration with fiscal and technological realities, and ensuring full transparency over foreign influence.

A central pressure point facing Western democracies is the erosion of free expression through what legal scholars and free-speech organizations call the assassin’s veto—the curtailment of lawful speech driven by fear of violent retaliation. As documented by PEN America, this phenomenon spans decades of high-profile attacks against writers, filmmakers, and educators:

From Rushdie to Charlie Hebdo and Batley.Violent reprisals include the 1989 Iranian fatwa against author Salman Rushdie (who survived a near-fatal stabbing in New York in 2022), the 2004 murder of Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh in Amsterdam, and the 2015 massacre at the Paris offices of Charlie Hebdo. In 2021, a teacher at Batley Grammar School in England was forced into police-protected hiding after showing a caricature of the Prophet Muhammad in class.

Street Unrest Across Western Cities. These free-speech tensions coincide with recurring civil unrest, campus encampments, and violent street demonstrations across European capitals, Canadian cities, and major U.S. jurisdictions—including New York, Michigan, and California—where protesters and agitators have repeatedly clashed with police and disrupted civic institutions.

Campus Radicalization and Foreign State Funding. In January 2026, the United Arab Emirates removed all UK universities from its state-funded scholarship list, citing concerns over Islamist radicalization on British campuses. Meanwhile, U.S. Department of Education disclosures identify Qatar as the largest single foreign state donor to American universities—contributing over $1.1 billion in 2025 alone and over $6 billion in cumulative reported gifts and contracts—alongside the 2022 Qatargate investigation in the European Parliament, where Belgian federal police seized over €1.5 million in cash linked to alleged foreign influence operations.

Competing Assessments and the Path Forward

Political leaders and foreign donors are intentionally eroding Western legal norms, while institutional defenders maintain that these challenges reflect uncoordinated policy, economic, and bureaucratic failures. Regardless of intent, preserving the Western tradition requires enforcing a single standard of secular law, rejecting violent intimidation against lawful speech, aligning immigration with fiscal and technological realities, and ensuring strict transparency over foreign funding in Western institutions.

Victor Davis Hanson is an American classicist, military historian, and conservative political commentator who serves as the Martin and Illie Anderson Senior Fellow in Residence in Classics and Military History at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution. His prominence in foreign policy debates stems from his academic background in military history alongside his decades of syndicated commentary, though historians and political analysts hold differing views on his contemporary policy arguments. [1, 2]

He is the author or editor of more than 20 books on ancient warfare, military strategy, and political history. Notable military history titles include The Western Way of War (1989), Carnage and Culture (2001), A War Like No Other (2005), The Savior Generals (2013), and The End of Everything: How Wars Descend Into Annihilation(2024). [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]

Hanson’s foreign policy views—including conservative policymakers and defense commentators—point to his formal training in classical military strategy, his chairing of the Hoover Institution’s Military History Working Group, and his longitudinal study of deterrence and civilizational conflict as valuable frameworks for analyzing modern adversaries like Iran. [1, 2]

In columns such as In the End, Everyone Hated the Iranian Theocracy and his 2026 video commentaries, Hanson outlines why Trump’s approach to Iran is  decisive for U.S. national security:Hanson argues that for nearly five decades, successive U.S. administrations failed to stop Iran’s regional proxy warfare and nuclear development. By authorizing joint U.S.–Israeli strikes on Iranian nuclear and missile sites, Hanson contends Trump shattered the regime’s aura of invincibility and restored American deterrence.[1, 2]

Following the November 2026 midterm elections, Hanson noted in his broadcast commentary that Trump accepted short-term political costs—such as temporary fuel price increases—because preventing a nuclear-armed Iran was essential for long-term U.S. survival. [1]

Israpundit is entirely dependent on readers support. Please help me continue educating people with the truth about what is going on in Israel and around the world.

USD:

ILS:

CDN:

November 17, 2026 | Comments »

Leave a Reply