PELONI: Israel’s Minister of Diaspora and Combating Antisemitism, Amichai Chikli, offers an important reflection on the vital element inherent in the Zionist enterprise: that the eternity of Israel is an extension of our Jewish faith, that it is greater than any political identity, and that it must be secured by a sense of unity around the survival of the nation as the paramount concern of the Jewish people – something that, in the current moment, risks being reduced to a secondary theme. He approaches this through the life of David Ben-Gurion, a man whose greatness is inseparable from his flaws which included the persecution of his Revisionist camp rivals and his role in the Altalena Massacre, chapters which the author names without flinching while also insisting that honoring Ben-Gurion’s life’s work does not require erasing them. Despite this, as Chikli masterfully explains, Ben-Gurion recognized the vital necessity of pressing on the youth of his age the need for vigilance against a national identity that severs itself from the Jewish heritage that sustained the people in exile. His warning was not that survival itself would be forgotten, but that the deep roots – rabbinic literature, prayer, custom, the historical memory between the Bible and the state – would be bypassed in the rush to build a “new Jew” drawn in a straight line from Torah to Palmach. While we are home in these lands, Chikli reminds us, we must not divest the basis of our presence as an extension of our Jewish identity, as both a people and a nation in our ancestral land.
Amichai Chikli | X
Click Image to Enlarge. Image created via AI.
One hundred and forty years have passed since David Ben-Gurion was born in Plonsk, one hundred and twenty since he immigrated to the Land of Israel, and fifty-three since his death and burial in the soil of the Negev, which he loved so dearly.
On Ben-Gurion’s modest gravestone, here before us, there is no mention of his being Israel’s first prime minister, defense minister, founder of the IDF, or the man who proclaimed independence.
Of all the many milestones in his life, only one act was chosen to be commemorated: his immigration to the Land of Israel in 1906.
Last Shabbat, in the Torah portion Toldot, we read about Isaac, the only one of the three patriarchs who did not leave the Land of Israel. Ben-Gurion’s character and life story combine Abraham’s “Go forth,” but no less so the figure of Isaac: the sower, the man who dug wells in Sisyphean labor, the man who clung to his land even under harsh conditions and in the face of repeated acts of hostility.
Ben-Gurion is one of the foremost representatives of practical, pioneering Zionism. A Zionism that was not content with congresses and lofty words, but demanded immigration, fulfillment, and difficult decisions.
Today I wish to turn the spotlight not on his work as a pioneer in the settlements of Judea and the Galilee, nor on his work as a statesman and security leader, but on the inner compass that drove and guided him. On the roots of his Zionist thought, at a time when Zionism seems to have become a Rorschach blot.
On May 6, 1952, speaking from the podium of the Knesset, David Ben-Gurion said:
“My Zionism is nothing but a part and an expression of my Judaism, and not the other way around. I am a Zionist only because I am a Jew…”
“Zionism,” he wrote in his essay “The Goals of Zionism Today,” “is nothing but a new, modern name for the soul of Judaism throughout the ages: the messianic aspiration of the Hebrew people for complete and full national and human redemption.”
In his foundational essay “The Eternity of Israel,” Ben-Gurion identified two sources of Zionism’s inspiration: “The first source is deep, irrational, enduring, independent of time and place, and as old as the Jewish people: the messianic hope.”
This source originated in the covenant God made with our forefather Abraham and in the promise of the land to his descendants. It continued in the prophecies of redemption delivered by the prophets of Israel, in the prayers of the Jew, and in the longing of generations for a return to Zion.
The second source, which he called “the renewing and activating source,” was the product of the political and social upheavals in nineteenth-century Europe: the rise of nationalist movements, the struggle for freedom and equality, and antisemitism.
Ben-Gurion distinguished between the Zionism of the Jews of Central and Western Europe, whom antisemitism brought back to their Judaism, with Herzl foremost among them, and the Zionism of the masses of Jews in Eastern Europe, which grew out of their Judaism and whose love of Zion they imbibed with their mothers’ milk.
His grandfather, Zvi Aryeh, taught him Hebrew and the Pentateuch even before he began his studies at the traditional religious school.
His mother, Sheindel, who died when he was eleven, dreamed that her son would become a great rabbi.
His father, Avigdor Green, was one of the first members of the Hovevei Zion movement in Poland, and the family home in Plonsk was a center of Zionist activity. In a letter he sent to his wife and children in May 1942, upon learning of his father’s death, he wrote: “From him I received my love for the people of Israel, for the land, and for the Hebrew language. Before I understood the substance of the discussions and debates, I absorbed the hope for Zion that filled our home.”
Ben-Gurion did not see Zionism as a substitute for Judaism, but as its national expression and its historical continuation.
This outlook also gave rise to one of his greatest concerns for our future: the weakening of Jewish identity.
Someone who had devoted the best years of his life to strengthening Israel’s military and political power understood full well that there were threats to the Jewish people’s existence that fighter jets, tanks, or advanced weapons could not address: “Not by might, nor by power.”
In February 1954, in an article he wrote here in Sde Boker, “A Bond with the Eternity of Israel,” he warned of the decline of American Jewry. In historical perspective, we can say that, to some extent, he also predicted it: a decline not caused by persecution, but rather by prosperity and assimilation into American society. He called it “a kiss of death.”
His concern about the blurring and weakening of Jewish identity was not limited to Diaspora Jews. He was also deeply concerned about the spiritual character of the younger generation growing up in the Land of Israel.
In 1955, he wrote to Education Minister Zalman Aran: “To the extent that I know the youth (and I am speaking of the best of the youth!), they are very, very deficient in Jewish consciousness, in knowledge of our historical heritage, and in a moral bond with world Jewry.”
Ben-Gurion did not content himself with writing articles and sending letters. In all four of his final governments, from 1955 until his resignation in 1963, deepening Jewish consciousness among Israeli youth, rooting them in the Jewish people’s historical heritage, and strengthening their bond with world Jewry were part of the official guidelines of the Israeli government.
Yet the sincerity of his intentions and the depth of his commitment were not enough to ensure the success of the educational enterprise across generations.
In the culture of national revival that Ben-Gurion helped shape, a deep tension prevailed: the aspiration to renew Jewish continuity alongside the desire to create a new Jew, freed from the shackles of exile and its world.
The direct link from the Bible to the Palmach, to the pioneer and the warrior, gave the generation of statehood tremendous strength, but left too little room for the Jewish world that sustained our people in the interim: rabbinic literature, the works of the early and later sages, the prayer book, custom, the community, and the library of books built up from generation to generation.
And I believe this is also where part of the failure lies.
Ben-Gurion himself carried this world with him from childhood; he imbibed it with his mother’s milk, and it was almost self-evident to him. But for subsequent generations, it had to be passed on through a comprehensive, deliberate effort that could not be confined to the four walls of the school and a few Bible lessons.
More than seventy years have passed since Ben-Gurion voiced his warnings, and despite his efforts, their relevance has only grown. The disconnect he warned against has long since extended beyond the young. Among substantial segments of the public, a distancing from Jewish tradition and Jewish identity is evident. The result is an Israeli identity alienated from its sources: disconnected from the Book of Books and the Jewish library, indifferent to the birth pangs of the homeland, and detached from the spirit of traditional Judaism.
A blue-and-white exile.
The consequences of the disconnect are also evident in the political sphere. Unity does not require uniformity of thought, but it does require recognition of belonging to one people, “those who are here… and those who are not here with us today,” and of responsibility for its future. This is the shared banner without which disputes lose their boundaries.
That is why I sought to focus my remarks on the anchor and compass that guided David Ben-Gurion throughout his life and work: the eternity of Israel. Unconditional love for Israel. Faith in the people of Israel, in its destiny and its mission.
In 1935, against the backdrop of his efforts to reach agreements with Ze’ev Jabotinsky, he said in a speech before the Zionist General Council in Jerusalem:
“There is now, more than at any other time, a great need for peace, for Zionist peace. And there is a need for unity, for Zionist unity. And there is only one unity that can take root among us:
Not ideological unity; that is impossible. There will not be a single doctrine and a single way of thinking throughout the Jewish diaspora; there are conflicts, conflicts of interest, cultural conflicts, educational conflicts, conflicts of tradition. And they will not disappear so quickly. But unity of action is possible and essential. I see it as the decree of destiny for this hour, unity of Zionist action…”
Historical truth requires me to qualify this and say that Ben-Gurion himself was far from exemplary when it came to the unity of the people. We, members of the national camp, do not forget the Saison, the Altalena affair, the persecution and exclusion of members of the Revisionist camp, and the treatment of Menachem Begin and the Herut movement.
We should not blur these chapters in our history, nor should we compromise our worldview in the slightest in order to recognize David Ben-Gurion’s greatness. On the contrary, our ability to honor the life’s work of someone who was a bitter rival of our camp is itself an expression of our understanding of the distinction between what is essential and what is secondary, between what we share and what divides us.
His Zionist doctrine contains elements that we sorely lack today: the depth of Jewish historical consciousness, the understanding that our right to the land does not derive from the goodwill of the nations of the world, the centrality of personal fulfillment, faith in the power of pioneering, and a sense of responsibility for the fate of the entire Jewish people.
National unity does not require us to think alike, but it does require us to share a common destiny and purpose.
It requires us to remember that there is something greater than any party, any political camp, and any one of us:
The eternity of Israel will not fail.
May his memory be blessed.
Israpundit is entirely dependent on readers support. Please help me continue educating people with the truth about what is going on in Israel and around the world.


Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.