The art of no deal: Who’s subverting Trump’s Israeli-Palestinian peace plan?  

T. Belman.  Horovitz takes a left wing position believing that what is intended is a negotiated solution. When Gantz says he wants to consult with the international community he is doing likewise. There is only one way that these issues can be resolved and that is through diktat.

Horowitz asks:

Is Trump genuinely seeking to broker the Deal of the Century, or are we, rather, witnessing the Art of No Deal?

That is the question.

Unilateral annexation risks so much damage for such potentially short-term reward, and completely undermines the proposal’s negotiated approach. So who’s pushing it, and why?

By DAVID HOROVITZ, TOI.

A week after the big reveal, something has gone terribly wrong with the Trump administration’s self-styled “Vision to improve the lives of the Palestinian and Israeli people.”

The document published by the White House last Tuesday broke ground in taking seriously many Israeli concerns that were marginalized, if not ignored, in previous peace efforts. Critically, it was predicated on the imperative that the rise of a Palestinian state in no way undermine or threaten Israel’s security, and that the US would only ask Israel to consider compromises that would make the country and its people “more secure in the short and long term.” It also included innumerable elements guaranteed to infuriate the Palestinians — radically constraining their future sovereign rights, denying them significant status in Jerusalem, refusing their demand for a “right of return” for refugees, and plenty more.

But the document was also declaredly only a starting point — “designed for the benefit of Palestinians, Israelis and the region as a whole,” as a recommended basis for direct Israeli-Palestinian negotiation on a “realistic two-state solution.”
Read more…

February 4, 2020 | 5:11 pm | Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

More Israelis support two-state solution via Trump plan than oppose it — survey  

T. Belman.  This survey was done before the Deal was released.  It only asked if they would accept the Plan if it included the creation of a Palestinian state. That is not the case.  No mention was made about what israel might get from the deal or any possible restrictions on the state.  I fully expect greater support for the Deal now that its details are known.

The Deal does not require acceptance by any side though Trump has said he would like approval.  Since Trump has said on many occasions that settlements are not illegal and that israel has the legal and historical claims to the land, I see not impediment to Israel extending sovereignty not because of the deal but because they have the right to. At the same time, she can indicate that she is open to considering the provisions of the Deal. That’s far from expressing approval of the creation of a Palestinian state.

If peace plan requires recognizing a Palestinian state, 45.3% said Israel should go ahead, 38.1% oppose the idea; half the population see release of plan as election interference

By TOI STAFF

US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu participate in a joint statement in the East Room of the White House, in Washington, DC, on January 28, 2020. (Sarah Silbiger/Getty Images/AFP)
US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu participate in a joint statement in the East Room of the White House, in Washington, DC, on January 28, 2020. (Sarah Silbiger/Getty Images/AFP)

More Israelis think the country should agree to a Trump administration peace plan that includes recognition of a Palestinian state than those who oppose the creation of a state under the plan, according to a survey published Monday.

The Israeli Voice Index poll was conducted before US President Donald Trump unveiled his peace proposal in Washington last week, but it asked respondents about willingness to recognize a Palestinian state on the assumption that such a condition would be included in the plan.

While 45.3% would accept the condition of recognizing a Palestinian state, 38.1% said Israel should not agree, according to the poll, a monthly survey conducted by the Israel Democracy Institute think tank in Jerusalem.
Read more…

February 4, 2020 | 11:37 am | Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Blue and White’s Bind Over a Knesset Vote on Annexation  

If the Trump peace plan comes to a vote, Kahol Lavan leader would oppose unilateral steps at annexation that are not coordinated with the Palestinians, but there are also divisions within the party on the plan

By Jonathan Lis, HAARETZ

Kahol Lavan leader Benny Gantz in the Knesset chamber.

Kahol Lavan leader Benny Gantz in the Knesset chamber.Emil Salman

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s announced plans to annex West Bank territory following last week’s unveiling of U.S. President Donald Trump’s peace plan for Israel and the Palestinians have put Kahol Lavan in a bind. The party’s chairman, Benny Gantz, has made it clear that Kahol Lavan objects to unilateral moves at annexation that are divorced from other elements of the Trump’s “deal of the century” and that are made without coordination with the Palestinians.

On the other hand, sources in the party said Sunday that it may support a proposal for some form of annexation if Netanyahu brings it to the Knesset before the March 2 election. “If there’s a snap decision to bring unilateral annexation to a vote, we may vote in favor. It would be a major dilemma,” a senior party source told Haaretz, adding that if the issue arises, Kahol Lavan’s Knesset faction would convene for lengthy deliberations that would end with Gantz deciding how to proceed.
Read more…

February 4, 2020 | 11:02 am | 22 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Oman, Chad, and now Sudan: Israel and the wider MidEast puzzle  

This was the first power change in Sudan since 1989. But even Omar al-Bashir, the former leader had considered a change in relationship with Israel.

By SETH J. FRANTZMAN, JPOST

PRIME MINISTER Benjamin Netanyahu meets Sultan Qaboos bin Said in Oman. (photo credit: GPO/REUTERS)

PRIME MINISTER Benjamin Netanyahu meets Sultan Qaboos bin Said in Oman. (photo credit: GPO/REUTERS)

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appeared to pull another diplomatic milestone out of his hat on Monday when he met Sudanese leader Abdel Fattah al-Burhan in Uganda. This is an important achievement that dovetails with other diplomatic successes in recent years. For instance Netanyahu went to Oman on a surprise visit in October 2018 and Israel renewed ties with Chad in January 2019. The Sudan meeting could be a trial balloon for further Israeli openings in the Middle East, or it could help Sudan with its own relationships with Washington and other countries.

The Sudanese meeting was likely made possible by a change in government in Sudan in August 2019 when al-Burhan came to power as part of a council that is supposed to run the country for a transitional period. This was the first power change in Sudan since 1989. But even Omar al-Bashir, the former leader had considered a change in relationship with Israel.

Read more…

February 4, 2020 | 10:40 am | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

You’re Going to Be Hearing a Lot More About Syria Soon  

by 

Once the dust had settled following Donald Trump’s abrupt decision to withdraw U.S. service personnel from northern Syria, the general-interest press seemed to lose all interest in the country. You haven’t heard much about the place since.

Casual observers might be forgiven for thinking that the nine-year-old Syrian civil war has virtually concluded with the Assad regime’s victory, but hostilities in that conflict are far from over. Last week, Syrian forces and Iran-aligned militia groups backed by Russian airpower executed a successful assault on the separatist-held town of Maarat al-Numan, sacking it and the surrounding villages. It was an important symbolic victory for the regime as well as a strategic feat. The city hosted some of the earliest anti-Assad protests before the Syrian uprising devolved into an international crisis, and its residents publicly objected to the Islamist elements that have since overtaken much of the remaining resistance to Damascus’s rule.
Read more…

February 4, 2020 | 9:33 am | 4 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Trump Plan is Death Certificate for Abbas’ Political Career, Says Palestinian Official  

According to some sources, the White House’s “deal of the century” represents the end Mahmoud Abbas’ political career.

By Baruch Yedid, TPS

Fatah member with a photo of Mahmoud Abbas

Palestinian Authority (PA) and Fatah officials believe they are marching toward the end of the Mahmoud Abbas era and the strategic failure of his “political intifada” against Israel.

Abbas has launched a series of diplomatic campaigns against Israel at several international forums in recent years, all of which have apparently failed in wake of President Donald Trump’s Deal of the Century which calls for a partial Israeli annexation of areas in Judea and Samaria

One source told TPS that the Deal of the Century peace plan is nothing but an “American impeachment letter to Abbas” and the Arab League summit that convened over the weekend in Cairo to discuss the plan is essentially “a respectable farewell ceremony” to the PA’s chairman. Read more…

February 4, 2020 | 9:13 am | 2 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Rage and Unreason  

A death cult shuns Trump’s Deal of the Century.

By Howard Rotberg, FPM   Mon Feb 3, 2020<
>

Merriam-Webster defines “rage” as “violent and uncontrolled anger.”

It is a sudden reaction, as in “road rage.” It is not planned and it is not controlled.

Hence, you cannot plan a day of uncontrolled anger due to a sudden reaction and call it a “Day of Rage.” Mahmoud Abbas of the so-called Palestinian Authority called for a Day of Rage in response to U.S. President Donald Trump’s “Deal of the Century” — which would gradually give Abbas’ people a state alongside Israel in as much as 70% of the lands which Israelis term “disputed” and the Palestinians and their supporters term “occupied.”
Read more…

February 4, 2020 | 3:56 am | Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Learning from David Ben-Gurion’s pragmatism  

The decisions made by Ben Gurion can and should provide important lessons for the dilemmas facing Israel today as a result of the Deal. His decision to relinquish important tracts of territory has been vindicated historically.

By Ron Jager, INN

Irrespective of the ambiguities and the “open to negotiation” provisions of President Trump’s “Deal of the Century,” Israel clearly stands at an historic juncture very similar to the Ben Gurion period.

At the time, Israel’s political leadership had to either accept or reject the United Nations Partition Plan and decide what to make of this one-time historical opportunity. Undeniably, the “Deal of the Century,” represents an acknowledgment of Zionism’s historical triumph and that the State of Israel is indeed the embodiment of both the ancestral and modern day homeland of the Jewish nation.

The “Deal” clearly recognizes Jerusalem as the undivided Capital of Israel, the Jordan Valley as the Eastern border of the State of Israel, and most importantly, demands the Palestinian Authority recognize the State of Israel as the homeland of the Jewish nation.

The “Deal” also recognizes the changes that have transpired over the past half century and allows for the declaration of sovereignty over Jewish communities located in the disputed territories of Judea and Samaria (aka West Bank).
Read more…

February 4, 2020 | 2:26 am | 2 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

A report from the front  

The Taming of the Jew is a report from the front. We now know that Jew-hatred is bigger than Jeremy Corbyn, bigger than the Labor Party, and that anti-Semitism has infected all of Britain.

Prof. Phyllis Chesler,  INN

Tuvia Tenenbom is a man of the theater, a showman, the most serious clown ever, for buried beneath his puckish exterior is a barely hidden heartbreak over humanity’s betrayal of both reason and the Jews; and of Western Culture as we have known it.

Tuvia Tenenbom is also a bon vivant, a gourmand, a lover of both luxury and simplicity, a convivial coffee and whiskey drinker, a smoker, and he invites us to join him as he tours the British Isles, dines well or dines poorly, talks to almost anyone who will talk to him, visits all the theater he can find in the hope that it has not been destroyed by political correctness.

After interviewing the people of Germany (I Sleep in Hitler’s Room and Hello Refugees); Israel (Catch the Jew); and the United States (The Lies They Tell),  he has just published the aptly titled The Taming of the Jew, in Czech, in Hebrew, and now in German (Suhrkamp). It is set in the United Kingdom. He was there and on the road for three months in 2018 and for four months in 2019.
Read more…

February 3, 2020 | 2:10 pm | Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

A month to election day, Netanyahu falls into an annexation trap  

T. Belman.  I get it.  Creating a Palestinian state west of the Jordan R, even with limited sovereignty, is a no, no, with the Israeli right. Why didn’t Kusher get this? If this is such a no no with them why have they not tabled their own plan?  What is their alternative?  This plan enlarges the Palestinian area but reduces its sovereignty and is heavily conditioned.  It was still rejected.  I think Bibi is responsible for showing acceptance of this plan and misled Kushner. But after three years in the making and numerous consultations with the Israeli right, surely Kushner knew this.

Could it be that Kushner included poison pills in the plan for both the Arabs and the Israelis to show how futile such a plan is?  Maybe he is setting the stage for something totally different.

How did the prime minister’s moment of ‘historic’ triumph in Washington descend into a bitter farce, turn Jared Kushner into a nemesis, and infuriate his right-wing base?

By SHALOM YERUSHALMI, TOI Today, 10:45 am

 

US President Donald Trump, left, and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during an event in the East Room of the White House in Washington, January 28, 2020, to announce the Trump administration’s plan to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh)

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will have had many long hours for contemplation during his flight Monday to Uganda.

How did it come to pass, the prime minister will likely have agonized, that he could deliver such a climactic crescendo in Washington, only to awkwardly stumble days later?

Why did he vow so publicly that he would immediately start to apply Israeli sovereignty to the Jordan Valley and all settlements in Judea and Samaria in a cabinet meeting that was supposed to have taken place on Sunday, only to have to swallow the bitter pill and cancel that meeting, because he could offer no annexation plan for the ministers to vote on — and couldn’t even be sure he had a majority among ministers from his own Likud party?
Read more…

February 3, 2020 | 12:26 pm | 5 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Benny Begin: No Arab sovereignty west of the Jordan  

Former Likud minister strongly opposes adoption of US plan and the idea of a Palestinian state in ‘regions of our homeland.’

Arutz Sheva Staff,

Former Minister and Likud figure Benny Begin on Sunday strongly opposed the idea that the government would officially approve the Deal of the Century introduced last week by U.S. President Donald Trump.

In an interview with Reshet Bet, Begin said, “It is an interesting document but it is not a plan. The Americans also call this document a ‘vision’, also the maps that it contains are called envisioned maps.”

“Of course, this document cannot actually be realized and therefore it should be viewed as an update on American policy in our region. It bears a certain import, but care must be taken to leave it at that,” he noted. Read more…

February 3, 2020 | 12:00 pm | 4 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Singer: “Trump’s vision is a mirage based on shaky foundations”  

T. Belman.  Singer wants to extend Jordan’s borders to take in the land set aside for the Palestinians  west of the Jordan R. I disagree vehemently.  I want Israel to have sovereignty over all land west of the Jordan R and to incentivize the Palestinians to emigrate to Jordan or elsewhere.

The “Palestinians” do have a state – now called Jordan – created in 78% of former Palestine in 1946. 

By David Singer, INN

President Trump’s now released deal of the century – calling for the creation of a second Arab state in former Palestine in addition to Jordan (“the two-state solution”) – has predictably already been consigned to the dustbin of history by PLO President Mahmoud Abbas on the day of its publication.

Trump’s solution was a mirage based on the same shaky foundations unsuccessfully pursued by the international community since the 1980 Venice Declaration.

Trump’s failure to address the following issues ensured its collapse from the get go:

  • The term “Palestinians” is not defined in the plan’s Glossary.
  • Who comprise “the Palestinians” and what constitutes their common identity?

Read more…

February 2, 2020 | 8:48 pm | 14 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

How Zionism Keeps us in the Game  

By Victor Rosenthal

Anshel Pfeffer, a very smart guy and one of the few writers that regularly appears in Ha’aretz who is worth reading, does not believe in Zionism. He doesn’t oppose it, he just thinks talking about it is a kind of category mistake:

You cannot be either a Zionist or an anti-Zionist, just as you cannot be a veteran of Iwo Jima unless you were born at least 90 years ago and fought in that battle. Zionism isn’t an ideology. It’s a program, or an ideological plan, to establish a state for Jews in the biblical homeland. And that program was fulfilled on May 14, 1948, when David Ben-Gurion declared Israel’s independence at the old Tel Aviv Museum. That’s it. Done.

…believing that on the whole, founding the State of Israel was the right thing to do, doesn’t make you a Zionist any more than thinking that Oliver Cromwell was right to overthrow King Charles, makes you a Roundhead. It simply doesn’t matter what you think about long-ago events you didn’t take part in. Israel is a reality and it’s not going anywhere.

As a consequence, he thinks that the World Zionist Congress is a waste of time and money, as are almost all other Zionist organizations, including those like the Jewish Agency and Jewish National Fund that are closely entwined with the government of Israel.
Read more…

February 2, 2020 | 7:19 pm | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

US rejects Arab League rejection but still seeks to restrain Israel. Why?  

T. Belman. Either Israel has the right to extend her sovereignty or she doesn’t. Israel should not need US permission to claim what is hers legally and historically. So she should go ahead and do it without consent. Trump/Kushner can disagree for their own reasons.  They can withhold their consent until after the elections if they so choose. In that way everybody exercises their rights.  Nothing hinges on Israel being compliant. But I think that both the US and Israel benefit from Israel showing independance.

It is not in Israel’s interest to encourage Abbas to join the process or to show him flexibility. Trump for his own reasons thinks that it enables him to sell the plan. But does it?  Better that he just plow ahead and do it. Don’t let the tail wag the dog.  The more resolve he shows, the more success he will achieve. The more flexibility he shows, the more he loses the Israeli Right and the more he gets bogged down in the process

If Israel extends their law to all land and people within the municipal envelopes in the first instance, there should be no technical issues to decide. The technical team can always meet thereafter to decide how much more to enlarge the envelope.

Senior official says Palestinian fate won’t change if group of 22 countries doesn’t alter methods; CIA chief said to visit Ramallah, assure PA of opposition to snap annexation

By TOI STAFF

Jared Kushner (R) joins US President Donald Trump as he holds a press conference in the Rose Garden of the White House on October 1, 2018. (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images via JTA)
Jared Kushner (R) joins US President Donald Trump as he holds a press conference in the Rose Garden of the White House on October 1, 2018. (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images via JTA)

A senior US official on Saturday lambasted the Arab League’s rejection of the recently released Trump peace plan, saying in a statement that such dismissals would not benefit the Palestinian people.

“It is only by having a wiliness [sic] to try a new approach that we will make a breakthrough in a conflict that has left the Palestinian people to suffer for decades,” a senior administration official said in a written statement.

“Past Arab League resolutions have placated Palestinian leadership and not led to peace or progress and it is important to try a new approach or the Palestinian people’s fate will not change.” the official added. Read more…

February 2, 2020 | 4:39 pm | 14 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Birthright’s measurable impact: More American Jews  

Two decades after it launched, it’s clear the free trip to Israel helped bring about a 25% rise in the US Jewish population

By Leonard Saxe, TOI

Participants in the Birthright Israel trip. (courtesy)

Participants in the Birthright Israel trip. (courtesy)<
>
Twenty years ago, in late December 1999, an El Al flight from New York City landed at Ben Gurion Airport. Among the passengers were 40 college students – the inaugural Birthright Israel participants from the United States. Their arrival was the beginning of an experiment in Israel-Diaspora education that has transformed Jewish life in America.

Since its launch, approximately 750,000 Jewish young adults – more than 425,000 from the United States – have participated in Birthright’s ten-day educational programs. Numerous studies have demonstrated Birthright’s impact on the Jewish identity of its participants. Less appreciated is how the program is reshaping American Jewry’s demographic profile.

When Birthright was launched, there were approximately 5.5 million Jews in the United States. Today, the US Jewish population is 7.5 million individuals, a 25% increase. Birthright is not solely responsible for the growth, but the program has become emblematic of efforts to engage future generations with Jewish life.
Read more…

February 2, 2020 | 4:17 pm | Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Conrad Black: This is a real chance for peace in the Middle East  

Since 1993 the Palestinians could have had their state, though it would have been a modest one. But they fought on, oblivious to the evaporation of their bargaining position

By Conrad Black, NATIONAL POST

The U.S. Middle East peace initiative has been largely lost in the distractions of the doomed and outrageous attempt to impeach the president of the United States and the coronavirus epidemic that has already caused the quarantine of 60 million Chinese (almost the entire population of France). Because it is Donald Trump’s, and importantly contributed to by his son-in-law Jared Kushner, and the entire traditional approach to peace-making has been jettisoned and replaced, most observers are dubious, beyond what is always somewhat justified in that part of the world. This is not an unreasonable reflex, given that no substantive negotiations have achieved anything useful in the Middle East since the assassination of Egyptian president Anwar Sadat in 1981.

A radical change in approach is justified because of the large shift in the correlation of forces in the region. To the end of the 20th century Israel was facing quite solid Arab opposition, and the United States was importing 15 million barrels of oil per day and had to pay some attention to the desires of the Gulf states, especially Saudi Arabia, a feudal country that was a joint venture between the nomadic House of Saud and the leadership of the radical Wahhabi Muslims. The entire Muslim world, in varying degrees, paid lip-service and gave some tangible assistance to the cause of the Palestinians, whose leadership militantly declined to accept Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state.

A radical change in approach is justified

Read more…

February 2, 2020 | 4:01 pm | 2 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Israel must present an “IRON WALL”  

The End of Palestine?

Editorial of The New York Sun | February 1, 2020

The reaction of the Palestinian Arabs to President Trump’s new peace plan turns out to be a vow to sever relations with both Israel and America. On its face that wouldn’t be the worst outcome, either, given the prospect that our permanent State Department, egged on by our Democratic Party intelligentsia, will be tempted to try to win a compromise by tilting Mr. Trump’s plan toward the Arab camp.

Why should America be suing anyone for a Middle East peace? We have been asking that question for years. It’s not that the Sun opposes peace in the Middle East. We don’t. Nor do we lack for regard for President Trump, whom we endorsed (partly on the basis of his seichel in respect of Israel). We also have great regard for the President’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, scion of a revered Zionist family.
Read more…

February 2, 2020 | 8:08 am | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

INTO THE FRAY: The Trump plan: The good, the bad, the unknown and…the untenable  

By MARTIN SHERMAN

Assessing the overall long-term merits of the “Deal of the Century” is a little like trying to hit a rapidly moving target

There was a wedding today. The groom showed up. The bride stayed home and wished the groom dead. And everyone clapped – A caustic assessment of the “Deal of the Century”, attributed to Meir Jolovitz, Middle East Radio, Phoenix, AZ, courtesy of my Facebook friend, Jan Sniderman

Over the years, I have expressed what are generally considered distinctly hardline, hawkish views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

I categorically opposed any notion entailing the establishment of a Palestinian state and any withdrawal from territory currently under Israel’s administration, west of the Jordan.

Given my past positions, I should, of course, vigorously reject the “Deal of the Century” as proposed last week by the Trump Administration, which does involve both these elements. Read more…

February 1, 2020 | 7:56 pm | 10 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free
« Previous Page — Next Page »