Why equality doesn’t belong in the nation-state law
T. Belman. Gordon says “equality” should be left out from the Nation-state law, as it has, because to include it would elevate democracy over Jewish. She said that the currrent law seeks parity between both.
I am not satisfied with Parity because that would leave it to the Court to decide between the two. They could always favour democracy.
By Evelyn Gordon
Ever since Israel’s nation-state law was enacted in July, one constant refrain has sounded: The law should have included a provision guaranteeing equality to all Israelis. It’s not only the law’s opponents who say this; so do many of its supporters, liberals and conservatives alike. But they are wrong.
Adding a provision about equality to the nation-state law sounds innocuous because civic and political equality is already implicitly guaranteed through the 1992 Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty. Basic Laws are Israel’s closest approximation to constitutional legislation, and the 1992 law, which protects the “dignity of any person as such,” has been consistently interpreted by the courts as enshrining equality on the grounds that discrimination violates a person’s dignity. So what harm could it do to offer an explicit guarantee in the Basic Law: Israel as the Nation-State of the Jewish People?
Read more…









