T. Belman. Shoval failed to address a bone of contention. Yes. the Court can over turn laws which conflict with our Constitution (Basic Laws). This is the same in western democracies. What is different in Israel is the ability of the Court to interpret basic laws which are not explicit. In Many countries, the law is returned to the Parliament to make it more explicit. Or at least the principles of interpretation require the Court to look at the intention of the Government. In Israel, the Court takes it upon itself.
For instance, in the Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty, there is no definition of “human dignity”. This is very problematic as the Court has taken upon itself to interpret the words and by virtue of their interpretation have overruled many a law passed by the Knesset.
By Salman Shoval, ISRAEL HAYOM
It seems that not a day goes by without an opinion piece being published accusing the Israeli government, and the state in general, of being undemocratic. Every political or legal step involving Judaism, Zionism or patriotism earns this label.
Supreme Court Justice Yoram Danziger championed freedom of speech as a central test for democracy. Indeed, a single glance at a newspaper these days is proof enough that in Israel this freedom is upheld to the extreme. There are additional principles: majority rule, minority rights, rule of law, freedom of employment and the right to property. These principles come with restraints, such as how to ensure that freedom of expression does not result in “grave harm to the public’s wellbeing and safety,” as former Chief Justice Aharon Barak once said, or how to prevent the election process from distorting the true will of the people. And perhaps most importantly, how to prevent a protected minority from taking advantage of its status to extort the majority.
Read more…