Into the Fray: Debating disobedience
[See also David Bedein’s The Moral Imperative to Refuse an Immoral or Illegal Military Order in Israel]
By MARTIN SHERMAN, JPOST
-
Is the Likud once again planning to use the military to impose evacuations of Jewish communities? If not, why did it opt to make Bennett’s remark an issue of such centrality? Theirs not to make reply; Theirs not to reason why; Theirs but to do and die
– Alfred Tennyson, The Charge of the Light Brigade, 1854
-
Above all, the grand and only effectual security against the despotism of the government is… the sympathy of the army with the people…. Soldiers to whose feelings half or three-fourths of the subjects of the same government are foreigners will have no more scruple in mowing them down, and no more desire to ask the reason why, than they would have in doing the same thing against declared enemies…. Such armies have been the executioners of liberty through the whole duration of modern history.
– John Stuart Mill, On Representative Government, 1861
The media feeding frenzy sparked by Naftali Bennett’s remark made during a blatantly antagonistic interview conducted by a blatantly adversarial interviewer, Nissim Mishal, was depressingly revealing as to the quality of the county’s public discourse.
Read more…


