E. Rowell: I disagree with the author when he states that Zionism has exacerbated antisemitism. Antisemitism predates Zionism. Antisemitism is as old as scape-goating itself, a practice described in the Bible. It is the means by which individuals place the blame on all Jews for their own failures, their own acts of destructiveness. Zionism did not exacerbate this; antisemitism would have continued had there been no State of Israel in existence. When progressive Jews blame Zionism for being a “colonial enterprise,” they are ignorant of history. They are using Zionism as a scapegoat, a way of saying “mea culpa” i.e. “We Jews are guilty of using our advantages at the expense of others.” That is an expression of their neurosis. In their desire to show “compassion” for others less fortunate, they feel the need to placate these others by diminishing the power of Jews and the State of Israel. In addition they are carrying water for those who truly hate Jews.
Israelis are defending the West, which is essentially our own creation to the extent that the West is ultimately a product of Judaism and Christianity.
By Saul Goldman, FUTURE OF JEWISH 1 June 2024
An Israeli Air Force plane prepares for takeoff. (photo: Israeli Air Force/X)
Today, many all over the world, including Jews, are calling Israel’s underlying Zionist ideology into question.
There are Jews apparently so ignorant of Judaism that they claim Zionism is not Judaism. They reject Zionism as if it was some sort of non-Jewish ideology. Therefore, in their ill-conceived conclusion, being “anti-Zionist” is not being anti-Jewish.
People have distorted the term “Zionism” by emphasizing the way early Zionists embraced socialism and ignoring the Biblical and rabbinic ideas pertaining to the centrality of the land of Israel in Judaism. Perhaps the mystical notion that prior to redemption a spiritual transformation of Israel must take place further removed the connection between redemption and homecoming.
Read more…