The medical war on Israel

Special: World’s medical NGOs anything but neutral when it comes to Israeli-Palestinian conflict

Giulio Meotti, YNET

Israel was excluded from the International Red Cross for half a century because of the Star of David. Questioned for having denied entry to the Jewish state, Cornelio Sommaruga, then-head of the International Committee of the Red Cross, declared: “If we’re going to have the Star of David, why would we not have to accept the Swastika?”

The historical injustice has been rectified only in 2006. Since then, the world medical organizations have been anything but neutral when it comes to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Over the past several months, three top officials from the Hamas terror group have set up shop at the International Red Cross office in east Jerusalem, in violation of the organization’s alleged mandate of “political neutrality.”

Secret documents leaked by WikiLeaks also said that Iran used Red Cross ambulances to smuggle weapons into Lebanon during Hezbollah’s 2006 war with Israel.

Recently, a new report by the Physicians for Human Rights, a group largely funded by the European Union, accused Israeli medics of abusing prisoners, calling the Jewish doctors “torturers.” Médecins Sans Frontières, which won a Nobel Prize in 1999, just released a report charging Israeli authorities are “depriving Gazans of critical medicare.”

The UN’s World Health Organization in its latest report accused Israel of “lack of respect and protection for Palestinian ambulances” and asked to “put an end to the closure of the occupied Palestinian territory” and to the Gaza blockade. The UN agency also urged Israel “to abide by the Fourth Geneva Convention” and called on “all international human rights organizations to intervene on an urgent and immediate basis vis-à-vis the occupying power: Israel.”

A case in point is how the Red Cross allocates personnel and budgets worldwide. For North Africa, the Red Cross has one office in Tunis. For “Israel/Occupied Territories/Autonomous Territories,” the Red Cross has offices in Jenin, Tulkarm, Nablus, Kalkilya, Ramallah, Jericho, Bethlehem, Hebron, Gaza, Khan Yunis, Majdel Shams, Jerusalem, and Tel Aviv.

Western newspapers, imbued with the ideological reports of medical NGOs, establish a comparison between the Palestinians and South Africa’s blacks, who were critically injured and left to bleed to death if there was no “black” ambulance to rush them to a “black” hospital. Jewish altruism never finds its legitimate space in the global media because it doesn’t fit in with the stereotype propagated by the medical NGOs.

This month, no Western journal reported on the story of Adi Weissbuch, a senior physician in the high-risk pregnancy unit of Kaplan Medical Center in Rehovot, who assisted an Iranian doctor with a pregnant woman suffering a rare defect. Similarly, nobody knows that Israel saved the life of the three-year-old daughter of Hamas Interior Minister, Elham Fathi Hammad, after she was the victim of a unsuccessful heart operation in Amman.

Hospital firebombed
It would be enough to stroll through the corridors of Israeli hospitals to understand how false the “apartheid” charge by medical NGOs is. Large Arab families stand with Israelis in the corridors of the maternity wards where one is born and in the oncology clinics where one dies. Through the private program “Save the heart of a child,” the Wolfson Medical Center in Holon cures congenital cardiologic defects in Arab children from all over the world. About half the children it treats are from the nearby Palestinian areas and there have also been some from Iraq and Iran, both technically at war with Israel.

The organization’s lead surgeon, Lior Sasson, said Palestinian parents sometimes seem “terrified” when they first arrive at the hospital. “Sometimes they (the parents) were brought up (to think) that the Jews are monstrous and they want to kill kids”, said Sasson.

Israeli medical statistics are constantly neglected by medical organizations. Last June, Israel’s Magen David Adom ambulance service reported that it delivered at least one Palestinian baby every single month. In February, brain surgeons saved the life of a Gaza toddler. Meanwhile, the IDF announced that 180,000 Arabs from Palestinian areas have been treated in one year.

Medical organizations never blamed the Palestinians for attacks on Israeli hospitals. Hadassah University Medical Center on Jerusalem’s Mount Scopus recently released a report, noting that it suffered 43 attacks by east Jerusalem Arabs in 2011. During the last “Nakba Day” events alone, 11 firebombs were thrown into the Mount Scopus campus.

The medical groups also didn’t report that 10 Gaza hospitals were used by Hamas during Operation Cast Lead to shelter weapons and terrorists.

Today Magen David Adom vehicles do not enter the Arab neighborhoods of east Jerusalem without police authorization and military escort. It’s not because of the “apartheid,” but rather, because terrorists tried to hit the doctors. During the Intifada, MDA had to replace the windows of its ambulances in the Jerusalem region with glass that does not shatter if hit by rocks.

Global silence when Israel hit
The Red Cross, the World Health Organization and medical NGOs never raised their voice when Palestinian bombs hit Israeli hospitals where Jewish doctors were saving the lives of Palestinians, such as the Barzilai Medical Center in Ashkelon, where the wounded were taken during the war in Gaza.

Israeli doctors didn’t ask for identification cards; they operated on everyone. If a Qassam were to hit the hospital, the “triumph” would be celebrated in Gaza without consideration for the Arabs being treated there. Barzilai coordinated the transfer of patients with Gaza’s health services; this dialogue has never been interrupted, even when 100 rockets a day were falling on Sderot and Ashkelon.

One of the Palestinian terrorists just exchanged for Gilad Shalit, Wafa al-Biss, was arrested before she used a permit for medical treatment in Israel to gain entry and blow up the hospital.

The political activism of such medical organizations severely damaged Israel’s reputation in the world. During the 2006 war in Lebanon, Red Cross employees in Tyre and Qana had fabricated an attack on an ambulance. A simple analysis of the photographs proved that the images used were those of an old ambulance damaged by rust and not by Israeli missiles and that a hole in the roof, actually in the middle of the cross (delicious symbolism,) was made by an artisan and not by an Israeli F16. And yet the Associated Press, Time, BBC, New York Times, Guardian and others had used this, together with Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, to accuse the Israeli army.

Today medical organizations such as the International Red Cross (which was shamelessly “neutral” and silent when it came to Nazi extermination camps during World War II) are anything but neutral when it comes to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Indeed, it’s much more fashionable to wear a white coat and accuse the Jewish state of “crimes against humanity.”

December 9, 2011 | 6 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest

Leave a Reply

6 Comments / 6 Comments

  1. I blame the jews. Instead of talking about peace, reconciliation and accmodation they should be focusing on injustices to the jews. There must be steps that can be taken to rebutting al these lies on an ongoin basis. hy doesn’t Israel write all the nations Red cross directorates worldwide and inform them of this, in my experience I dont believe they know. Why dont they approach red cross donors in US and europe; inform worldwide public. Perhaps there are legal steps that can be taken against the red cross, UN etc. Why is it we never hear of theses things except once in a while. Jews must stop accepting injustice as it it is just the normal course of events. Why is the red cross in israel or west bank. Give them ultimatum to cease anti semitism or get out. Stop being the “good guy” it is starting to appear masochistic.

  2. Magen David Adom is strictly an Israeli organization established, funded and maintained mostly by Jewish money for the benefit of Jews who live in the Jewish state.

    If all this is more or less the situation on the ground, why should any Jew, inside or outside of Israel, give even a minor damn about international recognition for it’s six-pointed Star of David symbol?

    When will all of you — Jews and non-Jews alike — come to understand that power to control a situation is everything, and that international recognition of that power is nothing whatsoever?

    Israel could quit the International Red Cross tomorrow, and no harm would befall the Jewish nation. For that matter, Israel could quit the UNO tomorrow, and save the embarrassment of having Jerusalem’s diplomats treated with the studied and purposeful discourtesies that one reserves for servants, recalcitrant children, and animals.

    Have none of you any sense of national dignity whatsoever?
    One more thing. Eliezer Ben-Yehuda, whose life work I count as more important to the Jewish nation than the scribblings of most of the rabbincal black hats who ever were born, re-assembled the Hebrew language as a living means of human communication for Jews and for anyone who wants to understand and communicate with Jews. Inseparable from his work and the concept behind it is the daily use of the Hebrew language. And inseparable from that is the use of the Hebrew alef-bet orthography.

    So why in hell is it necessary for the name “Magen David Adom” to be spelled out not only in Ivrit and “bli n’kudot”, but in latinic orthography as well? And for that matter, why did someone consider it necessary for street signs in Israel to be printed simultaneously in Ivrit, Latinic and Arabic? For the tourists? Let them learn enough tourist Ivrit to order felafel on a street corner and pay for their overpriced hotel rooms in Israeli currency. As for the Arabic on the street signs, just remove it. If the bastards want to continue to reside in eretz-yisrael, let them learn Ivrit. Just as all of you would be required to do if — for some crazy reason — you wanted to live in one of the raghead capitals amid the street-corner screamers.

    Either the land is yours, totally and without sharing it with any of the local goyim — all of whom hate your guts and wish you dead — or you have no rights to it whatsoever. Take your choice and live by it accordingly. Like any nation worthy of respect.

    Arnold Harris
    Mount Horeb WI

  3. I expect that the IRC will eventually want to replace the cross also with the crystal — or with the crescent, for that matter. The cross originally had a very Christian connotation, but today the organization is obviously anything but Christian — except for the fact that it’s mostly Christians who support it, which may explain why they still use the cross.

  4. Apparently the Red Cross only believes Jews when they receive confirmation from Nazis: On June 23, 1944, the Nazis permitted a visit by representatives from the Danish Red Cross and the International Red Cross in order to dispel rumors about the extermination camps. The commission included E. Juel-Henningsen, the head physician at the Danish Ministry of Health, and Franz Hvass, the top civil servant at the Danish Foreign Ministry. Dr. Paul Eppstein was instructed by the SS to appear in the role of the mayor of Theresienstadt.[15]

    To minimize the appearance of overcrowding in Theresienstadt, the Nazis deported many Jews to Auschwitz. Also deported in these actions were most of the Czechoslovakian workers assigned to ‘Operation Embellishment.’ They also erected fake shops and cafés to imply that the Jews lived in relative comfort.
    Apparently the Red Cross only believes Jews if they receive confirmation from Nazis:
    The Danes whom the Red Cross visited lived in freshly painted rooms, not more than three in a room. These could possibly have included the homes of the “prominent” Jews of Theresienstadt who were afforded special privileges whereby as little as two people shared a single room.[7] The guests enjoyed the performance of a children’s opera, Brundibar, which was written by inmate Hans Krása.

    Apparently the Red Cross representatives were easily fooled by the Germans as the tour was conducted by following a pre-determined path designated by a “red line” on a map. The hapless Red Cross apparently didn’t attempt to divert from the “official” tour route as led by the Germans who also posed questions to the Jewish residents along the way. If the Red Cross attempted to ask the residents questions directly, they were ignored and not answered. Despite this, the Red Cross still apparently formed a positive impression of the town.[7]

  5. Cornelio Sommaruga, then-head of the International Committee of the Red Cross, declared: “If we’re going to have the Star of David, why would we not have to accept the Swastika?”

    Why not draw the line at the Swastika instead of the Star of David? That would have been a good question for a working reporter, but only some like Meotti would ask such a question.

    Meotti has done yeoman’s work by enumerating the successes of Israeli medicine in the service of everyone. With his article in hand, it will not be possible to propagandize the world as to the evils of the Jews. We cannot force the MSM to print his work, but we should not gainsay the value of having such an article in print for future generations who may be more rational and less hate-filled.