It is time for logic to take over from US Jews’ ludicrous loyalty to the Democratic Party.
By Nurit Greenger, ISRAEL HAYOM
All too many American Jews just do not want to see the writing scrawled across every wall. The future of American Jews is not going to be with the Democratic Party.
This is a call to the Jewish brain left lobe, tasked to produce logic, especially for American Jewry.
Dr. Guy Bechor is a public opinion shaper in Israel and beyond. In his interview on April 30, 2019 on Israel’s Channel 7-GPlanet he had a message for American Jewry: “Democratic-Jews will bring catastrophe to American Jewry. Some of the Democrat Jews are becoming extremely anti-Israel. They are the Jewish people’s enemies and are more dangerous than Iran.”
No rosy future for the United States’ Jews. Bechor’s explains why Jewish logic must take over from the Jews’ ludicrous loyalty to the Democratic Party.
Historically, at the end of the 19th century, Jews in Europe believed that America was the “Jewish problem’s” solution. A large number of Jews emigrated to the “golden land.” In the early 2oth century, over 3 million Jews lived in the United States while in Israel only 60,000. Today, Israel counts some 7 million Jews and USA Jewry counts only 5.5 million.
The disbelief turned into reality. At first, hardly anyone believed the Zionist idea was logical as if it was suggesting to establish a colony on Mars. Consequently, until 20-30 years ago, the United States was the Jewish people’s center and Israel the periphery. Today, Israel is the Jewish nation’s center and American Jewry is the fringe. Over one million more Jews live in Israel than in the United States.
“This bothers quite a few Progressive Jews. What they did may be forbidden to talk about but here, in Israel, we tell the truth,” Bechor ventures into an arena where Jews hide.
The Jews in the USA lived safely in the Democratic Party. It is their political heaven.
One may ask, how did the Jews come to be part of the Democratic Party when it is the slavery party, the KKK that was the Democratic Party’s assault unit, and its racial segregation?
The answer is in the late US President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, a socialist who established the Minorities Alliance, and in it, he included the Jews, African-Americans, some Hispanics, and Catholics. The Jews, seeking to be protected, felt that America was theirs, the new alliance is their safety net.
However, in recent years, on the demographic level, a dramatic shift is occurring. Jews’ number is declining, their birth rate is negative and there is a 70% assimilation rate among them. Bechor suggested to the Jewish Agency to bring American Jews to Israel, otherwise they are going to disappear.
On the other hand, the number of Muslims in the US is rising. They count now 5 million and Jews 5.5 million and the Muslims’ number continues to rise while the number of Jews stagnates or drops.
The outcome, a shift in the Democratic Party. It seeks Muslim power vote to replace Jewish support. Just as with the British Labour Party and Europe. The Jews’ Democratic Party grounds have been shaken. For instance, the resolution brought to vote in the House to condemn Rep Ilhan Omar for her blatant antisemitism was not backed by the Democrats and thus did not pass.
Consequently, a small number of Jews will move to join the Republican Party, a small part will not vote and a large part is becoming a virulent and extremely anti-Israel.
Just as in the 19th century, Jews had to convert to Christianity to be accepted into the society, today, in the US you must be anti-Israel in order to be part of Democrats’ communities.
One may ask, how does this fit with President Trump’s empathy for Israel? This discussion’s central point is, the Jews who hate Jews.
The like of J Street, the New York Times that has only terrible things to say about Israel, Thomas Friedman and Peter Beinart. Not only do they hate Israel, they are Israel’s enemies and they are more dangerous to Israel than Iran. They also hate President Trump and incite against him.
All those who lead the lie, fake, Russian collusion conspiracy are Jews. Their names stand out. President Trump’s supporters will question, what is going on? Those Americans who voted for Trump would say, “There is a Jewish conspiracy against my President.”
Those Progressive Jews will bring upon the American Jewry a terrible disaster. That is exactly what happened in Europe and now is happening in the US. These Jews do not understand the magnitude of the ingathering disaster.
The Good American Jews, some 2-3 million, who are supportive of Israel, should rise up against those Progressives Jews who have become the unwelcomed changes in the United States’ spearhead, abandoning basic values of family structure, nationalism and religion. Some of the Trump supporters are angry at the Progressive Jews and they find their revenge by attacking Jews, sadly, the ‘good Jews’ in the Chabad center or a Synagogue.
Britain’s Jews thought that the Labour Party was their sanctuary. Now they are planning to leave. Already in 2000 Bechor spoke about the Jews in France having to leave, but was told he was hallucinating. Now it is the consensus.
Bechor’s forecast for the US Jews, [probably] they will be forced to leave. And to where will they leave? Destination, Israel.
Israel has the Law of Return in which Section 2B says that the law does not apply to Jews who harm the Jewish people. This law therefore should not apply to those Progressive Jews who are harming Jews. Every Progressive Jew should know and understand that if he or she supported BDS (Boycott, Divest, Sanction) organizations against the state of Israel, they will not have entry to the Jewish state. This should be clear.
The question is, on whom will Israel rely if not the American Jews?
In the United States there are some 100 million Evangelical Christians. They are good Americans, they love Israel’s authenticity, Jerusalem and the Israeli patriotic spirit. They are Israel’s alliance partner with the Conservative Americans and the Republican Party to which more and more Jews will have to move, just as it is happening in Britain.
Yes, a gloomy forecast brought upon the Jews by themselves. American Jews should join President Trump and his Party to make America safe for all Americans. The state of Israel is capable of separating the wheat from chaff, sorting the valuable from the worthless.
Jews in name only, their behavior hinges only on a pseudo Tikun Olam , unable to stand for their own rights and good . Same story happened in more tragic circumstances with the judenrat leaders ( Rumkovsky ) , who submitted to the nazis in order to save their own skin . Speaking with those JINO , I feel they are fearful, their ” progressive ” ideas are an escape from reality .The coming crash of the US $ will precipitate resentment , social unrest , more attacks on jews and more calls from the actual judenrat opinion makers ( Tom Friedman- Peter Beinart – Seth Rogen – JStreet ..) to bend the jews necks under the assault of the ” progressive ” anti-semites .
Very sobering but real picture of the fall of Jewish Diaspora.
The Liberal, progressive , reformist or whatever shade of left they wish to identify with virus has spread out of American and UK to Australia equally.
Our Liberal progressives who support J street, NIF , Beinart , Meretz , Breaking the Silence etc will have us believe they are all Zionists . Of course their idea of zionism . They have become nothing more than useful idiots and in my view since Trump has been elected adding fuel on the anti-Semitism fire and aligned with BLM , antifa , Muslim Brotherhood and defunding of the Police . These Jews have become divisive , radical and a liability to Jewish diaspora and Israel .
Indeed! The “Tree of LIfe” synagogue killer said that he hated Jews to begin with but was provoked to murder by this Progressive congregation’s support for Muslim and illegal immigration. Jews should not be at the forefront of issues that don’t particularly pertain to us but which are liable to provoke a violent response from left or right against our entire community.
Bravo Nurit! your article is an eye opener to thoese willing to see the reality, of what can and will happen should self hating-delusional Jews support a democratic victory in November. Let us hope they will come to theie senses before it is too late. I say: if you love your children, love Trump or hate him VOTE FOR HIM YOU MUST!
Pew estimated a few years ago that about a quarter of the US population was evangelical. 100 mill seems high, I often see the figure of 80 mill as being the approximately correct number..
As for the 5.5 mill Jews mentioned, many of them are not halachically Jewish, so even an estimate of 2-3 mill “good” Jews, may be closer to 2 than to 3.
The other salient points of the article are those with which I strongly agree. The American Jews had better make up their minds in fairly quick order. It is shameful to Jews, real Jews, that the names of Trump’s persecutors are predominantly Jewish- even if they are not practicing, nor even real Jews. Trump, the Best American President for Israel in history, a life-long friendship for Israel, of both his father and himself..
An excellent article.