Doctors attack the Health Ministry’s coronavirus combating policy

As an alternative, the group of doctors offered to keep the older population safer and to allow more freedom to Israel’s youth.

By Tobias Seigal, JPOST JULY 19, 2020 20:26

A woman reacts as a doctor wearing a protective glove takes a swab to test for coronavirus disease (COVID-19) at a residential area in Srinagar (photo credit: REUTERS/DANISH ISMAIL)
A woman reacts as a doctor wearing a protective glove takes a swab to test for coronavirus disease (COVID-19) at a residential area in Srinagar (photo credit: REUTERS/DANISH ISMAIL)

Dozens of Israeli doctors have signed a petition claiming that the current policy implemented by the Health Ministry will lead Israel to an economic collapse, according to N12.

The doctors also claimed that the policy has no chance of succeeding in any way and actually causes an increase in morbidity and death rates. As an alternative, the group of doctors offered to keep the older population safer and to allow more freedom to Israel’s youth.

The signatories, including 130 doctors who are officially registered with the Health Ministry, have signed an independent petition in recent days that has been circulating in social media. It heavily criticizing the government’s policy for managing the coronavirus crisis. The doctors insist that the current policy is useless, going so far as to say that it “will cause an economic disaster and promote the human suffering of millions of Israel’s population.”

In the petition, which was initiated by a doctor from central Israel, the doctors explain that their conclusions from the past few months are that all resources and efforts should be focused at treating and protecting the older, more sensitive population, as the majority of patients in serious condition are exclusively elders or people with underlying conditions. The petition also noted in this regard that the younger, healthier patients are usually those presenting no or barely any symptoms.

The petition also concluded that a majority of the population should be allowed to return to their normal lives, stating that young people will be infected and gradually develop immunity, with no major morbidity or death rates. The petition claimed that in this way, a severe economic crisis can be prevented, and the pandemic can be put to an end, as herd immunity will naturally prevent the virus from spreading.

According to the doctors who signed the petition, “The voices of many doctors who oppose the government policy have been silenced and ignored,” leading the Health Ministry to prevent any discussion on an alternative strategy.

“Enormous amounts of resources are being directed towards lockdowns, epidemiological inquiries and groundbreaking surveillance methods that target the healthy young population, who don’t pose a threat of developing a serious illness, and only lead to their economic demise,” the petition read.

The petition ends with a slogan that reads, “Coronavirus is easy on the youth – Protect the elderly!” – summarizing the message that it bears. The petition initiator has called upon the Health Ministry to invite the doctors who are signed on the petition to either meet with the health minister or with members of the coronavirus committee, and to allow them to represent those who’ve been dealing with the virus on the ground.

July 20, 2020 | 1 Comment » | 287 views

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest

1 Comment / 1 Comment

  1. SomeAmerican doctors have their doubts about whether our disease-control bureaucrats are giving us accurate figures about COVID-19 illnesses and deathis. This is from an article in today’s American Thinker By. Dr. Brian C. Joondeph, who describes himself as a Denver-based physician:

    “Context includes what defines a positive COVID test. Is it an actual positive antigen test result or a presumed positive case? Some counties in Texas were classifying a neighbor or co-worker of a test-positive case, suffering from a cough or sore throat, as having COVID, even without an actual test.

    This could result in 10 to 20 additional reported positive cases based on only one actual case. Antibody test-positive individuals, having previous, but not current active infections, are also positive cases. That would be like classifying retired military members as active duty.

    Context also includes asking whether these individuals are symptomatic or not. We never test asymptomatic individuals or contacts of those with the seasonal flu. In fact, most with the flu treat it symptomatically until they get better, and do not get tested unless they are sick enough to journey to the hospital. Asymptomatic individuals exposed to someone with the flu certainly don’t get tested. Why then is there such a push for COVID testing? Unless the goal is inflated numbers to fuel a media narrative and damage President Trump.

    Congressional candidate Jessi Melton tweeted about a friend of hers who went to a lab for a COVID test but couldn’t wait for the test and left, receiving a call later telling her she tested positive. Numerous labs in Florida are only reporting positive test results, not the negatives, giving the impression that everyone in the state is infected with the Wuhan virus.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*