Mideast peace a pipedream

Op-ed: Radical Muslim minority powerful enough to ensure peace never takes root

Avi Yesawich, YNET

A dubious conference that was scantly reported in the Western media took place in Iran this week, one that should serve as an unambiguous warning sign for proponents of the two-state solution and the prospects for establishing a lasting peace in the region.

The 5th International Conference for Defending the Palestinian Intifada wrapped up this past Sunday, and, like Tehran’s previous Holocaust conferences, boasted a relatively impressive number of high-ranking politicians and scholars from nations around the world. The motto for this year’s conference? “Palestine, home of the Palestinians.”

Hamas Politburo Chief Khaled Mashaal made clear that the two-state solution is invalid. “Palestinians must resort to resistance no matter how costly it is, until Palestine is free and Israel is destroyed.”

Islamic Jihad Secretary General Ramadan Abdullah Mohammad Shallah stated, “We regard the Zionist regime as an occupier which has no legitimacy and is declining in importance.” Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad declared that “effort must be made to free every span of the lands of this country from the Quds occupying regime (Israel),” calling for the “Zionist occupiers of Palestine” to return to their lands of origin.

Although several disturbing mantras emerged at the conference, the statements above reflect a more threatening, overarching reality: A powerful, belligerent conglomeration of forces continues to object to Israel’s presence, no matter the arrangement the country holds with its neighbors. It would be wise to consider what potential effects these forces could have on the region’s long-term future, and on Israel’s political and security situation.

Proponents of the two-state solution need to understand the serious barrier this minority poses to finding an equitable solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Perhaps these elements are a “minority” on the world stage, but that minority is sizable and powerful enough to ensure that a fair and peaceful solution is never achieved.

Iran has declared publicly on several occasions that, even if a comprehensive peace agreement were to be reached between Israel and the Palestinians, the country would never recognize Israel. Iran’s’ supreme leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, dismissed Abbas’ statehood bid as it would recognize the “cancerous tumor” as a legitimate entity. He completely dismissed the two-state solution as an acceptable option, even if the Palestinians themselves support the initiative and reach a compromise with Israel.

Likelihood of peace slim

Recognition of and normalization of relations with Israel was a critical point of attraction ostensibly offered by many Arab states in the 2002 Saudi-sponsored Arab Peace initiative, Unfortunately, the plan received meager or no support from the nations and government entities that pose the biggest military threats to Israel in the region.

Powerful elements and leading figures in Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria and Iran, the four entities considered to be the most hostile towards the existence of the Jewish State, have often and repeatedly expressed the position that, regardless of a future compromise between Israelis and Palestinians, their hostile demeanor won’t dissipate. Each of these entities will continue to use “resistance” until the “Zionist entity is eradicated.”

If we look at recent polls, such as the 2011 Democracy Index, we see strong indicators that Israeli-Arab peace seems to be a real possibility. For example, the majority of Palestinians have signaled that they accept a two-state solution. However encouraging that may be, Israel and the international community would be foolish not to take into consideration the extremely hostile minority that will continue to oppose Israel’s existence based on religious and political ideology.

Unfortunately, even if an agreement were reached now in the best of intentions of all parties involved, the likelihood of achieving a true, lasting peace is still very slim, simply because the “minority” that opposes the peace process and recognition of Israel happens to comprise a group of well-financed, well-armed, politically capable elements and nations whose formidable ideology and influence aren’t susceptible to sanctions, international isolation, or the democratic process.

Furthermore, as Egypt and Jordan have seen an increase in anti-Israel sentiment in the wake of the Arab Spring, calls for democratic reforms will most likely provide a platform for Islamic organizations to ascend to power, complicating regional relations with Israel and destabilizing the region even further.

The above realization needs to be emphasized in the strongest possible terms in all political circles and public relations efforts, especially to entities that seek to impose their own will on our region and force our hand in the Arab-Israeli conflict.

While peace may be established with the majority of our Arab neighbors, radical elements such as those gathered at the Tehran conference will continue to rise up against Israel through violence.

Avi Yesawich is an independent journalist and political commentator on Middle East affairs. He holds degrees from Cornell University and Tel Aviv University, is an IDF combat reservist and co-founder of www.israelicentrism.com

October 16, 2011 | 4 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest

Leave a Reply

4 Comments / 4 Comments

  1. H. Bendor writes:
    Well as much as I want to believe that Peace will prevail in the region…

    Why would you believe such nonsense? Haven’t you read the founding charters of Hamas, Hezbollah, Fatah and PLO which all refuse to accept Israel as a Jewish state, demand a right of return, demand East Jerusalem – then to top it off, vow to wipe Israel off the map.

    JUDEA & SAMARIA are clearly and unquestionably JEWISH!

    Based on what? This is pure emotion. Even the Israeli government considers J&S “negotiable”, which has then become the base premise.

  2. HB ,your CAPITALS express your emotional input!
    Emotion cannot be avoided – its part of any religious thought and certainly an expression of action
    Unfortunately our neighbours do not know or wish to know the difference between good and evil, truth and lie.
    As I have been told many a time by old-timers who have intimate knowledge of our Arab brethren, through language and living amongst them – they only kowtow to strength!
    There will a day when we shall have to adopt this method and I suspect for once the world WILL look on without doing anything – because basically the West tends to dislike the Arabs more than the Jews
    The Arabs have always let the West down – just look at past history

  3. re : Mideast peace a pipedream

    Well as much as I want to believe that Peace will prevail in the region… I bemoan the fact that most rhetoric and prophetic projections on this and other boards are based on emotional outbursts.
    I need to respect most contributors here together with their occasional outburst… they probably mean well… but somehow I can read through their qualified and articulate dissertations of history a tinge of the like of which is fortuitously disseminated… I am sure it is not from malice but simply from inexperience of the M.E. Theater.

    The M.E. where I was born and raised has to be analyzed from a pragmatic yet a patient and sedate attitude. The Arabs of the M.E. have a generous margin of 10% education in my country… they are motivated by the words of their Holy Book the Qur’an and NOTHING ELSE. The other 90% [functional illiterates] have acquired their beliefs in this so-called Holy Book by word of mouth and from father to son… the majority can parrot the Sura of the Qur’an without being able even to read it sometime. The Qur’an depicts the Jews and the Christians in a very negative fashion, and many Sura depict the Jews as descendent of Apes and Pigs…

    The implications here, is that the Arabs of the M.E. are an incited/deluded lot… and nothing in this world and I repeat NOTHING IN THIS WORLD will make them sway or bend to the realities of the day but cheer BRUTE FORCE.

    In fact the British were the only ones who knew this unguarded secret and they used it sparingly but effectively in their conquests.

    Israel wanting to show the world, how benevolent and generous it is, in its dealings with the Arabs of Palestine, has reaped an inverse result… the Arabs do not respect friendly gestures, they consider that a sign of weakness… In fact, the Israeli hierarchies have not as yet mastered this, and are paying dearly for their education.
    JUDEA & SAMARIA are clearly and unquestionably JEWISH!

  4. I would say peace is impossible. The vast majority of Arabs and Iranians want to wipe Israel off the map. They haven’t done it yet because its too expensive to do it today. But that doesn’t mean they’re going to give up. This is a not a problem Israel can solve through abject surrender to Islamic terrorists.