The Jordan Valley Is Not Up for Negotiation
By Maj. Gen. (res.) Gershon Hacohen, BESA
BESA Center Perspectives Paper No. 1,422, January 26, 2020

Jordan Valley, photo by Cycling Man via Flickr CC
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The Jordan Valley, in its full scope and broadest definition, is essential to Israel’s national security. Its retention by Israel requires not only military deployment but a comprehensive development plan—i.e., the construction of housing, roads, and infrastructure—that will establish this territory as Israel’s eastern wing.
Three fundamental questions help to clarify the positions voiced over the past few days on the possible annexation of the Jordan Valley:
- How wide does the Jordan Valley need to be to serve a security purpose? Does it need to run only from the Jordan crossings to Highway 90, or should it extend over 15 km west as envisaged by Yitzhak Rabin in his last speech to the Knesset?
- Is Israel’s need for the Jordan Valley conjectural or circumstantial, and therefore open to negotiation, or is it a basic and permanent requirement for Israel’s security?
- How does this area of ??land fit into an overall national outline for the construction of localities, roads, and infrastructure, to serve as Israel’s eastern wing?









