T. Belman. As a former Canadian, and son of a Polish father whose family supported the Communist revolution in 1917, I see things differently. I have always had a soft spot for Russia, though I was well informed about all the atrocities committed by Stalin and about the Jewish refusniks. I believe that Americans can’t shuck their cold war mentality. Having said that , I worried when the USSR was thought to be close to dominating the west. I certainly did not want them to succeed.
I think that Russia had every right to annex Crimea seeing that it used to be part of their empire and 80% of the people spoke Russian. I also didn’t mind when Russia made moves on the eastern part of the Ukraine. Surely, within their sphere of influence, they are entitled to do what other great powers do, extend their influence.
Finally I see nothing wrong in Russia’s support of Assad. They appear to be a moderating force. Contrast this with the the invasion of Iraq by the US. What a disaster that was.
Having said all that, there is much to be said regarding their weakness. They are in great economic difficulties and their very low fertility rate is dooming them in the future.
H. Laitin. WHEN I WAS ACTIVE IN STUDIES OF THE SOVIET UNION THIS ARTICLE WOULD’VE HIT THE NAIL ON THE HEAD. SINCE THEN , SO MUCH HAS NOT CHANGED. EVERYONE THAT I HAVE MET THAT HAS BEEN INVOLVED WITH THE TRUMP CAMPAIGN AND/OR THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION REGARDS PUTIN AS A RUTHLESS EXTENSION OF THE FORMER SOVIET RULING CLASS.
By Emil Avdaliani, BESA
In discussions of international affairs, it has become commonplace for Western observers to view Russia as a declining power, destined to succumb to a string of domestic and foreign problems that have beset it for some time.
To begin with, Russia’s 2014 conquest of Crimea and its support for the Ukrainian separatists backfired in grand style as Kiev, Moldova, and Georgia signed EU association agreements and stepped up military cooperation with NATO members and other western states. Similarly, while remaining the predominant military power in Central Asia, with bases in Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan, Russia has lost its economic preeminence in the region to China, which has also made important military inroads by holding joint exercises with the Tajik and Kyrgyz armed forces. No less importantly, Moscow is still reeling from the impact of Western sanctions, which are unlikely to be lifted any time soon, while its attempt to foment far-right populism across Europe has thus far failed.
Read more…