Israel’s Oil Weapon


Seemingly out of nowhere, geopolitics have been all but turned upside down in the Middle East, thanks to the discovery of massive energy resources in Israeli territory.  As a nascent Oil Power, the Jewish State is only beginning to contemplate the new dynamics of influence available to it.

The world knows Vladimir Putin as President of Russia; however, to Putin’s official title, allow me to suggest a second appellation, unofficial, but no less descriptive:  Israel’s New Best Friend.  Until recently, one could characterize Russia’s position vis-à-vis Israel as, at best ambivalent:  cordial relations with Jerusalem on the one hand, while supplying weapons, nuclear technology and other assistance to her enemies on the other.

But Putin’s late June visit to Israel signaled, and was meant to signal, a sea-change in Russia-Israel relations — “sea” as in Mediterranean sea, where in 2009, 50 miles off the Israeli coast, geologists discovered “an estimated 8.3 tcf (trillion cubic feet) of highest-quality natural gas,” to be surpassed just a year later with the discovery of a second field, named Leviathan, of an additional 16 tcf, “making it the world’s biggest deep-water gas find in a decade” and causing Israel to go from “a gas famine to feast in a matter of months.”  Other estimates put the Leviathan reserves as high as 20 tcf.

Needless to say, these discoveries could not be more timely, coming at about the same time as the Muslim Brotherhood’s ascension to power and acts of sabotage in Egypt jeopardize the reliability of natural gas supplies to Israel from that country.  Who says that God does not retain a special place in his heart for His Chosen People?

But of more earthly, and material, concern than the Almighty’s mysterious affection for an ancient tribe of itinerant sheepherders, is Russian energy giant Gazprom’s love of lucrative gas extraction contracts with the Jewish state.  After all, oil and gas discoveries of such magnitude are about as rare as the sight of Vladimir Putin, praying at the Western, wall in a yarmulke.  Or taking the Palestinians’ side against the Israelis’ as energetically in the future as he has in the past.  For, as Jerusalem Post columnist Isi Leibler notes, while Putin “heads a country which has ties and provides weapons to some of [Israel’s] greatest enemies including Iran and Syria” and “tends to support the Palestinian position, both as a member of the Quartet and at the UN”,

[Putin’s] visit to Israel unquestionably sends clear signals.  Even recognizing major divergence of policies in relation to Iran and Syria, and that Putin’s tensions with the United States and interests in the Arab world preclude [Israel] from considering him a partner, it sends a message to the Arabs that Russia is not an enthusiastic ally in their efforts to undermine the Jewish state.

Or at least not while the rubles are flowing into Gazprom’s coffers, anyway.  But it’s not just the Benjamins (Netanyahu or $100 bills, take your pick).  Both countries share ambivalent and sometimes strained relations with Turkey; concerns about the dark side of the Arab Spring, the rise of the Muslim Brotherhood and Islamic fundamentalism; and concerns about events in Syria.

Some of Israel’s European critics might also want to rethink their anti-Israel stances and the barely disguised anti-Semitism that inspires them, or at least tone it down a bit should they want, at some future time, a piece of the Israeli oil-pie.  As Victor Davis Hansen asks, “Will Europe still snub Israel when it has as much oil, gas, and money as an OPEC member in the Persian Gulf?”  Well, I’m pretty sure they’ll want to, but as De Gaulle famously said, “France has no friends, only interests.”  I suppose we’ll find out soon enough whether France has no enemies, either.  In the meantime, Walter Russell Mead simply states the obvious when he says that ”

regardless of the simple economic impact, in different ways and different degrees the Gulf countries and Russia are going to lose a lot of the political advantages that their energy wealth now gives them.  They will have less ability to restrict supply and to manipulate prices than they have had in the past. Oil and gas are going to be less special when supplies are more abundant and more broadly distributed.

To which this writer would only add:  especially when a major source of these “more abundant and broadly distributed” supplies is a stable, democratic friend and ally.

And finally there is America.  For Russia, it’s the traditional East-West rivalry.  But for Israel, it is not so much America the country as it is her current, and hapless, president, Barack Obama and the Israel-hostile fellow travelers who populate his administration.  For the first time since, perhaps, the Eisenhower administration, Israel has good reason, at least while Obama is in power, to question our reliability as an ally.  And Putin has an obvious incentive to exploit Jerusalem’s doubts by moving closer to Israel in the hope of creating a concomitant distance between Israel and the U.S.  Indeed, he may already be doing so (emphases below mine):

Putin’s arrival in the region must be viewed in contrast to President Obama, who has yet to visit Israel….  President Putin’s visit was clearly calculated to be the mirror image of Obama’s last visit to the region.  In a similar manner, while Obama chose to talk to Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas in his first overseas telephone call as president, Putin and Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu spoke on the phone immediately after Putin’s return to the presidency in May. […]

What’s more, not only did Putin begin his tour of the Middle East in Israel, he also made a point in visiting holy Christian and Jewish sites, while entirely skipping the Muslim shrines.  He met with Christian and Jewish religious leaders but avoided meeting any Muslim clergy.  Even when visiting the Palestinian Authority, Putin chose to come toBethlehem — a Christian site — rather than Ramallah.  Whereas Obama chose to reach out to Islam and the Palestinians during his famous 2009 speech in Cairo, Putin chose to appear as the defender of Christianity in the Middle East, outreaching to Judaism and playing down the Palestinian case.  […]

Indeed, when [Putin] insisted on negotiations instead of unilateral steps as the right path towards the resolution of the [Israeli-Palestinian] conflict, he practically endorsed Israel’s stance on the matter.

I mention the above as a cautionary note.  Israel has a lot more than oil to offer Russia — and China, and India — than oil.  She also has brainpower and all the technological prowess that goes along with it, and here I mean, especially, military technology, which, I think we all can agree, our competitors and enemies would very much like to have.  What Israel does not have a lot of, is money.  But Russia, India and, especially, China, have oodles of the stuff, much of it formerly ours.  And I would not count the Israelis themselves out, either:  as more and more Israeli energy exporting infrastructure comes online, and the revenues start flowing in, Israel might, one day, have substantial funds of her own to put in the pot.  Yes, Israel loves us — but do they love us enough to commit national suicide for us?  Israel is a tiny country, surrounded by enemies both potential and real, and like any country in such a situation, relies on alliances and partnerships with larger ones.  Which country, or countries, one allies with, however, is of considerably lesser importance when survival is the issue and let’s be brutally honest, here.  If you were Benjamin Netanyahu, and Barack Obama were your ally, would you want to put all of your alliance eggs in one basket?

So as he continues to lambaste Israel on the one hand, while schmoozing Israel’s rivals and enemies on the other, and assuming that an Israeli-designed anti-missile missile could shoot down an American missile as well as it can an Arab — or Chinese, or Russian — one, President Obama might wish to ponder the geopolitical implications of the day, if it ever comes, that the Israelis decide that they don’t need us anymore.

But we were talking about oil, about how the new Israeli discoveries make Israel, for the first time in her history, both energy-independent and an increasingly desirable ally and partner for any number of rich, powerful and above all, energy-hungry, countries.  So let’s look at the military implications of Israel’s emergence as an “energy superpower” and how her energy independence can benefit not just her, but us, too.

Many of us older folks remember well the Arab oil embargo of 1973, Sheik Yamani, a sweater-clad Jimmy Carter turning down the thermostat in the White House and, above all, the breathless anticipation with which the world would await the result of each price-setting meeting of the then-all powerful (or at least so it seemed) Arab oil cartel.  Fortunately, we haven’t heard from the cartel in a while and with an oil-rich Israel more than happy to help her Western friends — and hurt her Arab (and Venezuelan) enemies — by ramping up her own production to offset any lost production from production reductions elsewhere, we may never hear from them again.

But of course, any introduction of new supply will push oil prices down everywhere and reduce revenues for everyone.  Including, of course, Iran.  So if you’re Israel, with an enemy as implacable — and oil-revenue dependent — as Iran, why wait for an embargo?  Why not flood the world with as much oil, as fast, and as cheaply, you can?  Need oil, mister?  Oy, have I got a deal for you….

And finally, regarding Iran, there is the military application:  Iran’s nuclear facilities are hidden deep underground, but her oilfields are not.  Most, if not all, of Iran’s oil production infrastructure is above ground, vulnerable to attack and, oh, by the way, oil is extremely flammable.  By impairing Iran’s oilfields, which the Israeli air force probably could do, Israel could bring the Iranian economy, and the Mullahs who rule it, to its and their knees.  Indeed, one can only assume that the only reason the Israelis haven’t already done so is the predicted effect on oil prices and the predictable cries of outrage from the “international community” guaranteed to arise therefrom.  But with Israel ready, willing and able to replace any lost Iranian oil in quantities sufficient to keep world oil prices stable or even lower…?

Since the destruction of the First Temple by the Babylonians in 586 B.C., through centuries of conquest, revolt and exile, Jews have dreamed of — and fought for, and died for — the day when a restored, militarily strong, truly independent Israel would rise and resume her rightful place among the nations of the world.

With Israel’s newfound energy supplies, and the will and wisdom to exploit those supplies to her advantage, that day may not be far off.


Gene Schwimmer is the pundit-proprietor of Schwimmerblog and the author of The Christian State.

Read more:

July 16, 2012 | 13 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest

Leave a Reply

13 Comments / 13 Comments

  1. @ drjb:
    The Ministry has informed us all, and that is solid as the Minister is Dr. Landau, a fellow Engineer and friend, that the only hurdle is the pipe line ports size at the receiving end. I have worked at the test station of that facility and know in person all I need to know. 8 months for full flow from Tamar and that is fine for our needs.
    All new electrical power stations and industrial complexes are designed to use natural gas. Even the oldest power station set up be British in Tel Aviv has been converted to use NG.
    We tested oil from the fields four years ago. I know that some minor extraction has been done since. Significant flow is expected, like reported, in two years.
    Export is the least of my interest. I want us to be independent from the enemies.
    The shale oil content is huge within Israel and the field extending into Jordan has been allocated by Jordan to Dutch firms. Jordan is advancing well on their side.
    So are we. I expect, based on reliable data, that in less than five years oil will be exported by us and at an increasing pace Israel will become a factor on the field.

    Canada is extracting from its tar sands a fabulous amount of oil and we will be doing from shale.

  2. SHmuel HaLevi Said:

    Israel has vast resources on hand and all of them viable in a relatively short term. Oil by 2014-15 and natural gas in about 8 months

    nothing that I`ve read makes even a remote suggestion that Israel could be producing considerable amounts of natural gas in 8 months (never mind to meet its needs). All i read are preliminary findings of huge reserves and some tenders for the rigs to drill with Noble, maybe Transocean or Slumberger, maybe a Canadian outfit too, being negotiated. As far as oil production is concerned, 5 years at a bare minimum.
    All of this would be subject to a strong, non-bureaucratic, business oriented government. Non of which applies to Israeli leaders and government. That`s why I say 10 years before these beautiful resources start making a difference in Israeli lives.

  3. @ Laura:

    Israel has ten times the oil reserves of Saudi Arabia and twenty times the natural gas potential of Algeria. Israel IS NOW THE ENERGY GIANT OF THE WORLD.

  4. Oil and gas.
    The article is eminently accurate. Opinions to the contrary to the relation of facts therein issued by people not intimately familiar on the subjects are at least silly but at times worse.
    For a significant period of time I worked on behalf of three firms involved on oil processing, from raw material to end products testing, IKA, PETROTEST and CANNON which sold specialized equipment to Israeli petroleum refineries facilities and other locations. Within “the trade” and among specialized experts, all very careful regarding sensitive data, things have been known for a long time.
    Israel has vast resources on hand and all of them viable in a relatively short term. Oil by 2014-15 and natural gas in about 8 months. I am not going to offer details but the published information is less explicit than the real data is.
    Truly our fields are vulnerable but so are those of the US, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Iraq, Russia, Venezuela and so forth…
    Israel will never harm others unless its vital interests would be harmed in which case woe to anyone trying that route.
    Conclusively Israel can be a strong player in those fields… IF we are led by strong leaders. On this we have dreadfully little depth.

  5. Misleading story.

    Shame on Gene Schwimmer. Israel’s oil and gas finds are not significant, and shale is difficult to extract. This is possible future prediction, not the current situation. Dreaming.

    It’s better for Israel to be at the forefront of technology rather than become an oil power. Natural resources make a country vulnerable to hostile and powerful neighbors taking over.

  6. I disagree with both of you.

    Putin is more reliable a leader of Russia that the snake-face who now runs America. My own memory of dealings with the Soviet Union and the present Russian Republic is that they generally stick to the letter of agreements they make, but where there is a loophole somewhere, they will take advantage of it in their own self-interest. But show me where the USA, Europe or the UNO ever keep any agreement they made with the Jews in general or the State of Israel in particular.

    I’m a loyal American who served in our armed forces for three years, back in the Korean War years. But I know for a fact that Washington and its overseas toadies have persistently worked to undercut Israel’s sovereignty and not infrequently, Israel’s defensive safety needs. There was for example the period in May 1967, when Washington conveniently lost or forgot the agreement that Eisenhower made with Ben-Gurion to get Zahal withdrawn from the Sinai peninsula 10 years earlier. And while the days rolled into weeks, the Egyptian army mobilized and moved eastward through the Sinai.

    I never trusted this government since that time, and I probably never will.

    Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.

    Arnold Harris
    Mount Horeb WI

  7. When I think of Putin I think of an evil manipulator who is an active party to mass murder in Syria. He is no friend of Israel. I hope that Israel will never make the mistake of assuming that ANY foreign government can be fully trusted. There may be temporary exceptions such as Canada but time passes and leaders change. Jews should remember that it is only G-d that can and should be trusted and never a fallible human being.

    Israel also has the potential to obsolete oil entirely if they ever wake up and realize that the most advanced energy technologies already exist and have been suppressed for years. Click on
    and see a list of suppressed energy inventors and the many U.S. government agencies that are guilty of suppression. Once oil becomes obsolete the Arabs, Russia, even the U.S. under Obama, and all others hostile to Israel will suffer a decisive blow.