The Fourth Way is the Best Way – Voluntary Relocation  

By Israel Zwick, CN Publications, June 6, 2007

In his op-ed column in the NY Times on June 6, 2007, Thomas Friedman made some astute observations about the prospects for Arab-Israeli peace. The article was aptly titled, “What a Mess.” Friedman noted that the three methods that were tried so far have all failed. Land for peace, favored by the Left was discredited by the failure of Oslo. Permanent occupation, favored by the Right, was rendered impossible by Palestinian militancy. The third way, unilateral withdrawal, was discredited by the debacles in Lebanon and Gaza. So the solution to the mess can only come about via a still undetermined “fourth way.”
Read more…

June 6, 2007 | 4:34 pm | 10 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Sarkozy and Israel  

By Armand Laferrere, EURSOC

In a speech to the Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs, Armand Laferrere said that Nicolas Sarkozy’s Presidency will represent a strong change for the better for French foreign policy, particularly where Israel is concerned.

[..] I speak as a Frenchman who was always convinced that a strong alliance with the United States and support for Israel are not only geo-political necessities, but moral imperatives as well. I also speak as a former advisor to the current President, and a personal friend of several members of the new ruling team. Because I know these people, not just because of the of the election result, I am more optimistic about my country than I ever was.

However, this election does change one very important thing: I can’t even begin to tell you how good it feels to know today that I speak for a majority of the French people. A considerable majority – in a traditionally 50/50 country – elected President Sarkozy on May 6, with a historically high turnout of 86%. If polls are to be believed, an even greater majority is about to give him an even stronger mandate in next week’s general election. The Presidential party is now leading by up to 15 points – which could translate into gaining up to three quarters of the seats in Parliament.
Read more…

June 6, 2007 | 2:29 pm | Comments Off on Sarkozy and Israel

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

“Land for Peace” is a failed strategy  

By Ted Belman

Nothing should be taken for granted. Neither Resolution 242 nor the proposed “land for peace” trade off.

On June 5th 1967, Israel, under great threat of an imminent attack, had no choice but to defend itself. And defend itself, it did. Six days later Israel found itself in possession of what was left of the British Mandate after Jordan was removed from it.

Israel made two fateful policy decisions;

    1. Rather than annex the lands pursuant to its rights under the British Mandate, Israel offered to return much of the land for peace.

    2. Rather than to obliterate the al Aksa Mosque which sits on the Temple Mount, Israel took down the flag of Israel and turned its management over to the Muslim Wakf.

To no avail. The Arabs, meeting three months later at Khartoum, decided on no negotiations, no recognition and no peace.

Israel clearly wanted peace not land and the Arabs wanted land (Israel’s destruction), not peace.

Had Israel decided otherwise on both accounts, history would have been rewritten in Israel’s favour. There may not have been a formal peace but a defacto peace.
Read more…

June 6, 2007 | 10:44 am | 4 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The birth of the US/Israel alliance  

By Ted Belman

“What kind of an Israel do you want the Arabs to live with, and what kind of an Israel do you want the American people to support?”

In the aftermath of the Six Day War in which the US declared a neutral position but in fact helped the Arabs, PM Levi Eskol lead a delegation to President Johnson, cap in hand, asking for American Phantom planes.

Yehuda Avner, who was on the staff of five prime ministers, including Levi Eshkol, recounts the fascinating discussion in On the seventh day

Evidently, despite the glorious victory six months earlier, the Soviets were resupplying the Arabs at an enormous clip and Israel was weaker vis a vis the Arabs than before the war. France who had been Israel’s arms supplier had announced an arms embargo and Israel had no one to turn to but the previously neutral, if not hostile, US.
Read more…

June 6, 2007 | 7:16 am | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

SIX DAY WAR  

Six Day War Revisionist History

Yid with a Lid compares Time Magazine’s account of the Six Day War dated June 16/67 with Time’s current retrospective. [You should too.]

Reading reports about the war from 40 Years ago and today reminds me of one of those Star Trek episodes where Kirk an the boys go back in history and change the past—it seems like two different wars.

Forty years ago the reports spoke of the underdog Israel and her need to defend herself against the warlike acts of the big bullies lead by Egypt who was committing many acts that could be interpreted as acts of war including: conspiring with other belligerent countries (in this case, Syria and Jordan) for a coordinated attack, closing Israel’s access to international waterways (the straits of Tiran),volating the terms of the 1956 armistice by re-militarizing the Sinai. Expelling the UN and USA peace-keeping troops form the Sinai, perpetrating illegal spy-plane fly-overs to reconnoiter Israeli sensitive areas. Massing troops and tanks on Israel’s borders.
Read more…

June 5, 2007 | 4:29 pm | Comments Off on SIX DAY WAR

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Israel alone won the War  

With the media awash in Six Day War revisionism, Mitchell Bard notes for the record,

FACT

The United States tried to prevent the war through negotiations, but it could not persuade Nasser or the other Arab states to cease their belligerent statements and actions. Still, right before the war, President Johnson warned: “Israel will not be alone unless it decides to go alone.”1 Then, when the war began, the State Department announced: “Our position is neutral in thought, word and deed.” 2

Moreover, while the Arabs were falsely accusing the United States of airlifting supplies to Israel, Johnson imposed an arms embargo on the region (France, Israel’s other main arms supplier, also embargoed arms to Israel).

By contrast, the Soviets were supplying massive amounts of arms to the Arabs. Simultaneously, the armies of Kuwait, Algeria, Saudi Arabia and Iraq were contributing troops and arms to the Egyptian, Syrian and Jordanian fronts.3

June 5, 2007 | 6:37 am | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Pipes on the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process  

Testimony by Daniel Pipes, Director of the Middle East Forum & Distinguished visiting professor, Pepperdine University before U.S. House Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Middle East and South Asia February 14, 2007, 2:30 p.m.

What next in Israeli-Palestinian negotiations, which some call the “peace process”?

I shall argue three points:

    – that these negotiations have been so counterproductive, they could better be called the “war process”;
    – that their failure results from an Israeli conceptual error fifteen years ago about the nature of warfare; and
    – that the U.S. government should urge Jerusalem to forego negotiations and return instead to its earlier policy of deterrence.


Reviewing the “Peace Process”

[My earlier post challenging Daniel Pipes to take a position was entirely wrong as this testimony indicates. Clearly he rejects the peace process and negotiations until the Palestinians are defeated, totally.]
Read more…

June 5, 2007 | 6:06 am | 28 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Polish girl’s Holocaust diary unveiled  

By ARON HELLER

JERUSALEM — The diary of a 14-year-old Jewish girl dubbed the “Polish Anne Frank” was unveiled on Monday, chronicling the horrors she witnessed in a Jewish ghetto – at one point watching a Nazi soldier tear a Jewish baby away from his mother and kill him with his bare hands.

The diary, written by Rutka Laskier in 1943 shortly before she was deported to Auschwitz, was released by Israel’s Holocaust museum more than 60 years after she recorded what is both a daily account of the horrors of the Holocaust in Bedzin, Poland and a memoir of the life of a teenager in extraordinary circumstances.

“The rope around us is getting tighter and tighter,” the teenager wrote in 1943, shortly before she was deported to Auschwitz. “I’m turning into an animal waiting to die.”

Within a few months Rutka was dead and, it seemed, her diary lost. But last year, a Polish friend who had saved the notebook finally came forth, exposing a riveting historical document.
Read more…

June 4, 2007 | 10:12 pm | Comments Off on Polish girl’s Holocaust diary unveiled

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The case for bombing Iran  

The U.S. and its allies face terrible consequences from a military attack on Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s nuclear facilities, but the alternative is worse

David Harris, Ottawa Citizen Special

When the United States strikes Iran — as it will — the result will be a disaster, but a disaster that cannot be avoided.

Today, Iran’s radical Islamist military, security and intelligence machine reflects the extremism of its history and entrenched masters. It has made Iran an engine of global instability and menace. For Iran today is on the verge of grasping the nuclear club, even as it remains an ungovernable influence in the international community.

Iran’s extremist and uncontrollable nature has been well defined through action.

Start with reports of early post-revolutionary Iran. Massacres of Baha’is and other minorities. Razor-blade removal of lipsticked lips. Thumbtacks affixing veils to reluctant women. Adolescent gays hanged from construction cranes. Human waves of nine-year-olds attacking Iraqi forces.
CONTINUE

June 4, 2007 | 7:50 pm | 5 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Why is US indirectly funding Hamas  

New PLO account disbursing millions

Khaled abu Toameh and AP, THE JERUSALEM POST Jun. 3, 2007

Donor funds have begun flowing into an account controlled by Palestinian Authority Finance Minister Salam Fayyad, effectively ending the international boycott of the Hamas-led government. The funds will be used to pay partial salaries to tens of thousands of PA civil servants.

Fayyad said Sunday that the new account, which had been set up to bypass an international boycott of the Hamas-led government, is a key step toward restoring relations between the Palestinians and donor countries.
Read more…

June 4, 2007 | 4:59 pm | 4 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Netanyahu: As long as we stay in West Bank we’re unbeatable  

‘Automatic assumption of withdrawal to 1967 borders is unjustified, immoral and very dangerous for the State of Israel,’ opposition leader tells conference marking Six Day War’s 40th anniversary

“We must set defendable borders which do not include an additional Arab population. I plan to try and reach such an agreement, which will be supported by Egypt and Jordan.”

Lilach Shoval, YNET

“Since the Six Day War the Arab world has been trying to get us off the mountains of Judea and Samaria, but as long as we are on this mountain, we are unbeatable,” opposition leader Benjamin Netanyahu said Monday.

Speaking at a conference held in the capital by the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs (JCPA) to mark the 40th anniversary of the Six Day War, Netanyahu said that “the Six Day War was a turning point in which we turned from a fetal and fragile country whose existence was questionable, into a state which cannot be defeated.”
Read more…

June 4, 2007 | 3:48 pm | 16 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

British Appeasement  

Dr Joseph Alexander Norland, the person who started Israpundit, wrote to Ms Hunt of UCU.
……………………………………………….

I am writing to you to protest the UCU boycott of Israel. By now, you have probably heard the reasons for objecting to the boycott numerous times. For this reason I will refrain from repeating the reasons and offer instead two personal observations. All the statements in the following paragraphs are substantiated by mountains of evidence, which I will be pleased to forward to you upon request.

Observation #1. In 1938, the government and the people of the UK engaged in a systematic campaign to appease a terrorist bully at the expense of a small, democratic republic. Need I specify that I am referring to Britain’s appeasement of Hitler and the resulting destruction of Czechoslovakia? Need I draw the obvious parallel between this historic record and the British appeasement of Arab terrorists at the expense of the democratic republic of Israel? Since the UCU boycott is part of this anti-Israel campaign of appeasement, I will repeat here what I tell my British acquaintances at every opportunity:
Read more…

June 4, 2007 | 10:19 am | 5 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Machiavelli and the Decay of Western Civilization  

Paul Eidelberg, NATIVE

Machiavelli is the father of Modernity and Democracy and the creator of Secular Man par excellence. His deceptively simple book The Prince, so often trivialized, marks the Copernican revolution in politics.1 In that sibylline work Machiavelli undertook the world-historical task of destroying nothing less than the two pillars of Western civilization, classical Greek philosophy and Christianity, whose ethics, whether derived from Nature or nature’s God, derogate from the complete autonomy of human will and desire.

The key to modernity will be found in Chapter 15 of The Prince.2 There Machiavelli lists ten pairs of qualities for which men, especially rulers, are praised or blamed – qualities which a ruler, “if he wishes to maintain himself,” must be able to “use” and “not use” “according to necessity.”3 Some rulers, he declares, “are held liberal, some miserly…[and/or] rapacious; some cruel, others full of pity; the one faithless, the other faithful; the one effeminate and pusillanimous, the other fierce and spirited; the one human, the other proud; the one lascivious, the other chaste; the one open, the other cunning; the one hard, the other easy; the one grave, the other light; the one religious, the other skeptical, and the like.” CONTINUE

June 4, 2007 | 9:12 am | Comments Off on Machiavelli and the Decay of Western Civilization

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

No salvation in Fatah  

Prof Barry Rubin, GLORIA, just published Palestinian Politics: “Good Guy Fatah vs. ‘Bad Guy’ Hamas” is No Policy Solution in which he concludes,

Here is the paradox: Money is given Fatah it is likely to be stolen, not used to improve the lives of Palestinians. Arms and military training given Fatah will be turned against Israel

Fatah is unwilling to challenge Hamas militarily or even to restrain it–and smaller radical groups–from terror attacks and rocket launching against Israel. It will either reject or not implement any promises it makes in this regard, as experience as repeatedly shown.

The correct response to this unpleasant situation is to decertify the Palestinian movement. Since it failed the test of the peace process, and events since then, and is now in the hands of a movement that opposed the peace process, there is no sense giving it the rewards based on pledges to do otherwise. As before 1993, the world must wait until there emerges a Palestinian movement that is truly ready to cease terrorism, negotiate seriously, and make a permanent peace with Israel. Such a movement would be offered great rewards but until then there is nothing to be gained by dealing with Fatah or Hamas.

To “decertify the Palestinian movement” is to abrogate Oslo.

June 4, 2007 | 9:02 am | Comments Off on No salvation in Fatah

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Cheney, Rice at Odds Over Iran  

NewsMax

[..] She continues, “Look, there’s always noise in any large system. But I want to say something about the vice president. You know, if he doesn’t agree, the vice president talks about it, just as if [Defense Secretary] Bob Gates doesn’t agree, or I don’t agree, we sit down and talk about it. And then if necessary we talk about it with the president and he decides … The vice president has never been somebody who tries to do that on the sidelines, behind the scenes. He really doesn’t.”

In a separate article, a Newsweek investigation shows that Cheney’s national-security team has been actively challenging Rice’s Iran strategy in recent months. “We hear a completely different story coming out of Cheney’s office, even now, than what we hear from Rice on Iran,” a Western diplomat whose embassy has close dealings with the White House, tells Newsweek. Officials from the veep’s office have been openly dismissive of the nuclear negotiations in think-tank meetings with Middle East analysts in Washington, according to a high-level administration official who asked for anonymity because of his position.
Read more…

June 3, 2007 | 10:39 pm | 2 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Who is Daniel Pipes?  

Daniel Pipes is arguably the most important voice on American/Islamic relations and the Middle East today.

Recently he was written up in this excellent article.

Radical Departure
Is the country’s most controversial Middle East scholar mellowing?

June 3, 2007 | 12:45 pm | 1 Comment »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The hidden tragedy: the Jews of the CIS (former Soviet Union)  

Ami Isseroff

An article in Ha’aretz draws attention to an all but forgotten corner and neglected tragedy of Jewish history. It is history that is happening right now, history that we can change. It is, in my opinion, as a largely ignorant bystander, a failure of the Zionist movement, the Israeli government, and the Jews of the United States and Western Europe.

The Jewish community of Greater Russia, which became the USSR and is now the C.I.S. (Confederation of (not-very) Independent States) was once the heart of the Jewish world, and the original mainspring of Zionism. At one time, it numbered over 5 million. Its people were the engine of the Zionist revival. Achad Ha’am, Ben-Gurion, Bialik, A.D. Gordon, Jabotinsky, Pinsker, Weizmann… the list is endless. This is the world that my grandparents and my great grand-parents, and those of many other Israelis left behind to come to “Eretz Yisroel” as it was known before 1917. These were the people who clamored most insistently for a Jewish National Home, and who were most insistent that that home had to be the land of Israel. Unlike the Jews of Germany or France, they had few illusions about a rosy future for Jews in the Diaspora, except for the communists among them. Confined to the pale of settlement, living in abject poverty, they knew that time was running out for them. Large numbers emigrated to the United States and a smaller number to Palestine, but most of the Jews of Russia were trapped inside the Soviet Union soon after 1917.
CONTINUE

June 3, 2007 | 10:28 am | 2 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

What if Israelis had abducted BBC man?  

By Charles Moore, The Telegraph

Watching the horrible video of Alan Johnston of the BBC broadcasting Palestinian propaganda under orders from his kidnappers, I found myself asking what it would have been like had he been kidnapped by Israelis, and made to do the same thing the other way round.

The first point is that it would never happen. There are no Israeli organisations – governmental or freelance – that would contemplate such a thing. That fact is itself significant.

But just suppose that some fanatical Jews had grabbed Mr Johnston and forced him to spout their message, abusing his own country as he did so. What would the world have said?
Read more…

June 3, 2007 | 8:07 am | 2 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

The Method in Their (Islamic) Madness  

MARK STEYN, Mid-East Truth

On the day the Royal Navy’s hostages were released, I chanced to be reading a poem from Reflections on Islam, a terrific collection of essays by George Jonas. The verse is by Nizar Qabbani, and it is his ode to the intifada:

    O mad people of Gaza,
    a thousand greetings to the mad
    The age of political reason
    has long departed
    so teach us madness

Or as the larky motto you used to find on the wall of the typing pool put it: You Don’t Have to Be Crazy to Work Here, but It Helps. For the madness of the intifada and the jihad and Islamist imperialism is calculated, and highly effective. There is, as Jonas sees it, method in their madness.

Do you remember that little difficulty a few months back over the Pope’s indelicate quotation of Manuel II? Many Muslims were very upset about his speech (or his speech as reported on the BBC et al.), so they protested outside Westminster Cathedral in London demanding “capital punishment” for the Pope, and they issued a fatwa in Pakistan calling on Muslims to kill His Holiness, and they firebombed a Greek Orthodox church and an Anglican church in Nablus, and they murdered a nun in Somalia and a couple of Christians in Iraq. As Tasnim Aslam of the Foreign Ministry in Islamabad helpfully clarified, “Anyone who describes Islam as a religion as intolerant encourages violence.” So don’t say we’re violent or we’ll kill you. As I wrote in National Review at the time, quod erat demonstrandum.
Read more…

June 2, 2007 | 9:10 am | 8 Comments »

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free

Peace-processing our way to disaster.  

By Ted Belman

I have long been against the “peace process” and wrote Repudiate the ‘peace process’ and annex Judea and Samaria and The ‘peace process’ is a bigger danger than Hamas and The Conspiracy to Shrink Israel

Now, Reuel Marc Gerecht, WEEKLY STANDARD has weighed in with Dangerous Illusions. He addresses both negotiations with Iran and with the PA.

[..] The West Bank and Gaza are increasingly convulsed by civil strife–in Iraq such violence is sometimes called “civil war”–yet many people, in government and out, think that an Israeli-Palestinian deal is still possible, provided Washington has the will to force Jerusalem to make concessions. Yet the Islamic fundamentalist movement Hamas has grown powerful electorally and militarily by advancing an uncompromising hostility to the existence of Israel. Fatah, the backbone of the now-defunct Palestine Liberation Organization and the political base on which the Bush administration and the Europeans want to build a Palestinian state living in peace with its Jewish neighbor, has grown noticeably more anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic.
Read more…

June 2, 2007 | 8:17 am | Comments Off on Peace-processing our way to disaster.

Subscribe to Israpundit Daily Digest for Free
« Previous Page — Next Page »