The high ground is indespensible to Israel’s security.
T. Belman. After receiving this email and article I didn’t know how to respond. The article was important because it made the point that every second counts and that the high ground should never be ceded. With that I fully agree. But the article seems to suggest that a New State in Sinai is preferable to a Palestinians state in J&S. That goes without saying but I do not believe it was proposed as an alternative. The high ground in J&S should never be given up regardless if a new state is proposed for Sinai.
I believe we should focus on getting the Gazans to emigrate rather than to provide more land to them or a port offshore etc. Our agenda should be to get them to leave.
A retired US intelligence officer who was active for many decades in the ME wrote to me, “You might want to publish this with your comment/evaluation”
Any proposal such as an offshore port for Gaza, a new state solution, etc. coming from an IDF planner, especially from the Air Force worries me.
I remember how arrogantly we were dismissed during the Lebanese incursion by the then IDF Chief of Staff who had been the former commander of the Air Force. We told him that he had only 25% as much time complete his operation as had been promised by Condoleezza Rice.
Further, his helter-skelter hit and withdraw tactics resulted in the loss of IDF lives and Hezbollah retaking control of the areas as soon as the IDF returned from its missions.
My personal insult was when the IDF on security grounds did not publish the wing camera photography showing Hezbollah launch crews firing from courtyards of apartment houses when the IDF was accused of attacking civilian targets and causing civilian casualties.
The New State Solution in a Region Where Seconds Count
In recent months, several senior security experts have expressed support for an alternative to Israel’s status quo with the Palestinians. The plan, known as the New State Solution, proposes joining a coastal section of the northern Sinai Peninsula to the territory of Gaza, forming an expanded P
Read more…




